Difference IPPF (2004) and (2017)
Difference IPPF (2004) and (2017)
“The purpose, authority, and “The purpose, authority, and responsibility Revise the internal audit charter
responsibility of the ointernal audit of the internal audit activity must be by considering the mission of
formally defined in an internal audit
activity must be formally defined in internal audit and the core
charter, consistent with the mission of
an internal audit charter, consistent internal audit and the mandatory principles for the professional of
with the standards, and approved by elements of International Professional internal auditing.
the board of directors. Separate Practices Framework (the core principles
implementation standards here for the professional of internal auditing,
state that internal auditing the code of ethics, the standards, and the
assurance and consulting services definition of internal auditing). The Chief
audit executive must perodically review
must be defined in the internal audit the internal audit charter and present it to
charter” senior management and the board for
approval”
1000.A1 - Purpose, Authority, and Responsibility
2004 2017 Implication
There is no explanation
1010 - Recognizing mandatory guidance in the internal audit carther
“the mandatory nature of the core Revise the internal audit charter
principles for the professional by considering the mission of
practice of internal auditing, the internal audit and the core
code of ethics, the standards, and principles for the professional of
the definition of internal auditing internal auditing.
must be recognized in the internal
There is no explanation audit charter. The chief audit
executive should discuss the mission
of internal audit and the mandatory
elements of the IPPF with senior
management and the board.”
1110.A1 - Organizational independence
There is no explanation
1112- CAE roles beyond internal auditing
There is no explanation
1130.A3 - Impairment to independence or objectivity
There is no explanation
1130.C2 - Impairment to independence or objectivity
“The CAE must effectively manage the internal The internal auditors are
audit activity to ensure it adds value to the
expected to have sufficient
organization.
Interpretation: analytical and research skills. The
•It achieves the purpose and responsibility internal audit activity must be
included in the internal audit charter integrated with organizational’s
“The CAE must effectively manage •It conforms with the standards strategies and objectives. The
•Its individual members conform with the
the internal audit activity to ensure code of ethics and the standards
internal auditors are expect to
it adds value to the enterprise” •It considers trends and emerging issues that play more roles in providing
could impact the organization consulting service.
The internal audit activity adds value to the
organization and its stakeholders when it
considers strategies, objectives, and risks;
strives to offer ways to enhance governance,
risk management, and control processes; and
objectively provides relevant assurance.”
2010.A1- Planning
2004 2017 Implication
“The chief audit executive must ensure Internal audit resources must be
that internal audit resources are ensured by the CAE that are
appropriate, sufficient, and effectively
appropriate, sufficient, and
deployed to achieve the approved
plan” effectively deployed.
Appropriate refers to mix of
There is no explanation Interpretation: knowledge, skills, and other
competencies
Appropriate refers to the mix of Sufficient refers to the quantity of
knowledge, skills, and other resources needed to accomplish
competencies needed to perform the the plan
plan. Sufficient refers to the quantity of
resources needed to accomplish the
Deployed refers to optimalization
plan. Resources are effectively of using resources in a way to
deployed when they are used in a way achieve the plan
that optimizes the achievement of the
approved plan
2050 - Coordination and Reliance
2004 2017 Implication
“The chief audit “The chief audit executive CAE in reporting and
executive should report must report periodically to communication to senior
senior management and management and the
periodically to the board
the board on the internal board must include:”
and senior management audit activity’s purpose, ● "The audit charter.
on the internal audit authority, responsibility, and ● Independence of the
activity’s purpose, performance relative to its internal audit activity.
authority, responsibility, plan and on its ● The audit plan and
and performance conformance with the progress against the
Code of Ethics and the plan.
relative to its plan.”
Standards.” ● Resource
requirements…”
Sources: Moeller, 2016 Sources: The Institute of Internal Auditor, 2016
2060 - Reporting to Senior Management and the Board
2004 2017 Implication
“...
● Results of audit activities.
● Conformance with the Code of
Ethics and the Standards, and action
plans to address any significant
conformance issues.
● Management’s response to risk that,
in the chief audit executive’s
judgment, may be unacceptable to
the organization.”
● Ensuring effective
● Coordinating the activities organizational performance
of and communicating management and
information among the accountability.
board, external and ● Communicating risk and
internal auditors, and control information to
appropriate areas of the
management.”
organization.
● Coordinating the activities
of, and communicating
information among, the
board, external and internal
auditors, other assurance
providers, and management.
Sources: Moeller, 2016
2130 - Control
2004 2017 Implication
●
2210.A3 - Engagement Objectives
2004 2017 Implication
“Adequate criteria are needed to evaluate “Adequate criteria are needed to evaluate
governance, risk management, and governance, risk management, and
Additional interpretations
controls. Internal auditors must ascertain controls. Internal auditors must ascertain of the types of criteria:
the extent to which management and/or the extent to which management and/or
the board the board has established adequate internal, external, and
has established adequate criteria to criteria to determine whether objectives recommended practices
determine whether objectives and goals and goals have been accomplished. If
have been adequate, internal auditors must use such
accomplished. If adequate, internal criteria in their evaluation. If inadequate,
auditors must use such criteria in their internal auditors must identify appropriate
evaluation. If inadequate, internal auditors evaluation criteria through discussion with
must identify appropriate evaluation criteria management and/or the board.”
through discussion with management
and/or the board.” Interpretation:
Types of criteria may include:
Internal (e.g., policies and procedures of
the organization). External (e.g., laws and
regulations imposed by statutory bodies).
Leading practices (e.g., industry and
professional guidance).
2230 - Engagement Resource Allocation
2004 2017 Implication
“ Internal auditors must determine “Internal auditors must determine Additional interpretations
the appropriate resources appropriate and sufficient accordingly refer to a combination
necessary to achieve the audit resources to achieve of knowledge, skills, and other
engagement objectives. Staffing engagement objectives based on competencies.
must be based on an evaluation an evaluation of the nature and
of the nature and complexity of complexity of each engagement,
each engagement, time time constraints, and available
constraints, and available resources.”
resources.”
Interpretation:
“ Internal auditors must record “Internal auditors must Internal auditors must explain
relevant information to support document sufficient, reliable, reliability and adequacy of
the conclusions and engagement relevant, and useful informations that support the
results. “ information to support the conclusion in the working paper
engagement results and
conclusions.”
2410 - Criteria of Communicating
“ Internal auditors are “Indicating that engagements are No implication, just a change of
encouraged to report that their conducted in conformance with words.
engagements are “conducted in the International Standards for
conformance with the the Professional Practice of
International Standards for the Internal Auditing” is appropriate
Professional Practice of Internal only if supported by the results of
Auditing.” However, internal the quality assurance and
auditors may use the statement improvement program.”
only if the results of the quality
assurance and improvement
program demonstrate that the
internal audit activity conforms to
the Standards
2431 - Engagement Disclosure of Nonconformance
“ When noncompliance with the “When nonconformance with Nonconformance only with the
Standards impacts a specific the Code of Ethics or the Code of Ethics or Standards only.
engagement, communication of Standards impacts a specific
the results must disclose the: engagement, communication of
■ Principle or rule of conduct of the results must disclose the:
the Code of Ethics or Standard(s) ● Principle(s) or rule(s) of
with which full conformance was conduct of the Code of Ethics
not made; or the Standard(s) with which
■ Reason(s) for noncompliance; full conformance was not
and achieved.
■ Impact of noncompliance on the ● Reason(s) for
engagement. nonconformance.
● Impact of nonconformance on
the engagement and the
communicated engagement
results.”
2450 - Overall Opinions
“The internal audit activity must evaluate Internal auditor must evaluate
the adequacy and effectiveness of the adequacy and effectiveness
controls in responding to risks within the of controls in responding to risks
organization’s governance, operations, within organization’s governance,
and information systems regarding the: operations, and information
systems.
There is no - Achievement of the organization’s
explanation strategic objectives
- Reliability and integrity of financial
and operational information
- Effectiveness and efficiency of
operations and programs
- Safeguarding of assets
- Compliance with laws, regulations,
policies, procedures, and
contracts.”
2130.C1 - Control
2004 2017 Implication
In order to conduct
“Consulting engagement
consulting engagement
objectives must be consistent objectives, it must
with the organization's consistent with the
There is no values, strategies, and organization’s values,
explanation objectives.” startegis, and objectives.
2240.A1 - Engagement Work Program
2004 2017 Implication