Design and Simulation of A Vegetable Shredding and Washing Machine - International Journal of Excellence Innovation and Development
Design and Simulation of A Vegetable Shredding and Washing Machine - International Journal of Excellence Innovation and Development
net/publication/351068939
CITATIONS READS
0 94
4 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Oluwajuwon Caleb on 26 April 2021.
Abstract––Value addition to vegetables prior to mechanical damage. These losses have been estimated to
domestic use can be attained via processes such as be more than 50% in the tropics and sub-tropics. To
hygienic washing, shredding, and packaging. Manual reduce these losses and derive maximum utilization and
processing of vegetables is time-consuming while economic gains from vegetables, adequate preservation by
contamination and additional manpower are the notable way of processing vegetables is required. Quality
drawbacks of existing vegetable cutting machine. With preservation, safety and enhanced long shelf life of
the outlook of circumventing these challenges, this paper vegetables are areas of interest in modern manufacturing.
studies the design and simulation of a motorized electric-
driven vegetable shredding and washing machine. The Washing and cutting are the major operations required for
capacity of the designed machine in terms of the mass of the processing of vegetables. These unit operations are
vegetable that can be processed per hour is 83 kg/hr. The carried out via traditional techniques. The output of the
static structural components of the machine were traditional technique has been found to be low and wastes
simulated to test for the possibility of failure. The time due to the drudgery of the process. Shredding
maximum stress (190.12 MPa) that occurred on the (slicing, cutting or dicing) of vegetables by using kitchen
components of the machine was found to be less than the knife exposes human to the danger of knife cut. On the
material yield strength (250MPa). The simulation results other hand, washing of fresh vegetables can reduce the
confirm that the designed shredding and washing overall potential for microbial food safety hazards. This is
machine will have a long service life. Antimicrobial an important step since most microbial contamination is
agents are recommended as liquid constituents (for on the surface of vegetables or fruits [6] [7].
vegetable washing) in order to inhibit contamination and Contamination and spreading of human pathogens and
microbial reactions. microbes to a greater portion of vegetables ensue if they
are not removed, controlled or inactivated [3] [8-10].
Index Terms––Design, simulation, washing machine, Hussain et al. [11] recommended that fruits and
vegetables, vegetable shredding, shredding and washing vegetables must be cleaned after they are harvested to
improve product appearance and edibility, and to remove
INTRODUCTION harmful microorganisms that can shorten the life of the
Vegetables are referred to as edible plants or the edible products. Likewise, vegetables need to be prewashed to
parts of plants [1] that help in preventing micro-nutrient get rid of immediate surface dirt and pesticide residues.
deficiencies and other nutritional diseases [2]. Mechanical cleaning system has been identified as an
Vegetables are valuable nutritional sources of vitamins, effective approach of removing mites and other surface
minerals, and fiber [3]. The high fiber nature of arthropods from fruits [12] and this can be adopted for
vegetables controls blood sugar levels, prevents vegetables as well.
constipation, lowers the risk of digestive conditions,
cardiovascular diseases, and blood cholesterol levels [2]. Diverse works have been carried out on cutting or slicing
In fact, vegetables with the right proportion of process. For instance, Ndukwua and Onyenwigwe [13]
antioxidants, minerals, and phytochemical help in worked on the development of a motorized parboiled
keeping blood sugar in balance, create better energy in cassava tuber shredding machine in 2013. Leo and
the body and build up the immune system (with the Balogun [14] developed a functional multi-crop slicing
addition of fruits). Non-leafy vegetables like garlic and machine while Raji and Igbeka [15] invented a pedal
onions contain allicin, the anti-viral, antibacterial, and operated chipping and slicing machine for tubers. Food
anti-fungal phytochemical that can act antibiotics [4]. processor [16], vegetable shredder [17], and processing
The human-body need for vegetable cannot be apparatus for leafy vegetables [18] have been developed
overemphasized because vegetables are essential dietary over the years. Recently, Kamaldeen and Awagu [19]
requirements for a healthy living. However, huge post- developed a tomato slicing machine. Klintham et al. [20]
harvest losses of vegetables are experienced by farmers employed microbubbles (MB) technology as a washing
and marketers due to the high perishability nature of mechanism/process to reduce the microbial contamination
fresh vegetables, poor handling, and inadequate storage on leafy vegetables. Tony et al. [21] designed and
facilities. FAO [5] reported that over 23 % of most developed an automated vegetable cutting machine.
perishable fruits and vegetables are lost during their
journey (harvesting, transportation, processing, and Frank [22] worked on blade assembly for paper
packaging) through the agricultural food chain due to shredder. Nithyananth et al. [23] and Joseph [24]
spoilage, physiological decay, water loss, and designed waste shredding machines for waste seize
reduction, while Mandal [25] made available data required Design Calculations and Analysis
for design of shredder blades. Gear protection device of a Some factors were considered in the design of the
paper shredder was developed by Frank [26]. The blade vegetable shredding and washing machine. These
for the paper shredding cutting tool was designed and include capacity, drudgery reduction, simplicity and
produced by Emily [27]. Mark et al. [28] worked on flexibility of the machine, and strength of materials.
lubrication caring substrate for shredder maintenance, the Hopper, shredding discs, power drive mechanism, shaft
rotational speed controlling the system for shredder design, the power requirement of the pump, bearings,
motors was investigated by Hunag [29]. Hunag [30] also supporting frame, and capacity of the machine were
studied elliptical acetabuli for blade for shredder. designed for.
Shaft Design
The combined twisting moment and the equivalent
bending moment were considered in order to obtain the
correct diameter of the shaft during the shaft design. The
Fig. 3: Rotor-motor shaft configuration. loading diagram of the shredding shaft is illustrated in
Figure 4. RA and RB are the reactions at A and B
(4) respectively. The weight of the evenly distributed
shredding discs is 800 N. The estimated values of RA
Where, D2 is the diameter of the pulley on the shredding and RB are 266.7 N and 533 N respectively.
shaft (180 mm), D1 is the diameter of motor pulley (71
mm), N1 is the speed of the electric motor (1440 rpm),
and N2 is the speed of the shredding shaft pulley.
According to equation 4, the speed of the shredding shaft
pulley was estimated to be 568 rpm. The minimum
center distance (Cm) is estimated to be 161 mm by
employing Equation 5. The length of the belt (Lb) is
Fig. 4: Loading diagram of the shredding shaft.
evaluated as 546 mm via the use of Equation 6.
The shear force and bending moment diagrams of the
(5) shredding shaft are shown in Figure 5. The maximum
(6) bending moment is indicated as “B.M = max” at a point
G (center of the shaft) on Figure 5.
The identification of the tensions in the belt (tight and
slack tensions) requires prior knowledge of the angle of
contact on the pulley. By employing Equations 7 and 8,
the angles of contact on the pulleys are determined.
Where, R2 is the radius of the shredding shaft pulley (90
mm), R1 is the radius of the motor shaft pulley (35.5
mm), and is the angle of contact of the belt on the
smaller pulley (estimated to 2.94 rad).
(7)
(8)
The maximum bending moment is computed according tangential force acting on the shaft, WRH is the axial
to Equation 14 to be 60000N-mm. Where M is the force acting on the shaft, WRV is the radial force acting
maximum bending moment in N-mm, L is the distance on the shaft (27.12 N), RA is the reaction at A and RB is
between the bearings (300 mm) and W is the weight of the reaction at B. RB and RA were estimated to be 23.73
the shredding disc (800 N). N and 3.39 N respectively.
(16)
antimicrobial agents like quaternary ammonium machine. The application of a torque of 4970 N-mm on
compounds (benzalkonium chloride and didecyl the driving bevel shaft transmitted the torque to the
dimethyl ammonium chloride), and isothiazolinones (a driven bevel shaft and generated a pressure of 2107 MPa
mixture of methylchloroisothiazolinone and in Figure 9.
methylisothiazolinone) can be used as alternatives for
washing the shredding vegetables [34].
SIMULATION OF MACHINE
COMPONENTS
Based on the designed vegetable shredding and washing
machine, the essential parts of the machine were
simulated. Figure 9 shows the components of the
machine where forces are acting on. The entire machine
was reduced to the model shown in Figure 9 as most of
the stresses act on the shown structural parts. The
regions or components with red profiles are critical parts
where movements or relative motions take place in the Fig. 7: Isometric view of the machine.
Figure 10 is discretized into 68823 nodes and 22967 machine subjected to stresses will not fail under service
elements while the gear components in Figure 11 were condition since they will not undergo plastic deformation
finely meshed prior to the assignment of boundary or yielding.
conditions (according to the designed parameters in
Section 3) and the simulation process. Figures 10 and 11 CONCLUSION
show the results of the stress analysis on the washing The design and simulation of a motorized electric-driven
and motion transmission mechanisms. The values of the vegetable shredding and washing machine have been
maximum Von Misses stress were found to be lesser successfully carried out. The capacity of the machine is
than the material yield strength for the washing chamber about 83 kg/hr. The static structural simulation of the
and the motion transmitting components. The maximum machine reveals the capability of the machine to
stress (190.12 MPa) that occurred on the components of withstand deformation or operational force/loading
the machine was found to be less than the material yield effect. The maximum stress (190.12 MPa) that occurred
strength (250MPa). Thus, the components of the on the components of the machine was found to be less
than the material yield strength (250MPa). The machine [13] M.C. Ndukwua, and D. Onyenwigwe,
has the capability of processing various kinds of leafy “Development of a motorized parboiled cassava
vegetables at the shortest possible time due to the tuber shredding machine”. Nigerian Journal of
synergy of shredding and washing units in the designed Technology (NIJOTECH), 2013, Vol. 32, No. 1,
machine. Antimicrobial agents such as chlorinated water pp. 1–6.
and quaternary ammonium compounds are [14] A. Leo, and A. Balogun, “Design and
recommended as liquid constituents of the required Performance Evaluation of a Multi-Crop Slicing
water (washing) in order to inhibit contamination and Machine”, 5th CIGR Section International
microbial reactions. Symposium on Food Processing, Potsderm
Germany, 2009.
REFERENCES [15] O. A. Raji, and J. C. Igbeka, “Pedal Operated
Chipping and Slicing Machine for Tuber”. Journal
[1] International Agency for research on cancer,
of Agricultural and Engineering Technology,
“Handbooks of cancer prevention-fruits and
1994, Pp 90-99.
vegetables”, Lyon (France): IARC Press, 2003. [16] W.-H. Lin, “Food processor”. US patent grant no
[2] N.M. Lewis, J. A. Albrecht, M. I. Schnepf, F. L. US5156084A, 1992
Hamouz, and J. A. Driskel, “Vegetable choices [17] Z. Karl, “Vegetable shredder”. US patent Grant no
and cooking methods of Nebraskans”. Journal of US2782826A, 1954
Economics Rise, 1994, Vol. 22, pp. 286-295 [18] W. M. Hofmeister, “Method and apparatus for
[3] I. Castro-Ibáñez, M. I. Gil, A. Allende, “Ready-to- processing leafy vegetables”. US patent Grant no
eat vegetables: Current problems and potential US5727690A, 1995
solutions to reduce microbial risk in the [19] O. S. Kamaldeen, and E. F. Awagu, “Design and
production chain”. LWT - Food Science and Development of a Tomato Manual Slicing
Technology, 2017, 85, pp. 284-292 Machine”, Nigerian Stored Products Research
[4] O. Jane, “Benefits of a variety of fruits and Institute, International Journal of Engineering and
vegetables”, URL: www.naturalchoicesforyou.co Technology, 2016, pp 57-60.
m, 2005. Accessed on 25th April, 2017 [20] P. Klintham, S. Tongchitpakdee, W. Chinsirikul,
[5] FAO, “Fruit and fruits processing. FAO W. Mahakarnchanakul, “Combination of
Agricultural Services Bulletin No.119”. Food and microbubbles with oxidizing sanitizers to
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, eliminate Escherichia
Rome, Italy. 1995 coli and Salmonella Typhimurium on Thai leafy
vegetables”. Food Control, 2017, 77, pp. 260-269
[6] D. F. Maffei, V. O. Alvarenga, A. S. Sant’Ana, E.
[21] A. Tony, A. Muthu, and K.S. SreNandha, “Design
D. G.M. Franco, “Assessing the effect
and development of automated vegetable cutting
of washing practices employed in Brazilian machine”. 5th International & 26th All India
processing plants on the quality of ready-to- Manufacturing Technology, Design and Research
eat vegetables”. LWT - Food Science and Conference (AIMTDR 2014) December 12th–
Technology, 2016, Vol. 69, pp. 474-481 14th, 2014, IIT Guwahati, Assam, India.
[7] S. M. Henderson, and R. L. Perry, “Agricultural [22] C. Frank, “Blade Assembly For Paper Shredder”.
Processing Engineering”, Third Edition. US 6089482, BO2C18/06,BO2C 18/18, 2000
Macmillan Publishing Company: New York, [23] S. Nithyananth , N. S. Mathew, S. LSuraj, “Design
1980, pp 185. of Waste Shredder”. ISSN:2248 – 9622, 2014,
[8] FDA, “Guidance for Industry - Guide to Minimize Vol.4, Issue 3, pp. 487-491.
Microbial Food Safety Hazards for Fresh [24] Y.K Joseph, “Paper Shredding Device”. US
vegetables and Fruits”. 1998 639039 B1, 2002
[9] M. Lehto, R. Kuisma, J. Määttä, H.-R. [25] D.P. Mandal, “Design Data Handbook for
Kymäläinen, M. Mäki, “Hygienic level and Mechanical Engineering” 2nd Ed. Sanjeev kuma
surface contamination in fresh- Kataria, Delhi. 2013, pp 20 – 26.
cut vegetable production plants”. Food [26] C. Frank Taipei, “Gear Protection Device of a
Control, 2011, Vol. 22 (3-4), pp. 469-475 Paper” 6325309B1, 2001
[10] N. Garg, J. J. Churey, and D. F. Splittstoesser, [27] L. Emily, T. Shiepei, “Blade For Paper Shredder
“Effect of Processing Conditions on the Cutting Tool”. 7328867B1., 2008
[28] S.A. Mark, C.L. Butter and U.T. Orem,
Microflora of Fresh-Cut Vegetables”. Journal of
“Lubricant Carrring Substrate for Maintenance”,.
Food Protection, 1990, Vol. 53, No. 8, pp. 701-
2007
703 [29] S. Hunag, S. Chung, “Rotation Speed Controlling
[11] A. Hussein, “Trading technology of horticultural System for Shredder Motor”. 8000888262, 2011
crops after harvest”. The Conference of Post- [30] S. Hunag, S. Chung, “Elliptical Acetabuli for
harvest Handling of Agricultural Products, Cairo Blade for Shedder”. 6981667B2, App.
from 16th - 21st of December, 1991. No.10/682198, 2006.
[12] G. P. Walker, “Evaluation of a high-pressure [31] R. S. Khurimi, and J. K. Gupta, “A Textbook of
washer for postharvest removal of California red Machine Design (S.I. Units)”. Published by
scale (Homoptera diapididae) from citrus fruit”. J. Eurasia Publishing House (PVT) Ltd, Ram Nagar,
Econ. Ent. 1996, Vol. 89, pp. 148-155. New Delhi, 2005
[32] Aqua-Calc: URL: www.aqua-calc.com accessed [34] C. Pablos, A. Romero, A. Diego, C. Vargas, I.
on 20th May 2017. Bascón, F. Pérez-Rodríguez, J. Marugán, “Novel
[33] S. Baur, R. Klaiber, W. P. Hammes, R. Carle, antimicrobial agents as alternative to chlorine
“Sensory and microbiological quality of shredded, with potential applications in the fruit and
packaged iceberg lettuce as affected by pre- vegetable processing industry”. International
washing procedures with chlorinated and Journal of Food Microbiology, 2018, Vol. 285, pp.
ozonated water”. Innovative Food Science & 92-97
Emerging Technologies, 2004, Vol. 5(1), pp. 45-
55