Vinyl Acetate - Mass and Energy Balance
Vinyl Acetate - Mass and Energy Balance
Minerals
CHE 495
(181)
2
Table of Contents
ABSTRACT 2
Table of Contents 3
List of Tables 5
INTRODUCTION 7
1. MASS BALANCE 8
1.1. Reactor 8
1.4. Absorber 14
2. ENERGY BALANCE 17
2.1. Reactor 17
2.2.2. Vaporizer 19
2.2.3. Heater 19
3
2.3. Pumps 22
2.3. Compressor 22
CONCLUSION 25
References 26
4
List of Table
Table 1: Mass balance around the reactor 10
Table 4: K-values 12
5
Table 24: Energy balance around the distillation column 24
6
Introduction:
For applying mass and energy balances the law of conservation of mass and first law of
thermodynamics are used which state that “mass can neither be created nor destroyed” for
mass conservation and “energy cannot be created or destroyed but it can be transformed from
one form to another” for first law of thermodynamics. These two laws are the basis for
analyzing and solving any engineering problems and especially at chemical engineering.
Here is a representation the mass balance on a finite quantity in an instant in time where the
first term, and the third one represents what enters and leaves the boundary of a system.
Generation and consumption terms refer to what is generated or consumed within the process
boundary and accumulation is what builds up within the system.
Where Q represents the heat generated or consumed within the system and W defines the
work done either by the system on the surrounding or by the surrounding on the system.
1. Mass Balance
7
1.1. Reactor:
Reactions:
1
Main reaction: C 2 H 4 +C H 3 COOH + O 2 → C2 H 3 OOCC H 3 + H 2 O
2
Assumptions:
Steady state represents a continuous process which has no accumulation. In this process an
excess of ethylene to acetic acid has to satisfy in the reactant ratio where it has to be from
2: 1 to 3: 1. This excess ratio can insure that process is under explosion limit where oxygen
concentration has to be kept 8 % and below based on free acetic acid mixture [1].
Extent of reaction:
ni =ni ,o + v i ξ
Where ni is the amount remained, or produced of component i , and ni,o is the amount of
component i fed, and vi is the stoichiometric number which is positive for products and
negative for reactants.
8
For Ethylene (C2H4): ṅC 2 H4 =530.0525−ξ 1−ξ 2 (1)
ξ1
Selectivity of Vinyl Acetate (C4H6O2): =0.9 (8)
( 2∗ξ2 ) + ( ξ1 +2∗ξ 2)
Degree of freedom:
Degree of freedom:
DF =+ number of unknowns+number of indepensant reactios−number if species−number of other information
DF =8+2−6−2=0
530.0525−ṅC H4 kmol
From equation (7): 2
=0.09 → ṅ C H =482.348
530.0525 2 4
h
482.348=530.0525−ξ1−ξ2 → 47.705=ξ1 +ξ 2
9
ξ1
=0.9→ 0.1 ¿ ξ 1=3.6∗ξ2 → ξ2 =0.0278∗ξ1
( 2∗ξ2 ) + ( ξ1 +2∗ξ 2)
kmol kmol
47.705=ξ 1+ 0.0278∗ξ1 → ξ1=46.416 ∧ξ 2=1.290
h h
Now substituting ξ 1∧ξ 2 in equations (2), (3), (4), (5) and (6):
kmol
ṅC H 4 O2 =223.18−46.416=175.480
2
h
kmol
ṅO =89.272−0.5∗46.416−3∗1.290=62.217
2
h
kmol
ṅC H 6 O2 =46.416
4
h
kmol
ṅC O =245.498+2∗1.290=248.078
2
h
kmol
ṅ H O=46.416+2∗1.290=48.996
2
h
kmol
ṅC H6 =27.898
2
h
10
1.2. Mixing Points:
11
Table 3: Mass balance around second mixing point
Mixture stream
component Formula flowrate (kmol/h)
Ethylene C2H4 530.053
Oxygen O2 62.217
Carbon Dioxide CO2 245.489
Ethane C2H6 27.887
Acetic Acid C2H4O2 223.180
Fresh oxygen feed
component Formula flowrate (kmol/h)
Oxygen O2 27.055
Table 4: K-values
Assumptions:
12
Table 5: Inlet to the flash drum
V
c
( K i−1 )∗z i
Vapor fraction in the feed
f ( )
=∑
F i=1
1+
( K i−1 )∗V (1)
F
For ( VF )=0.748,
c
( K i−1 )∗z i (19.1602−1 )∗0.442 ( 0.00686331−1 )∗0.161 ( 206.986+1 )∗0.057 (18.0251−1
∑ = + + +
i=1 ( K i−1 )∗V 1+ ( 19.1602−1 )∗0.748 1+ ( 0.00686331−1 )∗0.748 1+ ( 206.986+1 )∗0.748 1+ ( 18.0251−
1+
F
z1
x 1=
Liquid compositions: ( K 1 −1 )∗V (2)
1+
F
0.442
For ethylene: x C H = =0.0303
2 4
1+ ( 19.1602−1 )∗0.748
13
Table 6: Liquid outlet from flash drum
1.4. Absorber:
The absorber is used to remove vinyl acetate as well as acetic acid from the gas stream that
leaves the flash drum. The solvent that is used for washing is pure acetic acid and it will be
recycled to the distillation column. The operation conditions are 31 ⁰C and 8 bar.
Assumptions:
Adiabatic operation
Negligible heat of absorption
Steady state
14
100% recovery of vinyl acetate and acetic acid at the bottom
Amount of vinyl acetate at inlet gas stream is 5.756 kmol/h and for acetic acid is 3.504 kmol/ h
will be transfer to the solvent and the below table shows the detailed streams for absorber.
component Formula solvent inlet (kmol/h) solvent outlet (kmol/h) Gas inlet Gas outlet
Ethylene C2H4 0.000 0.000 474.108 474.108
Acetic Acid C2H4O2 111.590 115.094 3.504 0.000
Oxygen O2 0.000 0.000 62.128 62.128
Carbon Dioxide CO2 0.000 0.000 243.573 243.573
Water H2O 0.000 0.000 1.497 1.497
Ethane C2H6 0.000 0.000 27.116 27.116
Vinyl Acetate C4H6O2 0.000 5.756 5.756 0.000
Total 111.590 120.850 817.683 808.422
Assumptions:
kmol
For acetic acid at bottom: B= ż C H O ∗F=0.728∗392.752=285.923
2 4 2
h
15
For others at distillate: D=z i F
kmol
For ethylene: D=z C ∗F=0.021∗392.752=8.274
H4 and others listed in below table.
2
h
16
2. Energy Balance:
2.1. Reactor:
Heat of formation is the method used to calculate the energy associated with the reactor.
Assumptions:
Heat of reaction: Q̇=∆ Ḣ=∑ ṅ out Ḣ out −∑ ṅ¿ Ḣ ¿ , where Ḣ=∆ Ḣ ° f at (25 ℃)
Table 10: Energy balance around the reactor
kJ
Q̇=−181990676.6−(−174019527.7 ) =−7971148.993 =−2214.21 kW
h
Negative (Q̇) indicates an exothermic process where 2214.21 kW of heat is produced at the
reactor.
component Formula C1 C2 C3 C4 C5
Ethylene C2H4 247,390 -4,428 40.936 -0.1697 0.00026816
17
Acetic Acid C2H4O2 139,640 -320.8 0.8985 0 0
Carbon Dioxide CO2 8,304,300 104,370 -433.33 0.60054 0
Water H2O 276,370 -2,090.10 8.125 -0.014116 9.37E-06
Ethane C2H6 44.009 89,718 918.77 -1,886 0
Vinyl Acetate C4H6O2 136,300 -106.17 0.75175 0 0
C p ,l=C 1 +C2∗T +C 3∗T 2+ C4∗T 3+ C5∗T 4
2 2
C3 C5
C p ,v =C 1 +C2∗
( ( )) ( ( ))
T
sinh 3
C
T
+C 4∗
T
C
cosh 5
T
18
For steady state operation, shell-tube heat exchanger is installed to overcome the heat of
reaction and to maintain constant temperature inside the reactor. Therefore, the duty of
shell-tube heat exchanger equals heat of reaction.
2.2.2. Vaporizer:
Only acetic acid will vaporize, and heat of vaporization will be added, and others are at gas
phase. Inlet and outlet temperatures are 30 ⁰C and 120 ⁰C respectively.
Q̇=∑ ṅi (C p ,l +∆ H vp +C p , v )
kJ
Q̇ v =11526976.31 =3201.94 kW
h
2.2.3. Heater:
The heater which is after the vaporizer is used to give further heat where inlet temperature
is 120 ⁰C and outlet temperature is 155 ⁰C. All species are in the gas phase.
Q̇=∑ ṅi (C p ,v )
Table 15: Energy balance around the heater
19
Ethane C2H6 27.898 27.898 65415.06
Vinyl Acetate C4H6O2 0.000 0.000 0
kJ
Q̇=2131486.279 =592.08 kW
h
kJ
Q̇=−13551622.73 =−3764.34 kW
h
Q̇=∑ ṅi C p
20
Table 17: Energy balance around the second cooler
kJ
Q̇=−2788649.21 =−774.62kW
h
kJ
Q̇=−2601955.06 =−722.77 kW
h
2.2.7. Fourth Cooler:
A portion of recycled acetic acid has to be cooled down from 130 ⁰C to 30 ⁰C before
introducing it to the absorber.
21
Acetic Acid C2H4O2 285.818 285.818 -10536580.4
kJ
Q̇=−10536580.4 =−2926.83 kW
h
2.3. Pump:
After the flash drum a pump is installed to pressurize the fluid from 1 to 1.3 bar which is
going to distillation column.
kg
Average molecular weight: Ḿ w =Σ xi M w =55.056 i
kmol
kg
Mass flow rate: ṁ= ṅtot∗ Ḿ w =55.056∗271.902=14972.403 =249.540 kg /min
h
1 kg
ρmix = =45.421
x m3
∑ ρi
i
22
1.67∗V∗∆ P
P=
ϵ
V (m3/min) 5.494
∆P 0.3
ε 0.7
P (kW) 3.932
2.4. Compressor:
After the flash drum a compressor is installed to compress the gases from 4 to 8 bar which is
going to absorber column, assuming Cp/Cv =1.4.
P2 a
( n∗R∗z 1∗T 1∗
(( ) ))
P1
−1
k −1 C P a
P ( W )=
a∗ε
, a=
k
, k = p , T 2=T 1∗ 2
Cv P1 ( )
Table 23: Energy balance around the compressor
n (kmol/h) 817.6825522
n (mol/s) 227.1340423
z1 1
k 1.4
a = (k-1)/k 0.285714286
P1 (bar) 4
P2 (bar) 8
R (J/mol.K) 8.314
T1 (K) 303.15
23
T2 (K) 369.5439893
ε 0.75
P (kW) 585.10
F h F +Q c +Q R=D h D + B hB , Q c =( 1+ R ) D(h D −H v )
h F , h D , hB ∧H V can be found from heat capacity and heat of vaporization depending on the
temperatures.
( h D −H v ) can be found from the difference between gas and liquid heat capacities of vinyl
acetate from reference temperature to vaporization temperature to distillation temperature.
24
( 1+ 0.85 )∗106.934∗(−39620 )
Q c =( 1+ R ) D ( h D−H v ) = =−2177.20 kW
3600
Q R=D h D + B hB −F h F −Q c = ( 2065122.2
3600 ) +(
10669993
3600 ) −(
478147.4
3600 )
− (−2177.20 )
Q R=5581.91 kW
Conclusion:
In summary, mass and energy balances are conducted based on the conservation law of mass
and first law of thermodynamics. Material and energy balances were used to identify the
unknown parameters at streams. Several assumptions were stated in each equipment to
achieve the degree of freedom or to simplify process calculation. However, some of the
assumptions may not be applicable and may lead to huge difference from the real case. The
temperatures and pressures were token from scientific source [3]. However, aspen plus was
used to obtain some parameters such as K-values. The major energy consumption was
determined to be 5581.9 kW from distillation’s reboiler. All stream and energy flows were
calculated for a production of 46.4 kmol/h vinyl acetate.
25
References
[ 3] Dimian, Alexandre C., and Costin Sorin. Bildea. Chemical Process Design: Computer-
Aided Case Studies. Wiley-VCH, 2008
26