Net Metering Handbook Print Secured
Net Metering Handbook Print Secured
YO U R G U I D E TO M E R ALC O’ S S O L AR PV
N E T M E TE RI N G PI LOT PROJ ECT
TITLE HERE 1
1 EMPOWERING YOUR TOMORROW
EMPOWERING YOUR TOMORROW
Your Guide to Meralco’s
Solar PV Net Metering Pilot Project
COPYRIGHT C 2014
Here in our country, spurred by the Renewable Energy Act of 2008, we are
seeing increasing interest in the application of the commercial and “own-use”
renewable energy, specifically Wind, Solar, Run of River and Biomass power.
We expect a more visible build up in generating capacity from these sources
over the years.
We in Meralco launched our Meralco Net Metering Pilot Project to model and
simulate the effects of interfacing with Solar PV systems on the distribution
network. Through the efforts of our engineers and analysts, the project now
serves as our proof-of-concept for Net Metering and paves the way for the
creation of Meralco’s Net Metering Program.
I congratulate and thank the project team for pioneering this important effort,
and I anticipate that it will serve as an added catalyst for the adoption of
renewable energy sources at a more meaningful scale.
OSCAR S. REYES
President and CEO, Meralco
At present, the Philippines’ demand for power grows alongside its growing
economy and populace. Aside from the need to put up additional power
plants, increased maintenance of existing power plants is necessary to prevent
future power outages and to address the issue of tightening electricity supply.
The use of renewable energy (RE) technologies such as run-of-river hydro,
solar, wind, and biomass is highly urged.
In support of the Renewable Energy Law (R.A. 9513), the ERC promulgated
Resolution No. 9, series of 2013, otherwise known as the Rules Enabling the
Net-Metering Program for Renewable Energy, including the Net-Metering
Interconnection Standards (Net-Metering Rules).
The Philippines is blessed with vast RE resources which need to be developed and
maximized. Efficient and proper utilization of such resources will not just meet
the energy demands of the country but also contribute to economic progress.
This Handbook will help jumpstart a progressive change which will positively
affect and direct us toward achieving a stable, safe, and quality supply of electricity
for every Filipino.
ZENAIDA G. CRUZ-DUCUT
Chairperson and CEO,
Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC)
5 THE GROUNDWORK
Installation of Low Voltage Renewable Energy Generating Facility
27 PEEKING INTO PQ
Assessment of Power Quality Parameters
41 WAY FORWARD
Learnings and Future Considerations
45 APPENDIX
PR OJ ECT O B J ECTIVES
The main objectives of the Pilot are (i) to provide Meralco engineers and
process caretakers a controlled venue for learning and evaluating an actual
connection and synchronization of low voltage renewables with the Meralco
system, and (ii) to establish a standard process of safely and efficiently
connecting and synchronizing low voltage renewables, applicable not only to
Meralco but to all RE stakeholders such as distribution utilities, LGUs, system
designers and installers, and all customers in general.
More importantly, the installation will also serve as proof of concept for Net
Metering. The metering set-up installed should be able to capture the two-
way flow of electricity and measure kWh registrations at both directions.
After the completion of the year-long study, Meralco now shares its
observations, learnings, and recommendations on low voltage renewable
interconnection.
1
Republic Act No. 9513 “An Act Promoting the Development,
Utilization and Commercialization of Renewable Energy
Resources and for Other Purposes”
2
Section 6, RE Act
3
Section 7, RE Act
4
Section 9, RE Act
5
Section 10, RE Act
6
ERC Resolution No. 09, Series of 2013, entitled
“A Resolution Adopting the Rules Enabling the
Net Metering Program for Renewable Energy”
(Net Metering Rules)
7
Section 4 (n), Article I, Net
Metering Rules
8
Section 10, RE Act; Section 7,
Article III, Net Metering Rules
9
Section 2, Annex A-1
Interconnection Standards,
Net Metering Rules
With the installation site identified, the next step is to select an RE integrator
for the project. This involves assembling the general requirements and
technical specifications of the RE system components safeguarding that they
conform to applicable industry and regulatory standards.
Finally, the installed components and wiring layout of the RE system would
have to be documented to facilitate post-installation maintenance activities.
Detailed discussion on the steps undertaken for the Meralco Pilot can be
found in the sections below.
I. Site Selection
To identify the most viable location for the solar PV panels, several
requirements were considered. These initial considerations were:
Initial Assessment
Based on the initial parameters set for selecting the ideal site, two
locations/buildings were shortlisted, the Operations Building and the
Covered Tennis Court.
OPERATIONS BUILDING
The location of the Operations Building is parallel to a major road often
used by both employees and visitors going to the Fitness Center. The
building’s rooftop is made of flat concrete slabs, which makes it attractive
in terms of stability and ease of installation. Actual shading analysis was
done on the rooftop of the Operations Building. Initial survey results
showed that shadows from the surrounding buildings may affect the
panels during different times of the day. The effects of the shadowing were
seen to be minimal and a significant portion of the day’s sunlight can still
be harvested. However, investigations on the structural integrity of the
building discouraged installation on the rooftop because of the building’s
age and current condition.
C OVE R E D TE N N I S C O U RT
The Covered Tennis Court was the second site considered. In terms of visibility
and accessibility, it is a good location. It can be easily seen because of the
building’s height and slanted roof construction. The building’s structural
supports are made of steel on concrete blocks. The structural integrity of
the building was found to be sufficient to carry the additional weight of
the panels. Also, the area is very accessible for maintenance purposes since
two of its sides are right along wide roadways. Another plus for this location
is the roof angle and orientation which favors panel installation technical
requirements – panels should have a tilt of at least 10 degrees to promote
natural cleansing of dust whether artificially or by rainwater. Also, the
roof is tilted facing south – the ideal orientation of PV installations in the
Philippines. However, a quick survey of the area showed that sunlight harvest
may be affected by buildings located south-east of the building. This merits
a more intensive investigation on its shadowing effects.
The survey has shown that the Medical City building and the Rockwell
Business Center Towers (RBC) may cast shadows on the Covered Tennis Court.
The Medical City is taller but farther and situated at about 70o southeast with
an approximate height of 60 meters. The Rockwell Tower 2, on the other
hand, is situated at about 55o southeast and approximately 50 meters tall.
For simplification purposes the sun was considered as a point source at a very
large distance from earth (thus shadow cast shall be parallel and will not
widen significantly when the sun is low on the horizon). Also, the shadowing
effect from RBC Tower 2 was disregarded as it will cast cover only at a limited
period of time. It was assumed that since the top of the Medical City has about
18 degrees elevation from the location of the Covered Tennis Court, there will
be no shading when the sun has reached an altitude of 18 degrees.
As can be deduced from the diagrams in Figure 1.3, about 1.5 hours of
sunlight during the months of February and October and 1 hour 20 minutes
during January and November will be lost. It is also important to note that
these values were estimated using interpolated data on a sunpath diagram
suited for Manila (15 degrees latitude). Also, the difference between Solar
Time and Local Mean Time (ranging from 5 to 15 mins) was not considered.
These assumptions may contribute to some differences in the actual and the
abovecited hours of sunlight.
Net AC Output (kW) refers to the estimated equivalent AC net real power
output of the inverter. This data gives the estimated AC power generation
of the entire solar PV system. Based on simulations, the net AC output of
the 6.16kWp installation is 4.44kW. This capacity was initially assumed to
handle a significant portion of the demand requirement of the project
load and even export power to the grid under favorable conditions.
S HA D O W A NA LYS I S
To determine the average irradiance per day, which is critical to optimizing
the PV system design, shadow analysis needs to be conducted. It determines
solar obstructions with reference to the position of the sun on different
seasons throughout the year.
In conducting shadow analysis, different tools can be used like the Solar
Pathfinder, SunEye, and PVSYST Software. These equipment also provide far-
shading analysis which gives the azimuth and altitude of the sun on different
seasons throughout the year. Far-shading is caused by physical obstructions
like mountains, trees, and buildings. The far-shading data is an input to the
software for graphical presentation.
PR OJ ECTE D PO W E R G E N E R ATI O N
The energy production in kWh of the solar PV system was estimated for the
first year. Based on the result of simulation, the initial year energy production
of the pilot project is 6,858kWh.
SYSTE M D IAG R A M
The system diagram illustrates the physical connection of different parts
of the solar PV system such as the solar modules, inverters, check meter,
protective devices, and switches.
PV Panels
M O D U LE T YPE
There are two common
types of PV modules,
the polycrystalline and
monocrystalline module.
Taking into account the
weather conditions in
the Philippines, long-run
efficiency, and component
cost, polycrystalline modules
were used in the system
design.
W I N D PR ES S U R E W ITH STA N D
This criteria determines the quality of the PV module. The higher the wind
pressure capability, the higher the quality of the PV module. Based on the PV
supplier’s submitted specifications for the solar PV module, the entire module
is certified to withstand high wind loads of 2.4 up to 5.4 kilo Pascal (kPa).
M O U NTI N G D E TAI LS
The module support structure model is dependent on the roof type. The
model used by the winning bidder is Schletter Single Fix HU Model made
with anodized aluminum with high grade steel screws. Based on the wind
pressure analysis, the module support structure can withstand the wind
pressure of 1.332 kPa or an equivalent wind velocity of 167kph.
I NVE RTE R
The brand and model of PV units serve as inputs to the design simulation for
the inverter. In general, the more inverter units in the PV system, the higher
the reliability of the solar power system. However, this would also mean
higher costs. The PV supplier used 2 units of SMA Sunny Boy SB3000TLST-21
model with a maximum efficiency of 97%.
Shading Analysis
One basic consideration to any Solar Rooftop design is the shading analysis of
the project site. Shading analysis will provide the solar resource that can be
harvested in the given project site. Solar resource is rated in terms of watt per
meter square (W/m2), which is also called Solar Irradiance.
Sunpeak Hours is defined as the equivalent number of hours per day when
solar irradiance averages 1,000 W/m2 . For example, six (6) sunpeak hours
means that the energy received during total daylight hours equals to the
energy that would have been received had the irradiance for six hours been
1,000 W/m2 . (www.ecowho.com).
Investigation showed that the roof bearing capacity of the Covered Tennis
Court is 600 Pascal (Pa) or about 60 kgs/m2 .
Comparing this capacity with the projected solar facility load of about 15 kgs./
m2 load, the Covered Tennis Court would be able to bear this load easily since
it is only 25% of the roof bearing capacity of the site.
Meteorological Data
Meteorological data is important in designing a Solar PV Rooftop. This will
give the average temperature, wind velocity, global and diffused irradiance.
Meteorological data will dictate the performance of the Solar PV Rooftop.
Global
Horizontal
Diffused
Horiz.
Array
Monthly
Projected
Monthly
Monthly
Performance
Projected
Values
Irradiance Irradiance Energy
Production Energy
Production Ratio Efficiency
The Meralco pilot project is designed to produce energy for the next 25
years or more. The projected energy generation during these years takes
into account the degradation factor and the projected irradiance on site for
25 years.
Table 1.3 on the next page will show the projected annual energy generation
of the 6.16 kWp Solar PV Power Plant for a period of 25 years.
TOTAL 156,884.76
Equipment Selection
For the Meralco 6.16 kWp Solar PV Solar power plant, reliable and efficient
equipment were selected. Twenty two (22) units of Suntech STP 280-24/Vd
280 watt-peak solar modules were installed connected to two (2) SMA Sunny
Boy SB 3000TLST-21 inverter via XLPE cables.
21
THE GROUNDWORK
Net Metering
In a net metering arrangement, the end-user maintains a two-way connection
to the distribution system. The customer is only charged or credited, as the
case may be, for the difference between the electricity supplied by the DU
(import energy) and the electricity it supplies to the DU during times when
it has excess RE generation (export energy), both of which are metered using
either 2 uni-directional meters, one for import and one for export, or a single
bi-directional meter1.
The Net Metering Rules also include the Interconnection standards, which
shall be complied with and observed by the net metering customer to address
engineering, electric system reliability, and safety concerns for net metering
interconnections, such as those concerning voltage level, frequency, and
power quality, and those relating to system protection.
1
Resolution No. 9, Series of 2013, Section 4 (n) Definitions
Methodology
A . EQ U I PM E NT U S E D
A power quality analyser was used to capture the behaviour of the voltage,
current, demand in kw and other power quality parameters.
- Fully Class-A
compliant: Conduct
tests according to the
stringent international
I EC 610 0 0 - 4 -3 0 C l a s s-A
standard
FIGURE 3.1
Power Quality Analyzer
1. Lighting 7. Spare
3. Lighting 9. ACU-4
M METER
INVERTER
1
INVERTER
2
BREAKER,
30A
2P
AC AC M
PV
PANEL
DC
DISCONNECT
Genera/on
Meter
B . M O N ITO R I N G D U R ATI O N
To verify any unwarranted effect of the RE facility to the distribution system,
three measurements were made: 1st was for the establishment of a baseline
data; 2nd and 3rd were conducted to check the system after the installation
of the RE source during the wet and dry season respectively.
Baseline Data
(Prior to installation of
Wet Season Dry Season
solar PV system)
Start of
January 16, 2013 July 30, 2013 April 30, 2014
Measurement
End of
January 23, 2013 August 6, 2013 May 7, 2014
Measurement
Parameters Measured
A . VO LTAG E VA R IATI O N
Voltage variation is the deviation of the root-mean-square (RMS) value of the
voltage from its nominal value, expressed in percent. The voltage variation
at the utilization level should be within ±10% of the nominal value limit1.
Maintaining the voltage level within the standard range is imperative to avoid
the following common power quality problems:
1
Philippine Distribution Code (PDC) Section 3.2.3.1
The total harmonic distortion (THD) is the industry standard used to measure
the level of harmonic distortion for voltage. Voltage THD is defined as the
ratio of the Root-Mean-Square (RMS) of the harmonic content to the RMS
value of the fundamental quantity, expressed in percent2 . The PDC requires
that voltage THD should not exceed 5% during normal operating conditions3.
The THD readings for the Baseline, Wet, and Dry Season are within the standard
threshold as shown in Figure 3.5.
2
PDC Section 3.2.4.2
3
PDC Section 3.2.4.4
The Flicker Severity at the Connection Point of any User shall not exceed 1.0
unit for short term (Pst) and 0.8 units for long term (Plt)4. Readings for Pst
(see Figure 3.6) and for Plt (see Figure 3.7) are within their respective standard
thresholds.
4
6.3.2 Net Metering Interconnection Standards, Annex A-1, ERC Resolution No 9, Series of 2013
D. FREQUENCY VARIATIONS
According to PDC 3.2.2.1, the nominal fundamental Frequency shall be 60Hz.
It should be maintained within the limits of 59.7 and 60.3 Hz during normal
conditions. Figure 3.8 shows the summary of the recorded Frequency. The
Frequency readings remained within the threshold set in the Net Metering
Interconnection Standards5.
Over frequency and under frequency may cause high core loss and overheating
of the machines and possible failure, lower equipment efficiency, increase or
reduction in speed of rotating machines, and increase in fault levels due to
the reduction of reactance.
5
6.2 Net Metering Interconnection Standards, Annex A-1, ERC Resolution No 9, Series of 2013
O V E R - A L L , T H E R E S U LT S O F T H E P O W E R Q U A L I T Y M O N I T O R I N G
RE V E A LED T HE A B SENCE OF A N Y U N WA RR A N T ED DIS T U RBA NCE
IN T RO D U C E D BY T H E R E FAC ILI T IE S TO T H E DIS T RIBU T IO N
SYSTEM. THROUGH THE PROPER DESIGN, SOLUTION AND
O P E R A T I O N O F T H E R E S Y S T E M , T H E V O LT A G E V A R I A T I O N ,
V O LT A G E T O T A L H A R M O N I C D I S T O R T I O N , L O N G A N D S H O R T
TERM FLICKER AND FREQUENCY FELL WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED
L I M I T S A F T E R T H E I N S TA L L AT I O N O F T H E R E S O U R C E .
1
De-‐energize
load
side
by
opening
the
main
breaker
Check
if
inverter
ceases
to
energize;
2
Hold
for
2
seconds
Record
time
when
inverter
re-‐synchronizes
3
Re-‐close
main
breaker
TABLE 3.2 Test Procedure for Anti-Islanding and Synchronization
Anti-Islanding Test
As shown in Figure 3.9, turning off the AC source from the distribution
network by opening the main breaker instantaneously disconnected the
inverter from grid. A quick "ON and OFF" (i.e. items 2 and 3 of Table 3.7) of
the AC source showed that the inverter remained disconnected from the
grid. This demonstrates the cease-to-energize functionality of the inverter.
1
7.5 Net Metering Interconnection Standards, Annex A-1, ERC Resolution No 9, Series of 2013
Synchronization Test
After turning "ON" the AC source from the grid (i.e. item 6 of Table 3.2), the
inverter was fully synchronized within 72 seconds which is shorter than the
minimum period of two (2) minutes set in the Interconnection Standards.
900
800
700
PV
GeneraEon
(kWh)
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Actual
Projected
Learnings and
Future Considerations
With the completion of the first year of Meralco’s Net Metering pilot study,
the team presents the following selected learnings and recommendations
based on its experience and observations in interconnecting a 6.16 kWp solar
PV system to the distribution system:
Since the pilot project scope was limited to a single installation, the study
may be expanded to cover several solar PV systems connected to a single
distribution transformer, so that the aggregate impact of multiple systems on
the operation of the distribution network may be assessed. The distribution
network needs to prepare for the increased adoption of end-use generation
and integration of these variable renewable energy while maintaining the
integrity and stability of the system.
With the pilot project and other initiatives to prepare for Net Metering, Meralco
is working towards continuously improving the Net Metering Program’s
implementation, especially, in terms of the assurance that the whole process
of installation and interconnection is done in a safe and efficient manner
– from the acquisition of quality products and components that conform
to industry and technical standards, contracting of accredited installers/
integrators, up to the actual interconnection and operation of the facility. All
these will redound to the protection of consumers, the distribution system’s
reliability, and the sustainability of the Net Metering Program.
1 2
E L EC T RO N I C
M E T E R D I S P L AY
The display of an electronic
meter is typically composed
of 5 parts which are as 5
follows:
C H EC K L I S T FO R I N S P EC T I O N A N D T E S T I N G O F S O L A R
P H O T OVO LTA I C ( P V ) G E N E R AT I O N SYS T E M FO R
N E T M E T E R I N G A P P L I C AT I O N S
Project/Customer Name:
Location:
PV Capacity (kWp):
Checklist for Commissioning of
Date Installed: Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Generation System for
PV Service Provider: Net Metering Applications
Project/Customer Name:
Location:
START-UP SYSTEM
PV Capacity (kWp):
Refer Date Installed: manual for the inverter and follow start-up procedure. This
to system
Date Commissioned:
generally involves turning on the PV DC main switch followed by the PV AC
PV Service Provider:
main switch but the procedures as recommended by the inverter manufacturer
must be followed.
procedures as recommended by the inverter manufacturer must be followed.
TEST YES NO
Date:
6. Initial reading of Generation Check
Time:
Meter
Reading: kWh
DECLARATION
PV Service Provider
Date / Signature over printed name
C H EC K L I S T FO R I N S P EC T I O N A N D T E S T I N G O F
S O L A R P H O T OVO LTA I C ( P V ) G E N E R AT I O N SYS T E M FO R
N E T M E T E R I N G A P P L I C AT I O N S
I. PHYSICAL INSPECTION
Project/Customer Name:
Location:
PV Capacity (kWp):
Date Installed:
PV Service Provider:
A. PV Array (DC Side). Disconnect the array string fuses and/or circuit
breakers. With the PV DC main switch OFF:
B. Inverter (AC Side). Ensure that the AC grid or normal supply is isolated and
the PV AC main switch is OFF:
C. Inverter Response Time. Refer to system manual for the inverter and follow
start-up procedure. This generally involves turning on the PV DC main switch
followed by the PV AC main switch but the procedures as recommended by
the inverter manufacturer must be followed.
PV Service Provider
Date / Signature over printed name
L I V E T E S T S I M U L AT I O N
1. Voltage Level. The PV system shall operate their facility to maintain the
same voltage level as Distribution System at the Connection Point.
- The voltage level is within the limits (refer to load logger data results)
3. Power Quality
3.2. Flicker Severity. The flicker severity at the Connection Point shall not
exceed 1.0 unit for short term and 0.8 units for long term as specified in
Section 3.2.6 of the PDC.
- The impact of PV inverters on flicker is generally low because a PV
inverter does not represent a considerable flicker source, as long as the
controller of the PV inverter is properly tuned. The inverter has this
characteristic.
M E R A LC O PI LOT PR O J E C T TE A M
U TI LIT Y E C O N O M I C S
Lawrence S. Fernandez
Anna Maria A. Reodica
Jan Jerome F. Kuizon
Julie B. Dulce
C O R PO R ATE B U S I N E S S G R O U P – TE C H N I CA L S U PPO RT
Rhonniel M. Caringal
M E TE R I N G S E RVI C E S AS S E T M A N AG E M E NT (M S A M)
Melchor Mateo L. Luber
LO G I STI C S PR O C E S S M A N AG E M E NT (LPM)
Ricardo L. Mendoza
Alexander L. Fandialan
C O R PO R ATE C O M M U N I CATI O N S
Ma. Teresita T. Bueno
Renee Joy F. Basa
Kevin Niccolo M. Kison
N E T W O R K AS S E T PL A N N I N G (N A P)
Froilan J. Savet
FAC I LITI E S M A N AG E M E NT
Christopher Martin H. Ocampo
Carlito L. Dela Cruz
S PE C IA L TH A N KS TO
D I STR I B U TI O N M A N AG E M E NT C O M M IT TE E
1 TITLE HERE