Propositions. A Proposition Asserts That Something Is The Case or It Asserts That Something
Propositions. A Proposition Asserts That Something Is The Case or It Asserts That Something
incorrect reasoning.
In logical reasoning we construct and evaluate arguments; arguments are built with
propositions. A proposition asserts that something is the case or it asserts that something
is not. A proposition may either be affirmed or denied because it presents a claim.
Therefore every proposition is either true or false.
Two different sentences, consisting of different words differently arranged, may have the
same meaning and may be used to assert the very same proposition. For example, “Leslie
won the election” and “The election was won by Leslie” are plainly two different
sentences that make the same assertion.
A statement may refer to proposition but it is not its exact synonym. Every statement
must be either true or false, although the truth or falsity of a given statement may be
unknown.
Arguments are clusters of propositions of which one is the conclusion and the others are
the premises offered in its support. The Premise of an argument is the statement that
provides reason for accepting the conclusion. Conclusion is a statement established by
the premises.
Note that the force of an argument can be appreciated only when one understands the
context in which that argument is presented.
An interrogative sentence can serve as a premise when its question is rhetorical—that is,
when it suggests or assumes an answer that is made to serve as the premise of an
argument. Questions can serve most effectively as premises when the answers assumed
really do seem to be clear and inescapable. Wherein the readers are led to provide the
evident answers for themselves, thus augmenting the persuasiveness of the argument.
Enthymemes are arguments that rely on some proposition that is understood but not
stated. An argument that is stated incompletely but there is an amount of truth in it.
Deductive Argument
- If the premises are true, then the conclusion must also be true
- The conclusion (general) is absolutely supported by the premises (particular).
- May be valid or invalid
- The central task of deductive logic is to discriminate valid arguments from invalid
ones.
Inductive Argument
Thus, an argument may be valid even when its conclusion and one or more of its
premises are false. The validity of an argument depends only on the relation of the
premises to the conclusion.
Sound Argument