P a g e | 57

CHAPTER 5: THE MODIFIERS OF HUMAN ACTS

Marl Lechben O. Gaputan, MPA, LPT, S.O.

Contents:
1. Learning Outcomes
2. Modifiers of Human Acts
 Ignorance
 Simple Ignorance
 Invincible Ignorance
 Vincible Ignorance
 Affected Ignorance
 Passion
 Concupiscible Passions
o Love
o Hate
o Desire
 Irascible Passions
o Hope
o Despair
o Courage
 Sensible Passions
o Joy
o Sadness
o Anger
 Fear
 Servile Fear
 Filial Fear
 Initial Fear
 Violence
 Physical Violence
 Verbal Violence
 Psychological Violence
 Habit
 Good Habit (Virtue)
 Bad Habit (Vice)
 Mixed Habit
 Punishment
 Corrective Punishment
 Vindictive Punishment
 Preventive Punishment
 Protective Punishment
 Reward
 Natural Reward
 Artificial Reward
 Intention
 Direct Intention
 Indirect Intention
 P a g e | 58

 Circumstances
 Concomitant Circumstances
 Antecedent Circumstances
 Consequent Circumstances
 Consequences
 Foreseen Consequences
 Unforeseen Consequences
3. Activity No. 12 and 13
4. References

Learning Outcomes:
In the process and at the end of the discussion, learners must be
able to:
1. Understand the complexity of human behavior and moral
decision-making.
2. Recognize the influence of intentions on the moral nature
of actions.
3. Examine the impact of different conditions on the ethical
judgment of human acts.
4. Investigate the role of consequences in determining the
moral implications of acts.
5. Understand the interplay of virtues, vices, and habits in
ethical behavior.
6. Examine the function of rewards and penalties in moral
conduct motivation.
7. Learn about the significance of ethical principles in
personal and societal circumstances.
8. Develop critical thinking abilities in order to evaluate the
morality of human actions in a variety of scenarios.
9. Encourage empathy and compassion for others, taking into
account their circumstances and intentions.
10. Develop a sense of responsibility and accountability for
one's actions and how they affect others.
11. Learn about the moral components of human behavior and
decision-making, which will help individuals build a deeper
knowledge of ethics and ethical reasoning.
 P a g e | 59

“Our objectives, the situations we find ourselves in, and the results we
produce all have an impact on the essence of what we do
and how our character is built.”
-Marl Lechben O. Gaputan

Modifiers of Human Acts

Human acts are not evaluated in isolation in the realms of ethics

and moral theology, but in light of different elements that can
affect their moral quality. These factors, known as human act
modifiers, play an important role in influencing the overall
morality and responsibility of individual actions. Modifiers
complicate the ethical judgment of our choices by changing the
voluntariness, intention, and consequences of human behavior.
Understanding these modifiers enables us to analyze human
behavior in a more sophisticated manner, recognizing the
interplay between personal agency, external factors, and the
moral importance of our actions.

The following are 10 modifiers of human acts:

 Ignorance

Ignorance is defined as a lack of understanding or awareness

regarding the moral implications of a certain action. Simply
put, it is not knowing or understanding what is right or wrong
about what we do. Ignorance can significantly influence how
we are held ethically accountable for our acts.

Consider the case where a friend steals your notes to study

for an exam. Unbeknownst to you, they decide to completely
replicate your notes without giving you any credit. In this
case, if you are unaware that your friend has duplicated your
work without permission, your ignorance about their
dishonesty renders you uninformed. Because you did not
consciously participate in the act of cheating, you bear less
moral responsibility for your friend's actions.

Another example, assume that you unintentionally damage a

school property, such as a classroom desk, while attempting
to transport it. If you honestly didn't realize the desk was
delicate or readily breakable, your actions can be blamed on
ignorance. In this situation, your ignorance of the desk's
frailty minimizes your ethical responsibility because you did
not want to inflict injury.

There are four types of ignorance relevant to ethical

considerations in philosophy, these four types are called
 P a g e | 60

simple ignorance, invincible ignorance, vincible ignorance,

and affected ignorance.

 Simple ignorance refers to a lack of knowledge or

awareness regarding a specific moral issue or
circumstance. It occurs when a person is unaware of
the moral principles or ethical concerns pertinent to a
certain situation. Someone, for example, may be
oblivious of the environmental effects of their behavior
because they have not been exposed to climate change
knowledge.

 Invincible ignorance happens when a person lacks

knowledge or information despite making reasonable
efforts to gain it. In other words, the person is not to
blame for their ignorance because they have done
everything possible to become aware. In terms of ethics,
this form of ignorance may reduce moral responsibility
to some level. For example, while attempting to stay up
with legal developments, a person may unwittingly
violate a law because they were ignorant of recent
modifications to it.

 In contrast, vincible ignorance occurs when an

individual lacks knowledge or information as a result of
their own negligence or unwillingness to make
reasonable steps to become informed. This form of
ignorance does not reduce moral responsibility because
the individual could have prevented it with greater
attention. For example, if a person avoids reading about
the ethical implications of their business operations in
order to maintain plausible deniability, they are
demonstrating vincible ignorance.

 Affected ignorance, also known as willful ignorance,

arises when a person chooses to remain ignorant about
a topic while having access to information. For
example, suppose you are aware that some clothing
manufacturers use child labor in their manufacturing
processes, but you choose not to research whether your
favorite brand does as well. Your purposeful decision
not to investigate the topic exemplifies affected
ignorance.

The study of the four types of ignorance demonstrates that

ignorance is not a simple concept, ranging from unintended
ignorance to intentional evasion of information. In ethical
discourse, these distinctions are critical in assessing moral
obligation and culpability. We may negotiate difficult ethical
 P a g e | 61

challenges more deliberately and make educated judgments

that accord with our beliefs and the well-being of others if we
grasp the various varieties of ignorance. To foster a more
ethical and compassionate society, we must own our
ignorance and accept responsibility for learning. Considering
ignorance as a modifier of human acts emphasizes how our
level of information influences how we are morally evaluated.
It acts as a reminder of the significance of learning and being
aware of the potential consequences of our actions. Accepting
our ignorance allows us to make better informed and
responsible decisions, building a stronger sense of integrity
and ethical decision-making.

 Passion

Passion is defined as powerful emotions or deep feelings that

might impact our behavior and decisions. It is critical to
acknowledge that our emotions can have a substantial impact
on our actions and their ethical consequences.

Assume you earn a poor score on a critical exam, which has

an impact on your total course achievement. You confront
your instructor in the heat of the moment, expressing your
displeasure in an impatient manner, feeling overwhelmed
with rage and wrath. In this case, your intense desire to
improve your academic performance influenced your actions,
causing you to act emotionally rather than rationally. Such
intense feelings may impair your ability to deal with the
matter calmly and ethically.

Another example, consider you witness a fellow student being

bullied by a group of peers. You interfere to protect the victim
because you are outraged by the injustice, even if you may
not have a personal relationship with them. Your
compassionate response is motivated by empathy and a
feeling of justice, demonstrating how a strong desire to do the
right thing can positively impact your behavior.

There are three classifications of passion relevant to ethical

considerations in philosophy, these three classifications are
called concupiscible passions, irascible passions, and
sensible passions.

 Concupiscible passions are a set of emotions related to

our needs and appetites. These passions have a huge
impact on our actions and decision-making, even when
it comes to pursuing what we find appealing or avoiding
what we believe to be dangerous or undesirable. Love,
 P a g e | 62

hate, and desire are the three primary concupiscible

passions.

Love is a strong and positive emotion that draws us to

something we think good, appealing, or useful. It can
be the affection we feel for our family and friends,
romantic love for a partner, or even love for an interest
or a cause. For example, you may have a strong
attachment to your family, which inspires you to spend
time with them, support them in their goals, and
prioritize their well-being. A great example of love is the
love between parents and their children, where parents'
love motivates them to unconditionally care for and
protect their offspring.

Hate, on the other hand, is a negative emotion that

drives us away from what we consider to be harmful,
unpleasant, or dangerous. It might be a strong dislike
for a person, a circumstance, or an idea. Assume you
have an intense hatred for bullying, and when you
watch someone being abused, you feel an extreme hate
for the act of bullying and a strong desire to put an end
to it. Hatred can inspire us to act against injustice and
cruelty in the world.

Desire is a passion that occurs when we long for or wish

to acquire something that we find appealing. It could be
a tangible property, a social rank, or even a personal
accomplishment. For example, if you want to excel in
your studies, this desire might motivate you to work
hard, set objectives, and put in effort to achieve
academic achievement. Desire can be a powerful
motivator, pushing us to strive for our goals and realize
our dreams.

 Irascible passions are a set of emotions that govern how

we react to challenges, challenges, and unpleasant
situations. They have an important part in how we deal
with hardship and can have a considerable impact on
our moral decision-making. Hope, despair, and courage
are the three basic irascible passions.

Hope is a good and optimistic emotion that occurs when

we wish and anticipate a happy outcome in the midst
of difficulties or uncertainty. It is the belief that things
will improve or that we will be able to overcome
adversity. For example, if you're about to take a difficult
exam, hope can motivate you to study hard, believing
that your efforts will result in success. Another example
 P a g e | 63

is when someone is dealing with a medical problem but

maintains optimism that the treatment will result in
recovery, which can have a good impact on their healing
process.

In contrast, despair is a negative emotion that arises

when we feel overwhelmed and hopeless in the face of
hardship. It's the sense of giving up or that things will
never get better. For example, if you have a string of
failures and setbacks in your job ambitions, you may
experience despair and believe that success is
unattainable. Despair can be paralyzing and
demotivating, leading to inactivity and retreat from
pursuing one's objectives.

Courage is a powerful virtue that involves confronting

obstacles even when they are accompanied by fear or
danger. It is the ability to act bravely and do what is
right, despite the risks involved. Standing up for
someone who is being bullied, for example, requires
courage because it involves potential conflict or
reaction from others. Courage is required in numerous
areas of life, including pursuing personal growth,
speaking up for justice, and facing difficult decisions
with integrity.

 Sensible passions are a type of emotions that are

caused by external events or experiences. These
emotions are closely tied to our sensory impressions
and can have a substantial impact on our moral
decision-making and behavior. Joy, sadness, and anger
are the three major sensible passions.

Joy is a positive, happy sensation that arises when we

encounter something delightful, delicious, or gratifying.
When something positive happens to ourselves or
others, we get a sense of satisfaction and fulfillment.
Receiving excellent news about acing a test or being
accepted into a dream college, for example, can make
you happy. Simple pleasures, such as spending quality
time with loved ones or watching a lovely sunset, can
also bring joy.

Sadness is a negative feeling that arises as a result of

loss, disappointment, or discontent. It is the sensation
of sadness or discomfort that we experience when
something does not go as planned or when we confront
difficult conditions. For example, if you learn of the
death of a loved one or experience a breakup in a
 P a g e | 64

relationship, you may feel sad. Sadness is a natural

reaction to challenging situations that allows us to
understand and accept our emotions.

Anger is a strong and intense feeling that occurs when

we are provoked, intimidated, or treated unfairly. When
we observe unfairness or injury, we feel frustrated,
irritated, or offended. Witnessing someone being
mistreated or experiencing discrimination, for example,
can cause rage. Anger can be a motivating force for
taking action and addressing injustices, but it also
requires emotional management in order to avoid
damaging or aggressive behaviors.

The three various types of passion are critical to our

emotional and moral experiences, influencing our actions,
decisions, and reactions to diverse events. Understanding and
navigating these emotions is important in ethical disputes
because they influence our intentions, behaviors, and moral
character. We can harness the great features of these
interests while avoiding their potential pitfalls by developing
self-awareness and emotional intelligence, establishing a
more compassionate, just, and morally responsible
connection with the world around us. Understanding passion
as a modifier of human acts allows us to realize how our
emotions influence decision-making, pushing us to be careful
of our emotions and stop before behaving rashly. This
awareness aids in the development of emotional intelligence,
which leads to more thoughtful and ethical actions in a
variety of settings. We strengthen our capacity for empathy,
generosity, and moral responsibility by positively channeling
our passions, which contributes to a more ethical community
and beyond.

 Fear

Fear is the emotional response we have when confronted with

perceived threats or hazards. It has a significant impact on
how we behave and the ethical implications of our judgments.

Consider the possibility of presenting your research findings

in front of a large audience at an academic conference.
However, you are possessed by extreme stage fright and are
terrified of public speaking. As a result, you decline the
opportunity, passing up an important opportunity to share
your expertise and progress academically. Fear affects your
capacity to make a confident judgment in this scenario,
harming both your personal progress and the potential
contribution you could have made.
 P a g e | 65

Another example, assume you watch someone being bullied

by a group of aggressive peers. Fear of retaliation or becoming
a target yourself may discourage you from intervening to
assist the victim. Although you are sympathetic and want to
do the right thing, fear clouds your judgment and prevents
you from acting. Fear alters your human conduct in this case
by reducing your readiness to speak out against injustice.

In ethics, there are three basic types of fear that can impact
human behavior and moral decision-making under the
modifier of human acts.

 Servile fear is a type of fear caused by the threat of

punishment or damage. It is the fear of retribution or
retribution for one's conduct. A person may stop from
stealing because they are afraid of getting caught and
facing legal consequences.

 Filial fear, often referred to as reverential fear, is a fear

that arises from love and respect for authority or a
higher force. It is the fear of upsetting or acting against
the will of someone or something highly regarded. For
example, a religious individual may avoid dishonesty
out of filial fear of offending their deity or divine figure.

 Initial fear is a normal hesitation or worry that emerges

before completing a morally significant action. This fear
is not always unpleasant; rather, it causes a person to
think about the potential consequences of their actions
and if they are acting ethically.

These sorts of fear influence human behavior and decision-

making in various ways. Understanding and navigating the
influence of fear on our moral behavior is frequently involved
in ethical issues, since fear can either hinder or inspire
virtuous behaviors. To live a morally responsible and virtuous
life, it is necessary to strike a balance between acceptable fear
and behaving in accordance with ethical standards.

Understanding fear as a modifier of human acts is critical in

making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the significance of
acknowledging and resolving our anxieties in order to avoid
limiting our potential or compromising our ethical ideals.
Recognizing fear as a modifier allows us to grow courage and
resilience, allowing us to make better educated,
compassionate, and ethical decisions even in difficult
situations. We may harness our anxieties' energy productively
by recognizing and confronting them, propelling us toward
 P a g e | 66

personal growth and a more ethical interaction with the world

around us.

 Violence

Violence is defined as the use of physical force or aggression

to cause hurt, injury, or damage to others. It has a significant
impact on how we act and the ethical implications of our
judgments.

Assume you witness a heated argument between two

classmates that evolves into a violent brawl. In the heat of the
argument, one student punches the other, resulting in
injuries. The use of violence in this case significantly modifies
the ethical nature of the act, as physical injury is inflicted on
another person. Such an act of violence not only affects the
victim but also violates the ethical decision-making standards
of respect, compassion, and non-harm.

Another example, consider a scenario in which you and your

buddies are participating in a competitive sport at a college
event. The enthusiasm and competitive spirit mount, and one
of your pals loses control and exhibits aggressive conduct
toward the opposition team, turning to verbal insults and
intimidation. In this case, using violence to obtain a
competitive edge changes the human act and negatively
impacts the values of sportsmanship and fair play.

There are three primary types of violence in ethics that are

relevant to debates about moral action under the modifiers of
human acts.

 Physical violence is defined as the use of force,

compulsion, or aggressiveness to cause harm or injury
to another person or living entity. It includes activities
that cause bodily harm, such as hitting, punching,
kicking, or any other sort of forceful physical contact.
Physical violence is universally acknowledged as
ethically reprehensible and is condemned in most
ethical frameworks and legal systems.

For example, a person engages in a physical altercation

with another individual, resulting in pain or injury, is
one example of physical violence. Bodily aggression
inflicts pain and injury, resulting in not just bodily
injuries but also emotional and psychological distress.

 Verbal violence is the use of abusive language, threats,

or intimidation to inflict emotional or mental harm on
 P a g e | 67

another. Although this sort of violence does not use

physical force, it can nonetheless have a severe and
long-lasting impact on the victim's well-being and self-
esteem. Negative communication such as name-calling,
insults, humiliation, relentless criticism, and
humiliating statements are examples of verbal violence.

A supervisor, for example, who regularly belittles and

humiliates their subordinates, using insulting words
and personal assaults, is indulging in verbal violence.
Victims of this type of abuse may endure depression,
anxiety, and a loss in job performance, resulting in a
toxic work environment.

 Psychological violence extends beyond verbal

aggression to include a broader variety of damaging
acts that attack a person's feelings, self-worth, and
mental well-being. It entails manipulating, controlling,
or undermining someone's psychological and emotional
state. Gaslighting, emotional manipulation, threats of
damage, and separating someone from their support
networks are all examples of psychological violence.

In an intimate relationship, for example, one spouse

may commit psychological violence by methodically
ruining the other person's self-esteem, isolating them
from friends and family, and employing manipulative
tactics to maintain control and authority over the
victim. This type of abuse can have serious
psychological implications, causing the victim to
experience worry, depression, and a sense of
helplessness.

Both verbal and psychological aggression are unacceptable in

ethical considerations because they undermine an
individual's dignity and well-being. Ethical principles
frequently emphasize the need of treating others with respect,
love, and compassion, as well as condemning any form of
aggression or mental or physical harm to others. Promoting
nonviolent communication and developing healthy,
supportive relationships are critical components of creating
an ethical and caring society.

Understanding violence as a modifier of human acts is critical

in making ethical decisions. It is a sharp reminder of the
significance of seeking peaceful and non-harmful solutions to
problems and challenges that we face. Being aware of violence
as a modifier allows us to develop empathy, conflict resolution
skills, and a dedication to nonviolent interactions. We may
 P a g e | 68

contribute to a safer, more inclusive, and ethically

conscious community and society at large by creating a
culture of respect and empathy.

 Habit

Habits are patterns of behavior that we form through time as

a result of repeated acts. It has a significant impact on how
we behave and the ethical implications of our judgments.

Assume you have a habit of delaying assignments and leaving

them until the final possible moment. As a result, you
frequently deliver hurried and poor work, harming your
academic success. This deliberate delay alters your human
act by compromising your commitment to excellence and
diligence in your academics.

Another example, consider a scenario in which you have

formed the practice of actively listening to and valuing your
classmates' different viewpoints during group discussions.
This practice promotes a welcoming and courteous learning
environment by fostering open discourse and collaboration.
This practice of attentively listening and respecting others
changes your human behavior, resulting in an ethical and
empathic approach to relationships with peers.

There are three primary types of habit that are significant to

debates of moral behavior in ethics, under the modifiers of
human acts.

 Good habit, sometimes referred to as virtue, is a

constant, positive behavioral characteristic that
encourages someone to regularly act morally and make
moral decisions. Over time, virtues are cultivated by a
person's repeated good deeds and become embedded in
their personality. Virtues like honesty, bravery,
compassion, integrity, and patience are examples. The
cultivation of virtues results in moral excellence and
enhances both individual and societal wellbeing.

 Bad habit, usually referred to as a vice, is a consistent,

unfavorable disposition or character feature that leads
someone to consistently act immorally and make bad
decisions. Repeated behaviors that are damaging,
immoral, or at odds with moral standards can also lead
to vices. Dishonesty, greed, arrogance, brutality, and
laziness are a few vices. Vices can degrade morals and
hurt both the individual and others.
 P a g e | 69

 Mixed habit is a blend of positive and harmful habits

within a person. People might demonstrate both
virtuous and vicious tendencies in various aspects of
their life or situations. For example, someone may be
kind and friendly to their friends but suffer with
dishonesty in business deals. A mixed habit denotes
that a person's moral nature is neither fully virtuous
nor entirely evil, but rather a combination of the two.

The establishment and cultivation of good habits or virtues

and the avoidance of bad habits or vices are essential factors
in ethical discourse for living a morally responsible and
fulfilled life. Ethical theories frequently highlight the
importance of developing virtuous character and encouraging
the practice of virtuous activities in order to positively
contribute to one's own well-being and the well-being of
others in society.

Understanding habit as a modifier of human acts is critical in

making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the importance of
developing beneficial habits that match with our ethical ideals
and ideas. Being conscious of habit as a modifier allows us to
reflect on our daily behaviors and establish intentional habits
that contribute to our personal and ethical development. We
can cultivate a more ethical and responsible attitude to
decision-making and interactions by creating positive habits,
which will have a positive impact on ourselves and people
around us.

 Punishment

Punishment refers to the negative consequences or

punishments that can be inflicted on persons for behaviors
that are morally wrong or violate established standards. It has
a significant impact on how we behave and the ethical
implications of our judgments.

Consider the temptation to participate in academic

dishonesty and cheat on an exam. You are aware, however,
that if you are detected, the consequences will be severe, such
as expulsion or a failing grade. The fear of penalty acts as a
modifier on your human conduct, discouraging cheating and
guiding you to make an ethical decision that maintains
academic integrity.

Now, consider a situation in which you see someone bullying

another student and have the opportunity to intervene and
stop the bullying. Regardless of the personal risks, you chose
to speak up against the bully and defend the victim. Your view
 P a g e | 70

in the significance of standing up for what is right, even if

punishment or retaliation is possible, influences your courage
to act against the bully's damaging actions.

There are four types of punishment in ethics that are

significant to debates or discussions about moral behavior
and accountability under the modifiers of human acts.

 Corrective punishment, also known as reformative

punishment, strives to correct the wrongdoer's
behavior and rehabilitate them. The emphasis is on
assisting the individual in understanding the
consequences of their actions, addressing the
underlying causes of their wrongdoing, and directing
them toward positive transformation. This sort of
punishment is frequently used in the criminal justice
system to encourage the offender's moral and social
growth and lessen the likelihood of future offending.

A scenario in which a student is detected cheating on a

test is an example of corrective punishment. When the
instructor discovers the cheating, he or she decides to
impose a corrective punishment to address the problem
and help the student understand the value of academic
integrity. Instead of resorting to harsh punishments
right away, the instructor decides to use a restorative
approach. The student must meet with the instructor
to explain why they cheated, the possible consequences
of their actions, and how they might make apologies. As
part of the corrective penalty, the student may be
required to retake the test without the use of any aid or
incorrect methods. The purpose of this punishment is
to guide the student toward understanding the value of
honesty, learning from their mistakes, and committing
to ethical behavior in the future, rather than simply
punishing them. This strategy tries to correct behavior,
teach accountability, and create a good learning
atmosphere.

 Vindictive punishment, also known as retributive

punishment, is founded on the notion of giving the
wrongdoer what they "deserve" for their immoral deeds.
As a sort of "eye for an eye" justice, the emphasis is on
retribution and restoring moral order by inflicting
injury or suffering on the wrongdoer. Vindictive
punishment tries to balance the scales and satisfy the
victims' or society's sense of justice.
 P a g e | 71

A student who engages in disruptive behavior in the

classroom is an example of vindictive punishment.
Despite repeated warnings and interventions, the
student continues to disrupt the learning environment
by shouting loudly, throwing things, and failing to
follow directions. In response, the instructor decides to
use vindictive punishment to address the disruptive
behavior and restore classroom order. The student will
be sent to the guidance councilor's office, where they
will receive a detention and a written warning.
Furthermore, the instructor informs the student's
parents about the offense, which may result in
additional repercussions at home. The goal of this
vindictive punishment is to "get back" at the student for
their disruptive behavior by inflicting consequences
that appear to be retribution. While this type of
punishment may satisfy the instructor's and the
classroom's learning environment's sense of justice, it
may not necessarily focus on altering the student's
behavior or addressing the underlying causes of their
behaviors.

 Preventive punishment, also known as deterrent

punishment, is meant to discourage others from
committing similar wrongdoing. The major goal of this
type of punishment is not to rehabilitate the wrongdoer
or to exact retribution, but to serve as a warning or
example to others, discouraging them from engaging in
immoral activity by demonstrating the bad
consequences.

Addressing bullying behavior is an example of

preventive punishment. Assume a student has been
spotted constantly bullying and intimidating other
students. The school administration understands the
importance of preventing future incidents of bullying
and discouraging others from engaging in similar
behavior. As a deterrent, the school institutes an anti-
bullying program that includes educational workshops,
presentations, and conversations about the negative
impact of bullying on people and the school community.

Additionally, the bullied student must attend

counseling sessions with a school counselor or
psychologist to comprehend the motivations behind
their actions, cultivate empathy, and improve their
interpersonal skills. The school may also set up a
procedure for reporting incidents of bullying to
encourage students to come forward.
 P a g e | 72

By putting these safeguards in place, the school hopes

to stop bullying in its tracks, encourage a respectful
and safe learning environment, and inform students
about the negative effects of such behavior. In this
situation, preventive punishment focuses on more than
just penalizing the offender, it also aims to address the
underlying issues that led to the behavior, educate the
entire student body, and promote an environment of
respect and empathy.

 Protective punishment, also known as defensive

punishment, strives to defend society from the
damaging actions of the perpetrator. This sort of
punishment is removing the offender from the society
or subjecting them to restrictive confines in order to
avoid additional harm. Protective punishment, which
may include measures like as jail or home arrest, is
primarily concerned with ensuring the safety and well-
being of others.

An instance where a student's behavior endangers the

safety and wellbeing of others could serve as an
illustration of protective punishment. Let's imagine a
student has been acting violently and aggressively
toward other students, harming them physically and
making other students fearful. The administration of
the school is aware of the need to offer a safe learning
environment for students as well as faculty.

The school may choose to temporarily prohibit the

aggressive student from participating in regular classes
and socializing with other students as a kind of
preventative discipline. Instead, a separate space may
be designated for the student where they could receive
specialized education and counseling. This preventative
strategy makes sure the student's actions don't hurt
other people while enabling the school to address any
underlying problems that might be causing their anger.

Involving the student's parents or legal guardians in

creating a plan to address their behavior and providing
the required assistance may also be part of the
protective punishment. By using support systems,
intervention, and counseling, this strategy seeks to
address and minimize the aggressive behavior while
simultaneously ensuring the safety and wellbeing of all.

Arguments about ethics frequently focus on the aims and

reasons of punishment in a variety of circumstances ranging
 P a g e | 73

from personal interactions to legal and societal structures.

The sort of punishment used can have a substantial impact
on individuals' moral development, communal well-being,
and the promotion of a just and caring society.

Understanding punishment as a modifier of human acts is

critical in making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the need of
thinking about the implications of our actions and the impact
of prospective sanctions on our conduct. Being aware of
punishment as a modifier empowers us to make considered
and responsible decisions that line with our ethical
convictions, especially in difficult situations. We may develop
a feeling of integrity, fairness, and compassion in our
relationships and contribute to a more ethical and supportive
community by putting ethical considerations over avoiding
punishment.

 Reward

Reward is a term used to describe the favorable results or

incentives we anticipate or obtain for taking particular
behaviors. It significantly affects how we act and how our
choices have an ethical impact.

Consider the possibility of cheating on a test, which might

result in a higher mark with no effort. The possibility of an
improved grade acts as a satisfying motivation. However, if
you succumb to the lure of the reward, you endanger your
moral values and academic integrity. Your human behavior is
altered by the desire for the reward, causing you to make a
choice that can have a bad impact on your reputation and
character.

Now imagine you offer to help struggling classmates without

expecting any kind of compensation or reward. Your
motivation is fueled by the satisfaction that comes from
seeing others succeed and by making a contribution to a
welcoming learning environment. Helping others makes a
positive change in how you behave as a human being, leading
you to make moral decisions that promote empathy and
group support.

Reward, as a modifier of human acts, has two types, the

natural reward and the artificial reward.

 Natural reward, in a school setting, it could be when a

teacher praises and recognizes a student for their
constant hard work and academic accomplishments.
 P a g e | 74

For instance, imagine a student who consistently puts

in extra effort to complete assignments, actively
participates in class discussions, and helps classmates
understand difficult concepts. The instructor or
professor notices this dedication and publicly praises
the student's efforts during a class session. The
recognition and positive feedback from the instructor or
professor serve as a natural reward, reinforcing the
student's intrinsic motivation to continue working hard
and contributing positively to the learning
environment. This natural reward enhances the
student's sense of accomplishment, self-esteem, and
satisfaction, fostering a positive attitude towards their
studies and encouraging them to maintain their
diligent approach to learning.

 Artificial reward, on the other hand, it could be a

student receiving a gift card or a certificate of
recognition for their exceptional work in a particular
topic or extracurricular activity. For instance, imagine
a science fair competition where students present their
research projects. One student's project stands out for
its creativity, thorough research, and presentation
skills. As an artificial reward, the school awards this
student a certificate of excellence and a gift card to a
bookstore as a recognition of their achievement.

This artificial reward is an external motivation created

to recognize and inspire the student's exceptional
achievement, in contrast to natural rewards that result
from the inherent satisfaction of the activity itself.
While the student's intrinsic drive may have inspired
them to achieve brilliance in their assignment, the
artificial incentive provides an additional layer of
external acknowledgment and a concrete advantage
that might encourage them to pursue academic success
in the future.

Understanding reward as a modifier of human acts is critical

in making ethical decisions. It encourages us to consider the
motivations behind our actions as well as the potential
repercussions of seeking rewards. Being conscious of reward
as a modifier enables us to match our decisions with our
ethical ideals, focusing on intrinsic rewards such as personal
growth, altruism, and community well-being. We can create a
sense of integrity and accountability in our decision-making
and positively contribute to the world around us by
prioritizing ethical considerations over external rewards.
 P a g e | 75

 Intention

Intention is the purpose or motive underlying our activities,

the "why" we do what we do. It is crucial in shaping how we
behave and the ethical implications of our decisions.

Assume you volunteer to assist a suffering friend with their

homework not because you honestly want to help them, but
because you want to impress the instructor or gain favor.
Here, your desire for personal benefit or recognition alters
your human act, making it less ethical because it lacks
sincerity and genuine concern for the well-being of your
classmate.

Now, consider lending money to a classmate who is in

financial need with the purpose of actually assisting them out
of compassion and empathy. In this scenario, your purpose
to aid a classmate in need transforms your human act,
transforming it into an ethical choice motivated by kindness
and a desire to be of service.

Intention, as a modifier of human actions, comes in two

different forms, direct intention and indirect intention.

 Direct intention, for example, could be a student taking

part in an outreach effort planned by the school's
community service club. The student's clear and
conscious purpose is to contribute their time and effort
to help a local charity organization. Their intention is
aligned with the goal of making a positive impact on the
community and supporting those in need. The
student's active engagement and commitment to the
volunteer event reflect their direct intention to be of
service and to contribute to the betterment of others'
lives.

 Indirect intention, on the other hand, could be a

student who decides to join a sports team primarily to
improve their physical fitness and overall well-being.
Although the student's primary goals are to maintain a
healthy lifestyle and engage in regular physical activity,
making new friends and developing collaboration skills
may come about as a result of their involvement in the
sports team. Even if making friends was not the main
reason for joining the team, it was anticipated and is in
line with the student's general wellbeing. In this case,
the student's indirect intention is concerned with the
potential social advantages of engaging in a team
 P a g e | 76

activity, while their direct purpose is on improving their

own health.

Understanding intention as a modifier of human acts is

critical in making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the
necessity of focusing on our motivations and investigating the
underlying causes of our behavior. Being aware of intention
as a modifier empowers us to foster self-awareness and
integrity, allowing us to make decisions that accord with our
ethical values and principles. We may contribute to a more
caring, responsible, and principled community and make a
good impact on the world around us by prioritizing sincere
and ethical intentions in our decisions.

 Circumstances

Circumstances are the exact context, settings, or conditions

under which our actions occur. They are critical in defining
the moral character and ethical implications of our decisions.

Assume you witness a fellow student cheating on a test by

copying answers from another student. Later, you learn that
the student was under enormous stress owing to personal
circumstances and felt overwhelmed by academic
responsibilities. The conditions underlying their cheating
deed may include emotional discomfort and a sense of
despair. Understanding the circumstances can change your
impression of the student's behavior, allowing you to
empathize with their difficulties while also recognizing the
ethical offense.

Now, consider a circumstance in which a classmate stole your

notes without your permission and you confronted them
angrily in front of others. Your classmate, unknowingly to
you, had misplaced their own notes and was worrying about
not being prepared for the class discussion. The
circumstances of their conduct disclose their desperate
problem, altering your human act and making your reply
appear less empathic and more emotionally heated.

As a modifier of human acts, circumstances has three types

or forms, the concomitant circumstances, the antecedent
circumstances, and the consequent circumstances.

 A student who is taking a difficult arithmetic test could

be an example of concomitant circumstances. The time
of day, the setting of the classroom, and the presence
of other students in the classroom could all be
considered concomitant circumstances in this case.
 P a g e | 77

The time of day becomes a concomitant factor that can

affect the student's performance if the test is set in the
afternoon when they are more likely to feel tired.
Similarly, if the classroom is noisy due to ongoing
construction nearby, the environment becomes a
concomitant circumstance that could affect the
student's concentration and focus. Additionally, the
presence of classmates who are visibly anxious might
contribute to a heightened atmosphere of stress. These
concomitant circumstances play a role in shaping the
student's experience and performance during the test,
providing additional context beyond the content of the
exam itself.

 The choice of a student to take part or participate in an

after-school tutoring program is an example of
antecedent circumstances. Let's assume that the
student chooses to enrol in the program because they
have previously had difficulty learning a certain subject
and wish to get better grades. The student's prior
academic difficulties, desire for progress, and
awareness of the need for further support are all
antecedent factors in this situation. These antecedent
variables have an impact on the student's motivation,
goals, and behavior before they decide to enrol in the
tutoring program. The setting in which the student
seeks out the tutoring program as a means of
addressing their academic difficulties and achieving
their educational goals is shaped by the antecedent
circumstances.

 A student who consistently completes their homework

assignments on time and actively participates in class
discussions and class activities is an example of a
consequent circumstance. As a result of their constant
efforts, they may receive praise and recognition from
the teacher, receive high grades on assignments and
tests, and establish a positive reputation among
classmates for their diligence. These beneficial
outcomes are the result of the student's responsible
behavior and active participation in their education.
The favorable consequences boost the student's
motivation to continue their hard work and active
involvement, resulting in a positive reinforcement cycle
that contributes to their academic achievement and
overall educational experience.

Understanding circumstances as a modifier of human acts is

critical in making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the
 P a g e | 78

significance of recognizing the larger context of our own and

others' actions. Being aware of circumstances as a modifier
helps us to cultivate empathy and discernment, allowing us
to make more compassionate and understanding decisions.
We may contribute to a more thoughtful, sympathetic, and
inclusive community by recognizing how circumstances can
influence actions, establishing an environment that supports
ethical decision-making and understanding.

 Consequences

Consequences are the outcomes or results of our decisions

and activities. They are crucial in shaping how we behave and
the ethical implications of our decisions.

Assume you have a group project with a deadline, and one of

your team members is routinely missing meetings and failing
to perform their tasks. You decide to exclude them from the
project and complete it without their involvement since you
are frustrated by their lack of effort. Your decision could
result in a poorer mark for the absent member and damage
your team dynamics. Your assessment of the potential
implications alters your human act, guiding you to make an
ethical decision that values accountability and teamwork.

Now, consider a friend requests for your assistance in

cheating on an exam, saying that you will not be detected and
that there will be no negative consequences. The immediate
benefit of a higher mark may be appealing, but you know that
the long-term consequences of academic dishonesty may
include a tarnished reputation, academic penalties, and a
weakened sense of integrity. Thinking about the
repercussions changes your human behavior, causing you to
choose ethical principles over short-term profits.

As a modifier of human acts, consequences has two forms,

the foreseen consequences and the unforeseen consequences.

 A student opting to devote additional time and effort to

studying for a crucial final exam is an example of
foreseen consequence. Their decision may result in a
better knowledge of the subject matter, better exam
performance, and possibly higher grades. The student
understands that putting in more study time will result
in better comprehension and a higher chance of
passing the exam. These anticipated effects act as
motivation for the student to put the necessary time
and energy into their preparation, with the objective of
 P a g e | 79

reaching a positive outcome in terms of academic

performance.

 Unforeseen consequences could include a student

sharing their notes and study materials with a
classmate who missed numerous classes due to illness.
Unexpected outcomes of this helpful gesture could
include the classmate feeling more confident and
prepared for the forthcoming test, performing well on
the exam, and eventually becoming a close study buddy
and friend. The student who shared their notes may not
have expected their act of kindness to result in a great
study relationship and a significant friendship. These
beneficial effects were neither anticipated nor expected,
hence they were unintended repercussions of the initial
decision to help a classmate in need.

Understanding consequences as a modifier of human acts is

critical in making ethical decisions. It emphasizes the
significance of considering the consequences of our actions
on ourselves and others. Being aware of consequences as a
modifier equips us to build foresight and responsibility,
allowing us to make more informed and principled decisions.
We may contribute to a more ethical, responsible, and
accountable community of people living together in harmony
by emphasizing ethical considerations or contemplation over
instant enjoyment, establishing an environment that values
honesty, empathy, and responsible decision-making.

In conclusion, investigating the many modifiers of human acts

has supplied us with vital insights into the diverse nature of
ethical decision-making. We have seen how ignorance, passion,
fear, violence, habit, punishment, reward, intention,
circumstances, and consequences all have a substantial impact
on the moral quality and ethical implications of our decisions and
acts. Understanding these modifiers enables us to make better
informed, sensitive, and responsible decisions. We can create a
more principled and empathic attitude to moral dilemmas by
reflecting on our motivations, recognizing external influences,
and contemplating the larger context of our acts. By embracing
these principles, we have the opportunity to establish a more
ethical community, one that promotes honesty, empathy, and
collective well-being, while also constructively contributing to the
world outside of our academic pursuits.