PGDT 412 Unt 1 To 3
PGDT 412 Unt 1 To 3
Introduction
This unit deals with concept of growth and development, stages of development, determinants of,
dimensions of development in general and relates these with the developmental profiles of the students
and their implications for learning. The major domains of development we need to study as secondary
school teachers are changes of the body and its different parts (i.e. physical development), the growth
of the mind (i.e. cognitive development), improvement of relations with others (i.e. social
development), changes in emotional control (i.e. emotional development), understanding and
acceptance of moral values (i.e. moral development), and changes in identity (i.e. personality
development). As high school teachers, we need to develop grasp of the salient features of these
changes, how they affect students‟ learning, and how we can facilitate learning to occur in a better
way.
Unit Objectives
Upon completion of this unit, the students shall
Understand concepts of growth and development, dimensions, stages, and determinants of development
Understand major developmental changes, factors affecting these changes
Explain the implications of these changes for classroom teaching and learning
Appreciate the importance of developmental changes in structuring the teaching act
Use these changes as a foundation to design, plan , and conduct the teaching and learning act
Unit Contents
1.1. Physical development 1.3. Moral development
1.2. Cognitive development 1.4. Gender development
Kohlberg was not interested so much in the answer to the question of whether Heinz was wrong or
right, but in the reasoning for each participant's decision. The responses were then classified into
various stages of reasoning in his theory of moral development.
1.3.2. Levels and Stages of moral development
1. Pre-conventional Morality
Stage 1 - Obedience and Punishment፡ The earliest stage of moral development is especially
common in young children, but adults are also capable of expressing this type of reasoning. At this
stage, children see rules as fixed and absolute. Obeying the rules is important because it is a means to
avoid punishment.
Stage 2 - Individualism and Exchange፡ At this stage of moral development, children account for
individual points of view and judge actions based on how they serve individual needs. In the Heinz
dilemma, children argued that the best course of action was the choice that best-served Heinz‟s needs.
Reciprocity is possible at this point in moral development, but only if it serves one's own interests.
Level 2. Conventional Morality
Stage 3 - Interpersonal Relationships፡ Often referred to as the "good boy-good girl" orientation, this
stage of moral development is focused on living up to social expectations and roles. There is an
emphasis on conformity, being "nice," and consideration of how choices influence relationships.
Stage 4 - Maintaining Social Order፡ At this stage of moral development, people begin to consider
society as a whole when making judgments. The focus is on maintaining law and order by following
the rules, doing one‟s duty and respecting authority.
Level 3.Postconventional Morality
Stage 5 - Social Contract and Individual Rights፡ At this stage, people begin to account for the
differing values, opinions and beliefs of other people. Rules of law are important for maintaining a
society, but members of the society should agree upon these standards.
Stage 6 - Universal Principles፡ Kohlberg‟s final level of moral reasoning is based upon universal
ethical principles and abstract reasoning. At this stage, people follow these internalized principles of
justice, even if they conflict with laws and rules.
1.3.3. Identification with Role Models that affects moral development of adolescents:
1. Parents: The first positive role model that any child should have is a parent. Nevertheless, many
parents fail to realize the value of modeling positive behavior to their children. They may try to instill
certain standards of behavior in their children, but children are more likely to imitate the behavior they
observe in a parent than to listen to any regulations that a parent hopes to impose (see Reference 2). As
a child grows into adolescence, his role models may be as diverse as musicians, friends or even
politicians. While his choice of role models may appear to be reckless or misguided, he is likely to
seek role models who demonstrate behavior that is consistent with the types of behavior modeled by
his parents or caregivers.
2. Peer Pressure: Peer pressure is often considered to be a negative force in the life of a teen.
Indeed, most teens will not choose to engage in negative behaviors such as smoking or premarital sex
unless coaxed to do so by her peers. Still, peer pressure often exerts a positive influence on the life of a
teen. Often, teens will provide support to one another in times of stress. For example, if a teen is
considering committing suicide, her friends will usually be the first to tell her that life is worth living.
1.3.4. Criticisms of Kohlberg's Theory of Moral Development:
Does moral reasoning necessarily lead to moral behavior? Kohlberg's theory is concerned with
moral thinking, but there is a big difference between knowing what we ought to do versus our
actual actions.
2.1. Behaviorist learning theories (design instruction, teaching, classroom management and
behavior modification)
The understanding of the behaviorist theories, particularly classical and operant conditioning uses to
analyze teaching. In the analysis, the quality of learning that is facilitated by this teaching approach is
considered.
Unconditioned stimulus (UCS) is a stimulus that can produce the response without any learning. •
Example: Meat.
Conditioned stimulus (CS) is stimulus acquired the ability to produce the response because it was
paired (associated) with the unconditioned stimulus. • Example: Bell.
Conditioned response (CR) is a response that is produced by the conditioned stimulus • Example:
Salivation due to the bell.
The Common Phenomena in Classical Conditioning are generalization, discrimination, and extinction.
Generalization Generalization occurs when similar stimuli to a CS produce the CR. A student may
generalize his fear to physics and chemistry tests although he had performed poorly
only on mathematics test. In this case, the physics and chemistry tests were similar
stimuli to the mathematics test and they produced the CR by themselves.
Discrimination Discrimination is the opposite of generalization. It refers to the ability to differentiate
between similar stimuli. For example, a student may feel fear during mathematics
test but not during physics or chemistry tests. This shows that the student is able to
discriminate between appropriate and in appropriate situations for a response.
Extinction Extinction is the process of unlearning a learned response because of the removal of
the original source of learning. In classical conditioning, extinction is done by
repeatedly presenting the CS without the US. This action will decrease the frequency
of previously CR. Eventually, the CR disappears. In the example mentioned above, if
the student repeatedly passes the mathematics tests, his fear of mathematics tests will
disappear.
Classification The ability to group objects together on the basis of common features.
Class Inclusion The understanding more advanced than simple classification, that some classes or sets of
objects are also sub-sets of a larger class. (E.g. there is a class of objects called dogs. There is
also a class called animals. But all dogs are also animals, so the class of animals includes that
of dogs)
Conservation The realization that objects or sets of objects stay the same even when they are changed about
or made to look different.
Decentration The ability to move away from one system of classification to another one as appropriate.
Egocentrism The belief that you are the centre of the universe and everything revolves around you: the
corresponding inability to see the world as someone else does and adapt to it. Not moral
"selfishness", just an early stage of psychological development.
Operation The process of working something out in your head. Young children (in the sensorimotor and
pre-operational stages) have to act, and try things out in the real world, to work things out
(like count on fingers): older children and adults can do more in their heads.
Schema (or The representation in the mind of a set of perceptions, ideas, and/or actions, which go
scheme) together.
Figure 2.2.1: Gestalt saw that the whole is different from the sum of the parts
Gestalt psychology
- is a theory of mind and brain that proposes that the operational principle of the brain is holistic,
parallel, and analog, with self-organizing tendencies, or that the whole is different from the sum of its
parts.
Figure 2.2.2: Young Lady or Old Lady? (From Spooncer, 1992 p.35)
iii) The Law of Proximity
Figure 2.2.3: Two men and the table
Things, which are close together in space or time, tend to be perceived as grouped together. Thus, if
you want your audience to associate the product with the presenter, put them close together; if you
want them to perceive two ideas as associated, present them in close proximity.
iv) The Law of Similarity
There are 3 stages of motivation. They are enactive, iconic, and symbolic.
Insightful experiences evoke our powers of induction. We seek answers to questions, we solve
problems and we make connections between clues because we want to answer, solve, and make those
connections. He translated his ideas of learning via insight through discovery learning.
Example: Teacher asked her class a problem:
Question-1: Mulu is two years older than Rishan and one year younger than Abraha. Who are the
youngest of them all?
Question-1: Solomn is shorter than Feyissa and is taller than Jula. Who is the tallest?
She directed her class‟s attention to the problem and let them try to solve it, piece by piece; she was
encouraging their learning through insight.
2.3: Learning in school settings: aids, gains and losses
In this topic, you have to revisit and sharpen your understanding about motivation, memory and
transfer of learning. The aim is to make you improve your competencies in motivating your students,
helping them to improve their memory and making them able to learn better in different situations.
2.3.1: Behaviorism in the classroom
This section describes how teachers can apply the principles of behaviorism in the classroom. It is
divided into three subsections according to the perspectives discussed earlier that are classical
conditioning, operant conditioning and social learning theory.
i) Applying Classical Conditioning in the Classroom: The key element in classical conditioning is
association. Therefore, teachers are encouraged to associate variety of positive and pleasant events
with learning and classroom activities. For example, a teacher may:
Use attractive learning aids.
Decorate the classrooms.
Encourage students to work in small groups for difficult learning tasks.
Greet the students and smile at them when he comes to the classroom.
Inform the students clearly and specifically the format of quizzes, tests, and examinations.
Make the students understand the rules of the classrooms.
Give ample time for students to prepare for and complete the learning tasks.
ii) Applying Operant Conditioning in the Classroom: In operant conditioning, the
consequences of behaviour produce changes in the probability that the behaviour will
occur. Reinforcement and punishment are the 2 main concepts in operant conditioning. The
following are some examples on how operant conditioning can be applied in the
classrooms.
• Gagne (1985) translated the information-processing model into an instructional model called “phases of learning.”
Gagne (1985) parallels information processing with instructional events.
Internal Process Instructional Event Action Example
Reception Expectancy 1. Gaining attention Use abrupt stimulus change. Tell learners
2. Informing learners of the objective. what they will be able to do after learning.
Retrieval to Working 3. Stimulating recall of prior learning. Ask for recall of previously learned
memory knowledge or skills.
Selective perception 4. Presenting the stimulus. Display the content with distinctive features.
Semantic encoding 5. Providing “learning guidance”. Suggest meaningful learning.
Responding 6. Eliciting performance. Require additional learner performance, with
Reinforcement Retrieval 7. Providing feedback. feedback.
& reinforcement 8. Assessing performance.
Retrieval and 9. Enhancing retention and transfer. Provide varied practice and space reviews.
Generalization.
Activity: Describe the features of three stages of memory storage in Information Processing model.
Multi-Store Model of Memory
One of the major issues in cognitive psychology is the study of memory. The dominant view is labelled
the “stage theory” and is based on the work of Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968). The Atkinson-
Shiffrinmodel(also known as the Multi-store model, Multi-memory model and the Modal model) is a
psychological model proposed in 1968 by Richard Atkinson and Richard Shiffrin as a proposal for the
structure of memory.
It proposed that human memory involves a sequence of three stages, which are sensory memory, short-
term memory and long-term memory as shown in Figure 2.3.2.2.
a) Sensory Memory: The first stage is sensory memory, which contains receptors that briefly hold on
to only that information that enters through our senses. Sensory memory is affiliated with the
transudation of energy(change from one form of energy to another). The environment makes a variety
of sources of information(light, sound, smell, heat, cold, etc.) available, but the brain only understands
electrical energy. The body has special sensory receptor cells that transducer (change from one form of
energy to another) this external energy to something the brain can understand. In the process of
transudation, a memory is created. This memory is very short (less than 1/2 second for vision; about 3
seconds for hearing).
Figure 2.3.2.4: The frontal lobe, the structure associated with working memory.
The hypothalamus is a brain structure thought to be involved in this shallow processing of information.
While the frontal lobe of the cerebral cortex as labeled in Figure 5.15 is the structure associated with
working memory. For Example, you are processing the words you read on the screen in your frontal
lobes. However, if I ask, “What is your telephone number?” Your brain immediately calls that from
long-term memory and replaces what was previously there. Another process that is sometimes used to
expand the capacity of short-term memory is called chunking. Chunking is a process by which we
group individual bits of information into some types of large, more meaningful unit.
c) Long-term memory: The third stage is long-term memory (LTM). LTM provides the lasting retention of
information, from minutes to a lifetime. Long-term memory appears to have an almost limitless capacity to
retain information, but it could never be measured, as it would take too long. Contemporary psychologists agree
that long-term memory can be divided into subtypes of declarative and procedural memory (Santrock, 2008).
Declarative memory is subdivided into episodic memory and semantic memory.
•PM is non-declarative knowledge in the form of skills and cognitive operations.
Procedural •PM cannot be consciously recollected, at least not in the form of specific events or facts.
memory •PMt is sometimes called “knowing how,” and recently it also has been described as “implicit
memory.”
• When students apply their abilities to perform a dance, their procedural memory is at work.
• DM is the conscious recollection of information, such as specific facts/events that can be verbally
Declarative communicated.
memory • DM has been called “knowing that” and more recently has been labeled “explicit memory.”
• Demonstrations of student‟s declarative memory such as describing a basic principle of math.
Episodic • EMs are the memories we have for times and places (like first day Aidilfitri celebration).
memories • Information encoded in our episodic memory is in the form of images.
Semantic SMs are our memories for general facts and concepts. Most of what we learned in school
memories (instructional content) is stored in our semantic memories.
Long-term memory is also called preconscious and unconscious memory in Freudian terms.
• Preconscious means that the information is relatively easily recalled (although it may take several
minutes or even hours) while
Guidance and counseling are two sides of the same coin. The goal in both cases is to give an
opportunity for an individual to see a variety of available options and thereafter, assist the person in
making a wise choice. Guidance is the process that is put in place at a time a choice is to be made.
Counseling on the other hand i) helps with considering all sides of a potential choice even before the
choice is made; ii) takes place when a choice has been made and there is a need to modify, reinforce or
abandon such a choice.
The basic purpose of a guidance and counseling program is to ensure the physical, emotional, social,
and educational development of learners. Since primary school students spend most of the school day
with just a few teachers, these teachers are in a favorable position to perform their role as a counselor
for their students. They can assume their counseling role at two levels – school and classroom. At
school level, their role as counselor will be oriented towards the more general and common problems
of primary schoolchildren. In contrast, their role as classroom counselor will be slanted towards the
more specific and individual problems of their students.
Definitions:
Guidance is a broad term that is applied to a school‟s program of activities and services that are aimed
at assisting students to make and carry out adequate plans and to achieve satisfactory adjustment in
life. Guidance can be defined as a process, developmental in nature, by which an individual is assisted
to understand, accept and utilize his/her abilities, aptitudes and interests and attitudinal patterns in
relation to his/her aspirations. Guidance as an educational construct involves those experiences, which
PGDT 412 Page 23
assist each learner to understand him/herself, accept him/herself and live effectively in his/her society.
This is in addition to the learner having learning experiences about the world of work and people
therein.
Guidance can also be looked at as a program of services to people based upon the need of each
individual, an understanding of his/her immediate environment, the influence of environmental factors
on the individual and the unique features of each school. Guidance is designed to help each person
adjust to his/her environment, develop the ability to set realistic goals for him/herself, and improve
his/her total educational program. As a process, guidance is not a simple event but it involves a series
of actions or steps progressively moving towards a goal. As a service, we can isolate three major
services, that of educational, vocational,
personal and social guidance.
1. Educational Guidance: Educational guidance is so far as it can be distinguished from any other
from of guidance, is concerned with the provision of assistance to pupils in their choices in and
adjustment to the schools‟ curriculum and school life in general. Educational guidance is therefore
essential in counseling service. Guiding young people to pursue the right type of education in which,
for example the right balance is met for accommodating the human resource needs of a nation.
2. Vocational Guidance: Vocational guidance is a process of helping individuals to choose an
occupation, prepare for, enter into and progress in it. Vocational happiness requires that a person‟s
interests, aptitudes and personality be suitable for his/her work. It plays its part by providing
individuals with a comprehension of the world of work and essential human needs, thus familiarizing
individuals with such terms as `dignity of labor‟ and `work value‟.
3. Personal and Social Guidance: Personal and social guidance is the process of helping an individual
on how to behave with consideration to other people. Primarily, personal and social guidance helps the
individual to understand oneself, how to get along with others, manners and etiquette, leisure time
activities, social skills, family and family relationships and understanding masculine and feminine
roles.
Counseling is usually viewed as one part of guidance services; it is subsumed by the general term,
guidance, in that it is one service within guidance rather than a synonym. It is difficult to think of one
definition of counseling. This is because definitions of counseling depend on the theoretical orientation
of the person defining it. Let us examine some of these definitions.
Counseling is learning-oriented process which usually occurs in an interactive relationship with the
aim of helping the person learn more: about the self; about others, and about situations and events
related to given issues and conditions and also to learn to put such understanding to being an effective
member of the society.
Counseling is a process in which the helper expresses care and concern towards the person with a
problem to facilitate that person‟s personal growth and positive change through self-understanding.
Counseling denotes a relationship between a concerned person and a person with a need. This
relationship is usually person-to-person, although sometimes it may involve more than two people. It is
designed to help people understand and clarify their views of their life-space, and to learn to reach their
self-determined goals through meaningful, well-informed, choices and through resolution of problems
of an emotional or interpersonal nature. It can be seen from these definitions that counseling may have
different meanings.
Activity 2: a) List any four activities you have carried out in your department within the last one year
that are (a) guidance and (b) counseling in nature. b) From your list, indicate the elements which
distinguish each activity as either guidance or counseling.
In fact, counseling is provided under a variety of different labels. For example, there are instances
where counseling is offered in the context of a relationship which is primarily focused on other, non-
counseling concerns. For example, a student may see a teacher as a person with whom it is safe to
PGDT 412 Page 24
share worries and anxieties. In such a situation it seems appropriate to see what is happening as being a
teacher using counseling skills rather than engaging in an actual counseling relationship. The teacher is
counseling but not being a counselor.
Guidance programs and the counseling service within them, usually deal with situational and
environmental conditions. Counseling is often seen as assistance given individuals to attain a clear
sense of identity. Counseling, as well as the total guidance program, stressed rational planning,
problem-solving, and support in the face of situational pressures. The counseling relationship is usually
characterized by much less intensity of emotional expression than that found in the therapeutic
relationship. Counseling services are usually located in schools, universities, community service
agencies, and pastoral organizations, while psychotherapeutic services are usually found in clinics,
hospitals, and private practice. The recipients of counseling are `normal‟ individuals rather than those
who exhibit abnormal or extreme modes of adjustment. Psychotherapy exists for individuals with
psychological disorders. Counseling helps the essentially normal individual remove frustrations and
obstacles that interfere with development, while psychotherapy attempts to deal with disabling or
disintegrating conflicts.
Counseling focuses upon helping the individual to cope with development tasks such as self-
definition, independence, and the like. Attention is given to clarifying the individual‟s assets, skills,
strengths, and personal resources in terms of role development. Counseling approaches, are based more
upon emphasizing present conscious material (material available within the individual‟s awareness)
while psychotherapeutic approaches tend to emphasize historic and symbolic materials, relying heavily
upon reactivation and consideration of unconscious processes.
Activity 3: Go through the statement of views on the meanings of guidance and of counseling. Review
these views with your peer in the class. Agree on a meaning for each of the two terms (guidance;
counseling). What are the commonalities in your meanings (or definitions) and those listed above?
The school is expected to provide more than just teaching and instruction. A school guidance and
counseling program includes all those activities other than instructional which are carried out to render
assistance to pupils in their educational, vocational, personal development and adjustment. The
fundamental aim of guidance and counseling program being the maximum development of the child,
all guidance counseling program must be geared toward attainment of the goal. Guidance and
counseling services can assist the pupils in knowing themselves-their potentialities and limitations,
making appropriate choices in educational, vocational and other fields. Some of the important
guidance services are:
The orientation services Group guidance services
Student inventory services Placement services
Career Information services Research and evaluation services
Counseling services
Learners in the school systems come in with a wide variety of backgrounds. There is diversity in their
entry socio-economic and academic profiles. This diversity translates into a differential in their
behavior patterns. Yet our desire is to ensure that all are found worthy in learning
Difficulties that arise during instruction: these may be related to the content, the lecturer or the way of
presentation.
Difficulties after instruction: these may be related to social activities of the student or they may be
related to the facilities themselves. In such cases where should the information come from? The
sources of relevant information about learners can be found or gleaned through the following:
Individual observation. This requires that individual lecturers are keen in noting any strange things
that happen to the students or with the students. The observation should arise out of a genuine desire to
help and get involved with the students.
Student statements: Students invariably make statements and comments which are indicative of the
struggles that they may face. The lecturers should be prepared to note these comments and statements
which are indicative of or are symptoms of other things that may appear later.
Activity 4: Comment on the view that teachers are best placed to give relevant advice to learners
since they know their academic strengths and weaknesses. The fact that the teachers know the interests
and aptitudes of most of their students makes them the best persons to assist their students in their
learning. How are you as a teacher in a school fitted to play these roles?
3.3. Types of Guidance and Counseling in schools
Types of guidance and counseling include: Individual and Group - Individual guidance, Group
Guidance: Concept, Need and Significance, Organization of Group Guidance activities, Techniques of
Group Guidance, Advantages of Group Guidance, Limitations of Group Guidance
Individual guidance and counseling:
Individual guidance and counseling is tailored to an individual. It is advice, strategy or planning
designed for a singular person or thing and their unique situation. This is in contrast to general
guidance which is frequently based on demographic information such as age or income or meant for
the general population. The most common reference to individual guidance and counseling is in
reference to children or students.
Individual guidance and counseling can be used to refer to any advice, usually professional advice,
given to a person based on their unique circumstances. This could include legal services, career
counseling, financial planning, medical or psychological advice or a number of other areas where a
trained professional is looked to for direction/support in a given area.
Group Guidance: Concept, Need and Significance: Group refers to collection of people, interaction
between individuals, development of shared perceptions, the development of affective ties and the
development of interdependence of roles. For example many students and /teachers at one school may
gather together to form a group.
Group guidance encompasses those activities of guidance which are carried on in a group situation to
assist its members to have experiences desirable or even necessary for making appropriate decisions in
the prevailing contexts. In a more specific term, it is guiding the individual in a group situation. Group
could be of any type ,but for guidance purposes a group should have a common goal. Just collection of
individual may not be called a group for organizing guidance activities. Selection of group members
will have to depend on sharing a common problem, volunteering to be members and willingness to
group activities.
Jones, A.J (1951) defines group guidance ‗as any group enterprise or activity in which the primary
purpose is to assist each individual in the group to solve his problems and to make his adjustment„.
Group guidance is used to address the developmental needs of a functional group consisting of a
number of students to implement program that would benefit them at all time. Students in group with
common problems and concerns are helped in groups i.e. small or large. In other words, if guidance is
to be available to all, it should be planned in groups.
Some of the objectives of group guidance are:
1. To help people in identifying common problems, analyze them and find relevant solutions
2. To place a wide range of information before people with common problems which could be useful
for them for finding solutions?
3. To provide a platform where people with common problems could interact with each other and
could be benefited by each other„s perspectives, ideas and experiences
Personality records should contain the following views about the students; (a). Concern for others -
antisocial, indifferent, dependable, sometimes socially concerned or deeply concerned.
(b). Responsibility -unreliable, somewhat dependable, usually dependable, conscientious, assumes
much responsibility. (c). Emotional stability -hyper-emotional, excitable, usually well balanced,
exceptionally stable.
Health Records: Though the teacher cannot have this, it is necessary that the school counselor has a
record about student‟s health. This should be made up-to-date indicating the type of disease from
which the individual must have suffered, the duration of illness and the time of the year, if possible.
Medical statements about student‟s ears, eyes, teeth, posture, nervous symptoms, or speech defects
should also be included. A cumulative up-to-date health record will help the school counselor refer
particular students at different times to specialists for treatment. This also helps to decide the type of
job to which a student can be assigned. A research fellow on school discipline has suggested that the
offence should not determine the punishment but instead type of punishment recommended should
depend on the physical strength of the individual offender. It therefore follows that a detailed, up-to-
date health record will help remind the counselor and the school authority of the importance of
individual differences in dealing with the children.
Family Records: The home is one of the major factors which affect the education of students. An
unstable home causes the student emotional imbalance. The family record should include name and
address of parents, their nationality and occupation, and the socio-economic status.
If family records are kept and maintained up-to-date by the counselor, clues can be found in an
attempt to spot out student‟s difficulties with the aim of helping to alleviate his or her suffering. A
good knowledge of the family records of the student will help to foster the triangular relationship,
which should exist between the teachers, the parents and the student.
The counselor should examine the cumulative records of each student to;
a) Help the counselor get acquainted with a new student more quickly at the beginning of the
semester or session.
b) Help students who are not working up to class level to cope with their problems. The under-
achievers and those students who need remedial courses are this identified and helped.
c) Identify gifted students and other students of unusual ability and help them by finding
appropriate and challenging work for them.
d) Find out students who attend classes irregularly and encourage them towards regular
attendance.
e) Study the personality traits of students who misbehave and suggest ways for their learning
other adaptive behaviors.
f) Help the counselor to study students for whom special aids, such as scholarship are being
considered.
g) Gain background knowledge about students before assisting them in the choice of course for
study.
h) Gather some information about a student before conferring with his parents.
i) Discover students of exceptional talents in such special fields as arts, music, athletics or
creative writing.
As for the United States, Gysbers (2008) has described the recent development of individual student
planning in his article. He emphasized that individual student planning is not only collection of
students‟ records, be they hard or soft copies. Rather, students need to be contacted either on an
individual or a group level on which they can share their needs and goals with the school counselor.
Although Gysbers did not explicitly state the need for more professional school personnel, the practice
he described can show that school counseling work is carried out by trained, qualified professionals
well-informed of the counseling practice and ethics in the United States.
From Position to Program : Gysbers (2008) posited that to make school guidance work effective,
emphasis should be placed on the implementation of school guidance as a program on the whole rather
than the sheer establishment of the school counselor position. In the 1970s and 1980s, three models of
school counseling and guidance work that shared the same emphasis were devised (Gysbers, 2001). In
one of the models, Myrick (1997) delineated the characteristics of developmental guidance and
counseling work. They included: (a) provision of programs for all students; (b) guidance curriculum be
organized, planned, sequential and flexible; (c) all school personnel be involved.
The second model, developed by Johnson and Johnson (1991) in the 1980s, emphasized the
development of students‟ competency. The acquisition of competencies by all students was the major
concern.
The third model, developed by Gysbers and Moore (1981) in the 1970s, was a comprehensive
guidance program model. It consisted of an organizational structure which includes content
(competencies), organizational framework (structural components and program components), and
resources (human, financial, and political). In practice, different time compositions should be allocated
to the four program components (i.e., guidance curriculum, individual student planning, responsive
services, and system support) according to students‟ levels and their developmental needs.
In sum, the three models provide us with some perspectives on the reorientation of school guidance
and counseling from a problem-based approach to a strength-based approach, from a remedial mode to
As for South Korea, the position of school counselors was established in 2005. School counselors‟
training and role identity issues are still the main concerns at the moment. As stated by Lee and Yang
(2008), South Korea can follow the example of the United States to put stronger emphasis on the
development of school guidance work as a program in the long run. Adopting the model of
comprehensive school guidance program can be an appropriate and feasible direction to develop
school counseling work in South Korea.
From a Remedial Orientation to a Preventive and Developmental Orientation: According to Yagi
(2008) and Lee and Yang (2008), school counseling and guidance work seems to be moving from a
remedial orientation to one that emphasizes more on the strengths of students in both Japan and South
Korea. This is like the development of school guidance in the United States, where emphasis was first
put in resolving students‟ career-related issues and other learning and behavioral problems, then later
to guidance activities which are more preventive and developmental in nature that emphasize students‟
strengths and assets.
In the United States, the Comprehensive Developmental Program approach began to emerge to
respond to the call for a reorientation. What began with the appointment of teachers to the position of
vocational counselor has become a program. This framework has become the major structure of
organizing and managing guidance in the schools of the United States (Gysbers, 2001). The level of
implementation of guidance programs varies from one school to another. Among the four program
components, individual student planning seems to be the most difficult to be implemented. It is
because there is a great demand on human resources to carry out effective individual student planning.
Although literature on individual student planning is not very substantial in the field of school
counseling, Gysbers‟s (2008) article does provide us with some updated and valuable information on
the implementation of individual student planning in the United States.
At present, individual student planning exemplifies an integration of theory and practice, as
demonstrated by the four examples quoted in the article. Gysbers (2008) described a number of recent
studies which indicate substantial impact on students‟ success in schools through individual student
There is continuous development in the guidance curriculum. Gysbers (2001) described that guidance
curriculum typically consists of competencies and structured activities which span systematically from
kindergarten to Grade 12. In recent years, different systemic and integrative models for the
implementation of school-based prevention programs have been devised. One of these conceptual
frameworks is “Developmental-Contextualism” (Walsh, Galassi, Murphy, & Park-Taylor, 2002).
According to this perspective, both the personal and contextual aspects of the person-environment
relationship are considered in school guidance programs because “Within this newer perspective, a
developing person not only affects his or her contexts, but the context also affects the person‟s course
of development” (Walsh et al., 2002, p. 686).
Besides individual student planning and the guidance curriculum, responsive service is another core
component of the comprehensive guidance program (Gysbers& Henderson, 2001). As Seligman
(1998) suggested, approaches to helping people have been changing. There is also a trend to conduct
diagnostic activities and personal counseling with a positive, strength-based orientation. Morrison,
Brown, D‟Incau, O‟Farrell, and Furlong (2006) stated “A focus on strengths represents a different
perspective on how to conceptualize student adaptation to school” (p. 20). Morrison et al. presented an
interview format to organize and collect information about students‟ strengths and protective factors in
their personal and contextual domains. Student, parents, and teachers are all informants. They will be
asked interview questions in the five areas of “Individual Assets,” “Family Assets,” “Peer Assets,”
“Classroom Assets,” and “School Assets.” Questions like “Do you have any ideas about what you
want to be when you grow up?” (for students), “How do you participate in or help at your child‟s
school?” (for parents) or “What are the rules and procedures in class? How do the rules help students
to learn?” (for teachers) will be asked. By collecting information about family, peer, classroom, and
school assets, school counselors could form a picture of the availability of protective factors that can
become the basis for developing interventions.
Other than this, different strength-based counseling models have appeared. As Seligman (1998) stated,
“Treatment is not just fixing what is broken, it is nurturing what is best within ourselves” (para. 5).
Carl Rogers, the founder of Person-Centered Therapy, had a strikingly different view on the
development of persons and the role of counseling and psychotherapy. Rogers paid attention to human
strengths rather than pathologies, to human assets rather than liabilities, to human potential rather than
limitations (see Lopez et al., 2006). Recently, Smith (2006) proposed and outlined ten stages of
strength-based counseling to illustrate how the approach may be implemented. The ten stages are: (a)
creating the therapeutic alliance; (b) identifying strengths; (c) assessing presenting problems; (d)
encouraging and instilling hope; (e) framing solutions; (f) building strength and competence; (g)
empowering; (h) changing; (i) building resilience; and (j) evaluating and terminating. Overall
speaking, in providing responsive service and designing guidance activities, there is an obvious move
from a remedial to a preventive, strength-based orientation.
From the above discussion, we have traced the general trend of the development of school counseling
in an international context. From the beginning, school counseling work was taken up by the appointed
teachers on top of their regular duties. Then, full-time positions of school counselors were introduced
in the schools. This is a move from non-professionals to professionals. Thereafter, there was a further
move from position to program where the focus on the counseling personnel was shifted to
implementing guidance activities as a program. There is also a move from the remedial approach of
Based on the description above, school counseling and guidance programs in the United States, South
Korea, and Japan do manifest the three characteristics. However, in delivering the programs, resources
may be one of the key issues to consider. Gysbers and Henderson (2006) proposed that resources for
school counseling and guidance work include human resources, financial resources, and political
resources. Such a perspective can be helpful to evaluate and develop school counseling work further in
the three countries.
First of all, the need for human resources suggests that schools need more professional school guidance
personnel. This not only means that more manpower be allocated to schools to carry out guidance
duties and activities, but also entails that these people should receive appropriate and professional
training before they become qualified guidance teachers. For teachers without prior training, on-the-job
training could be provided to familiarize them with the knowledge and skills needed for the job as
guidance teachers. Such training and certification issues are important to the success of school
counseling work, as advocated earlier in this article that guidance teachers should change from non-
professionals to professionals. This is exactly an issue facing South Korea and Japan for the time
being.
Apart from human resources, financial resources are another important criterion for effective school
counseling work. For example, individual student planning, as a focus in Gysbers‟s (2008) article,
requires teachers not only to keep hard and soft copies of students‟ records, but also to meet students
individually or in group meetings to discuss students‟ transition planning for their attainment of
personal and career goals. These meetings which involve consultation with school guidance teachers or
counselors could be expensive and imply a lot of money. Besides this expenditure, other school
counseling work such as guidance curriculum, responsive services, and system support also need
financial resources to sustain and implement. No matter how developed guidance programs are, as in
the case of the United States, or how progressively developing they are, as in the cases of South Korea
and Japan, financial resources should remain a key factor for the successful development of school
guidance work. Although large expenses are anticipated, it is worthwhile to spend money on
counseling programs and work because early intervention or more desirably, prevention, can enhance
the overall well-being of the student cohorts, which is beneficial to the population‟s health and
productivity in the long run. This is the reason why we are arguing for a change from the remedial
approach to the one that emphasizes development and prevention.
Last but not least, political resources are needed for school counseling and guidance programs. On the
school policy level, political resources imply clear support from the upper management in the schools
such as the school supervisors or head teachers. Their support could be shown in the clear role
descriptions of school guidance workers, which could help to avoid role ambiguity of these personnel.
On the other hand, on the government policy level, political resources of school guidance work could
be policies devised by the local education department. The 1963 Educational Act and the 1997
Elementary and Secondary Education Act from the Ministry of Education in South Korea (Lee &
Yang, 2008), as well as the school counselor system introduced by the Ministry of Education, Culture,
Sports, Science and Technology in Japan (Yagi, 2008) are good examples of political resources given
from the governmental level.
Recognizing the importance of government support, educators and school counseling personnel could
try to solicit help and support from the government or make use of existing policies and resources to
develop school guidance work. To take Hong Kong as an example, the New Senior Secondary
Education curriculum in 2009 can be an opportunity to enhance school guidance and counseling work
because when the new curriculum is implemented, all secondary schools are to keep students‟
portfolios in their three years of senior secondary education. This requirement is favorable to school
counseling because such records enable teachers to assist students to formulate their transition plans
and attain their personal career goals, which is similar to individual student planning, a key element of
comprehensive guidance program as posited by Gysbers (2008).
Conclusively speaking, whereas different countries or regions face different problems or limitations in
developing school guidance programs, one important issue we have to resolve is resources allocation
which include human, financial, and political resources. Other than this, however, the government
bodies and school administrators should be convinced of the rationale behind the school guidance and
counseling work in the first place as the mindset and values could influence subsequent decisions to be
made and actions to be taken.
References
Bandura, A. (1986). Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Bannister, C., &McInnes, B. (2005).RCN working well initiative guidance on traumatic stress
management in the health care sector. Retrieved from:
http://www.rcn.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/78543/001804.pdf
Benard, B. (1991). Fostering resiliency in kids: Protective factors in the family, school, and
community. Portland, OR: Western Center for Drug-Free Schools and Communities.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Cobia, D. C., & Henderson, D. A. (2003).Handbook of school counseling. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Merrill.
Dougherty, A. M. (2009). Psychological consultation and collaboration in school and community
settings (5th ed.). Belmont: Brooks/Cole.
Epstein, M. H., Rudolph, S., & Epstein, A. A. (2000).Using strength-based assessment in transition
planning.Teaching Exceptional Children, 32(6), 50–54.
Gysbers, N. C. (2001). School guidance and counseling in the 21st century: Remember the past into
the future. Professional School Counseling, 5(2), 96–105.
Gysbers, N. C. (2008). Individual student planning in the United States: Rationale, practices, and
results. Asian Journal of Counselling, 15(2), 117–139.
Gysbers, N. C., & Henderson, P. (2001). Comprehensive guidance and counseling programs: A rich
history and a bright future. Professional School Counseling, 4(4), 246–256.