BSBSTR401 - Learner Guide.v1.0
BSBSTR401 - Learner Guide.v1.0
Learner Guide
Learning Resources
Copyright Warning
This product is copyrighted to Aspire Training & Consulting
(ABN 51 054 306 428).
Aspire Training & Consulting owns all copyright to its products. Except as
permitted by the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) or unless you have obtained the
specific written permission of Aspire Training & Consulting, you must not:
reproduce or photocopy this product in whole or in part
publish this product in whole or in part
cause this product in whole or in part to be transmitted
store this product in whole or in part in a retrieval system including a
computer
record this product in whole or in part either electronically or mechanically
resell this product in whole or in part.
Aspire Training & Consulting:
invests significant time and resources in creating its original products
protects its copyright material
will enforce its rights in copyright material
reserves its legal rights to claim its loss and damage or an account of profits
made resulting from infringements of its copyright.
Aspire is committed to developing quality resources that meet the needs of our customers. However, occasionally Aspire finds, or
is notified of, errors. Please refer to our website at www.aspirelr.com.au to see if there are any updates that may be relevant to you.
Every effort has been made to ensure the information in this book is accurate; however, the author and publisher accept no
responsibility for any loss, damage or injury arising from such information.
Except where an information source is acknowledged, the names and details of individuals and organisations used in examples are
fictitious and have been devised for learning purposes only. Any similarity to actual people or organisations is unintentional.
All websites referred to in this unit were accessed and deemed appropriate at time of publication.
Aspire Training & Consulting apologises unreservedly for any copyright infringement that may have occurred and invites copyright
owners to contact Aspire so any violation may be rectified.
Learning content Read each topic in this Learner Guide. If you come across content that is
confusing, make a note and discuss it with your trainer. Your trainer is in the
best position to offer assistance. It is very important that you take on some
of the responsibility for the learning you will undertake.
Examples These highlight key learning points and provide realistic examples of
workplace situations.
Practice Tasks Practice Tasks give you the opportunity to put your skills and knowledge
into action. Your trainer will tell you which practice tasks to complete.
Summaries Key learning points are provided at the end of each topic.
Learning There is a Learning Checkpoint at the end of each topic. Your trainer will tell
Checkpoints you which Learning Checkpoints to complete. These checkpoints give you
an opportunity to check your progress and apply the skills and knowledge
you have learnt.
Unit Release 1 (Aspire version 1.1) © Aspire Training & Consulting vii
BSBSTR401 | Promote innovation in team environments
Foundation skills
As you complete learning using this guide, you will be developing the foundation skills
relevant for this unit. Foundation skills are the language, literacy and numeracy (LLN)
skills and the employability skills required for participation in modern workplaces and
contemporary life.
The following table provides definitions for each foundation skill.
Planning and organising • Selects the appropriate form, channel and mode of
communication for a specific purpose relevant to own role
Planning and organising • Plans, sequences and prioritises tasks for efficient and
effective outcomes
Initiative and enterprise • Understands the nature and purpose of own role and how it
affects others in the work context
viii Unit Release 1 (Aspire version 1.1) © Aspire Training & Consulting
Topic 1 | Identify opportunities
to maximise innovation
1A Identify team dynamics
1B Identify opportunities to promote innovation
Types of innovation
The types of innovation you focus on will depend on your team and the problems
you have identified.
Jay Doblin was an American industrial designer and educator who identified 10 areas of
organisational innovation.
1. Profit model – how to make money and ways to make money from different avenues
2. Network – how to connect and network with others to use the capabilities and assets
of other companies
3. Structure – how to organise and align talents and assets in ways that create value
4. Process – how to look at different ways of doing things using the company’s unique
capabilities
5. Product performance – how to develop distinguishing features and functions in new
products or extend an existing line of products or services
6. Product system – how to create complementary products and services
7. Service – how to amplify the value of the offerings to customers
8. Channel – how to improve the way offerings are delivered to customers and users
9. Brand – how a business and its offerings are represented
10. Customer engagement – how to improve the customer experience and develop
insights into connections with the company.
You can learn more about these types of innovation at the Doblin website:
aspirelr.link/doblin-ten-types.
Purpose of team The purpose of the team is its function. For example, the marketing team
exists to communicate with customers about the products and services
of the organisation.
Team objectives Objectives state how the team will fulfil its purpose. Many objectives
relate to improving efficiencies in the team such as time, cost and
processes. For example, the finance team may have objectives to
complete monthly reports by a certain date, ensure data is accurate for
quality assurance purposes, and manage cash flow and creditors.
Team requirements Requirements are the resources a team needs to carry out its work and
meet its objectives. These might include basic items such a desk, chair
and computer, but also specific software, knowledge and training. It
might also include access to resources to find information.
You may find that some team members are unable to answer these questions or that
they provide different answers. To be able to innovate, the team members need to have a
shared understanding, and a clear vision of what they are doing and what resources they
need to achieve their objectives.
Team requirements can include physical resources, such as equipment and machines, to
do their work. They can also include a range of human resources that each team member
provides. These can be enhanced with training, and sharing of knowledge and skills
among the team under the guidance and supervision of a team leader.
Initiatives will require a range of resources to achieve objectives. The requirement to
work innovatively might mean the team needs:
• dedicated time to brainstorm, collaborate and problem-solve
• additional training for skills and knowledge development
• time and resources for testing new concepts and processes.
Example
Here are five areas to consider when identifying common and unique characteristics of
your team:
Personal interests
It is good for people to spend most of their work time doing things they like,
but through working with others they learn to operate effectively in other areas
as well.
Knowledge, experience
Each team member is the product of past learning, skills and experience; they
bring their unique perspectives to the work and can share these with other
members of the team. This adds to the ability of the team to carry out its tasks
and achieve common goals.
Work styles
A person’s work style includes things such as what time of day they work best
and how they like to get things done. For example, some people like a checklist
to identify and work through their tasks. Others are keen to have variety and
mix up their tasks.
Strengths, weaknesses
Finding out people’s strengths and weaknesses helps identify situations where
they can be relied upon to undertake certain roles or lead/train others.
Life roles
Each team member has a range of other roles in life, in addition to their work. All
of these life roles should be seen as valuable when building an innovative team.
Team dynamics
Group dynamics are unconscious, psychological forces, or undercurrents, that
influence behaviour and performance.
Each team member has skills, knowledge and experience to offer, but it is helpful to get
the right mix to ensure the team can work effectively together.
People tend to be attracted to specific roles when working in a team, and adopt distinct
roles and behaviours. Dynamics are created by the nature of the work, personalities within
the team, their working relationships with others and the team’s work environment.
Researcher and management theorist Belbin developed the Belbin Team Roles model
to help identify and build strengths, and improve weaknesses in teams. The aim is to
improve team contributions and performance. Belbin identified nine team roles and he
categorised those roles into three groups, as shown below.
Action-oriented
People-oriented
Thought-oriented
Group dynamics can support team performance through positive behaviours, or hinder
it through negative behaviours. Teams with positive dynamics trust one another, make
decisions collectively, take responsibility for their individual and team performance, and
hold one another accountable. Poor dynamics can disrupt work, impede decision-making
and lead to poor choices.
Some behaviours that commonly affect group dynamics are listed here.
Giving too much advice or instruction Promoting teamwork and shared problem-
solving
Censoring ideas and giving precedence to Conveying empathy and welcoming objective
only one opinion assessment of each idea
Talking too much or dominating discussion Letting others speak and gently interrupting
dominators to call on other individuals to
present their views
Displaying negativity or lack of interest Taking on more challenging and active tasks
such as gathering information, taking notes
or making presentations
The table below lists some of the workplace procedures, processes and policies and that
you may need to be familiar with when evaluating your team.
Job descriptions Job descriptions outline the expectations, key performance indicators,
reporting lines and objectives of a role. They may also outline the
skills and knowledge required to carry out the role and the behaviour
required of staff.
Relevant documents include code of conduct, WHS policies and
procedures, customer service policy, IT and email usage policies,
complaints procedures, and fair work entitlements such as leave, work
conditions and salary.
Organisation chart The organisation chart shows the teams, line managers and
management structure of an organisation. This indicates the reporting
lines and level of responsibility of each department or team and their
manager.
Team, department Meetings are scheduled to share information, and keep teams and
and whole company departments updated. There are likely to be set agendas, and teams are
meetings expected to share information and participate in discussions.
Relevant documents include minutes of meetings, code of conduct,
conflict resolution procedures, and storing and sharing of documents.
Terms of employment Terms of employment statements outline the tools required to fulfil
the duties of a role and any working arrangements that have been
negotiated.
Relevant documents include fair work entitlements such as leave, salary
and work conditions.
Performance reviews Past and present performance reviews provide team leaders with
insights into team member performance.
Relevant documents include conflict resolution, complaints, fair work
including unfair dismissal, and privacy policies.
Reflecting legislation Policy review processes ensure the organisation remains compliant with
legislative requirements, such as privacy, workplace health and safety
and fair work entitlements.
Example
Take time to watch the way your team works together before you begin
identifying opportunities for innovation.
Workflow processes
Your team will work to a plan and follow processes to achieve their objectives.
A workflow process and the ways of working should be documented so everyone has a
clear idea of how work is to be carried out. If it has not already been documented, arrange
a team meeting to discuss it, or have individual team members or small groups work
together to document the process they use to carry out work tasks. A workflow process
doesn’t need to be overly detailed, but it does need to capture the actions required to
complete a task, who carries out the actions and an estimate of how long each action
typically takes.
Documenting workflow processes makes it easier to identify where there could be
improvements in ways of working, and can lead to ideas on how to work better or more
efficiently. A workflow shows:
• transparency of who is doing what within the team
• an increased understanding of the activities required to complete a task
• greater visibility of overlap in activities, doubling up of work or other
inefficiencies.
Ideas for innovation may come from customers, stakeholders or management, as well
as from team members themselves. You should work to see that all ideas have potential
merit and are not dismissed or taken up without proper investigation.
The nature of work-related issues will vary according to the industry, roles and
responsibilities, and the working environment. Typical examples are discussed below.
└ How easily do people share information about themselves, their roles, their needs
and their wants?
• How well do they listen to others when they communicate?
└ How well do team members work together to overcome problems, see others’ points
of view and account for differences?
• How do they minimise tension and conflict?
Generate ideas
Make decisions
Encouraging contributions
People have different strengths that can be used in different ways.
Ensuring team members and others feel they can contribute is very important, but not
everyone will contribute in the same way.
Individuals who often share ideas are usually people who enjoy being active and vocal in
the group, thinking about all the possibilities. Less vocal people generate ideas too, but
may need more encouragement to share them. Others may excel at seeing various points
of view and accounting for differences, and these people often work to minimise tension
and conflict.
Below are some different ways team members contribute to team innovation.
└ These team members are positive and energetic, with an interest in team cohesion;
they also provide an element of fun.
└ These team members are good at visualising and creating flow charts, mind maps,
diagrams and other pictorial representations of ideas.
└ These team members can take an opposing view and ask the hard questions; this
ensures all aspects of an idea have been considered before the team decides to act.
└ These team members are good at bringing together ideas and strategies so they
make sense; they have good analytical skills and a high level of literacy.
└ These team members are good networkers and come into their own when
negotiation is required.
└ These team members understand the organisation’s processes and systems, and
can advise on how new processes and systems might be incorporated. They can
provide historical information about previous successes and failures.
Problem-solving
└ These team members ensure new ideas are implemented with a minimum of fuss.
They meet challenges and overcome hurdles to facilitate the process of change.
Example
Summary
• Innovation is a new way of doing things to solve a problem.
• Identifying team requirements will confirm the purpose of the team and what the
team needs to carry out their duties.
• Understanding the team relationship will provide insights into individual
strengths and weaknesses and how these are combined as the team members
work together.
• Any changes to team requirements and relationships need to be reflected in
workplace policies and procedures.
• Identifying the way teams work towards objectives will provide greater
transparency and uncover where efficiency could be improved.
• Creating processes that allow for collaboration and the sharing of ideas will
promote innovative working within teams.
• Working space – Many businesses use hot desking where people don’t always use
the same desk but move around the seating provided in the office. This allows for
better collaboration by getting people out of their own space and mixing with
other staff they may not have worked with otherwise.
• Agile working – This could be working remotely and using video conferencing to
communicate with others in the team. It can decrease costs for the business but
also increases productivity, and adds more flexibility to arrange tasks and think
creatively.
One common way working conditions change is through the introduction and use of
technology.
Here are examples of how technology is changing the way people work, where and when
they work, and the nature of employment itself.
Outsourcing
Telecommuting
Boundaries
└ These include the kind of work, the scope of the job role, accountabilities and
outcomes of work. Boundaries may also cover areas not to be dealt with by the team
if they need to be clarified.
Example: ‘This team does not process payments to staff, whether these are wages
or sundry items.’
Confidentiality
└ Team members must follow policies and procedures to ensure individual, group,
client and other stakeholder privacy and confidentiality are respected.
Example: ‘All correspondence related to specific clients will be centrally maintained
with limited access.’
Communication
└ Set guidelines for how often people need to communicate and what methods are to
be used such as meetings.
Example: ‘Team members are expected to attend the staff meeting on the third
Thursday of each month.’
└ The general duties and authority/knowledge base of each team member regarding
meeting the team’s common or project goals need to be clear.
Example: ‘Maria is to respond to all inquiries about the project from within the
organisation.’
Relationships
└ Coordinate with the other teams and individuals that are critical to the work of the
group – either inside or outside the organisation – and how the team is to relate to
them.
Example: ‘The sales team is to supply updated figures to the finance team each
month so they can incorporate the figures into the monthly report.’
Timelines
Example
Ground rules
Ground rules need to be explained so team members know where they fit into
the team and what is expected of them now they have a different role or set of
responsibilities.
Individual ownership
Team members need to be given some control of their own role and that
they can bring their own individual influence to the responsibilities and
contributions.
Collaboration
Agreement
In some situations, as team leader, you may need to make the decision on the
responsibilities for each team member with little consultation. This may be because of
an urgent priority or as a result of a staff absence at short notice.
Decisions about who will take on certain responsibilities will depend on the task or
objectives involved and the skills or strengths of the team. It is likely that certain team
members will be better suited to certain responsibilities based on their skills, knowledge
and personal characteristics. For example, a member who is a good communicator may
be better at seeking advice from others in the organisation. A team member who enjoys
solving problems, may like to lead the group in a problem-solving brainstorming session.
• Match the skills, knowledge and attitude of team members to the tasks.
• Match the level of responsibility of the person to the amount of authority they have.
• Provide training and development activities if required.
• Discuss timelines and schedules.
• Think about the time required to complete the tasks and if the amount of work will mean
reshuffling other tasks or backfilling for their original role.
• Consider the level of independence of the staff member and their work style.
• Provide support or ‘buddy’ systems so team members develop confidence in new tasks.
• Reward contributions and behaviours that show responsibility has been taken.
• Monitor the progress of each team member.
Coaching Mentoring
It is not always practical or easy to divide tasks up according to the individual strengths
of each team member. This can be a particular problem if it is a small team. Here are
some other ways to share tasks and responsibilities among the team:
• Rotate responsibilities around the team.
• Arrange for external staff to help out in busy periods or for a special project.
• Have several team members share a set of responsibilities.
• Divide up the less popular responsibilities so each team member has only a
small share.
Here are some tips for encouraging collaborative and innovative teamwork.
• Ensure team members have time to meet and discuss issues and share solutions.
• Encourage active listening to everyone’s views.
• Ensure levels of autonomy are established and are clearly understood so the
need to ask for permission doesn’t prevent innovative ideas from being trialled or
implemented.
• Identify obstacles that stand in the way of effective teamwork and/or innovation.
• Ask team members to come to meetings prepared, but if ideas don’t flow then
don’t persevere for too long. Innovation can’t be forced.
• Encourage each team member to offer their ideas. Give people enough time to
formulate their ideas.
• Ensure you have agreement before moving on. Avoid asking for a vote, as this will
create tensions and promote black-and-white thinking.
• Do not try to reach agreement too quickly or compromise too early in the
process. Rushing to agree without sufficient thought or consideration may lead to
problems later.
Obtaining agreement
Before team members are delegated tasks, they need to agree to take them on
as additional responsibilities or to reduce some of their existing responsibilities.
Here are some strategies to use when getting agreement from the team on the sharing of
responsibilities.
• Agree on a time frame for discussion ahead of time.
• Allow each person equal time to put forward their point of view or ideas, and
listen to each person before proceeding.
• Identify areas of agreement and disagreement.
• Encourage everyone to think outside the square. Avoid team responsibilities being
allocated purely based on their similarity to work roles.
• Explore each person’s ideas, discussing their pros and cons as a team.
• Reach a solution, ensuring all team members have the same opportunity to fully
express their opinions.
• Ask each person individually if they agree to and support the group decision.
Example
Thinking
└ Thinking is an internal process; you look inward to make sense of things and
formulate ideas. Critical thinking is reflecting on one or more possible solutions to a
problem and evaluating or comparing them against criteria to judge their validity or
likelihood of success.
Challenging
└ Challenging is not about arguing points with others, but questioning our own
thoughts and ideas, and those of others. Challenging activities include debating
issues, testing theories and ideas, and combining and re-formulating ideas into
other possibilities.
Collaborating
└ Collaborating with others helps us understand how they think and gives us new
ideas to think about. It also helps others feel involved and that their contributions are
valued. This is especially important in teamwork.
Critical thinking
Critical thinking involves reflecting on possible solutions to a problem and evaluating
them against criteria to judge the validity of each possible solution. It involves looking
carefully at an issue and making a decision based on what you know from by questioning
your own and others’ ideas.
Critical-thinking skills are important because they help solve problems, identify solutions
and generate new ideas. Many workplace issues such as process inefficiencies, resource
allocation and workplace safety can be improved by using critical thinking.
Another activity is the Six Thinking Hats exercise, based on Edward de Bono’s work on
lateral thinking and problem-solving . In this activity, you and your team put on various
‘hats’ in order to examine a problem.
└ The White Hat calls for information known or needed: just the facts.
└ The Yellow Hat symbolises brightness and optimism. Under this hat, you explore the
positives and look for value and benefit.
└ The Black Hat is the devil’s advocate. Under this hat, you spot the difficulties and
dangers – where things might go wrong. The Black Hat is probably the most
powerful and useful of the hats but should not be used too often.
└ The Red Hat signifies feelings, hunches and intuition. Using this hat, you express
emotions and share fears, likes, dislikes, loves and hates.
└ The Green Hat is about creativity: possibilities, alternatives and new ideas. Using this
hat provides an opportunity to express new concepts and new perceptions.
└ The Blue Hat is used to manage the thinking process. It’s the control mechanism
that ensures the other hats are being used.
2D Establish rewards
Here is a list of staff characteristics, the types of things that motivate each person
and what a suitable reward might look like. Notice that very few of the rewards relate
to money.
A rewards program
A rewards program can provide the necessary boost for many team members,
build spirits, inspire creativity and increase motivation.
A rewards program can give the team more exposure in the organisation and recognition
of their work. Rewards can include the act of publicly recognising outstanding efforts in
front of the rest of the team or wider organisation. The key is to ensure that every team
member has a reasonable opportunity to achieve a reward.
• The system must be fair and achievable for all employees, not just the high achievers.
• It must aim to motivate workers and be relevant to the objectives of the team.
• It must be based on clear targets that are known to the team to avoid conflict when one
member feels another is being given preferential treatment.
• It must support the organisation’s core values.
Examples of rewards:
Half-day reward Staff can leave early if they meet their targets.
Parking space for a Reward a team member with one paid parking space for a month.
month
Travelling trophy Organise a trophy for the best performer that sits at each person’s desk
for a set period, and is then rotated around the team.
Time off in the field Offer access to a specialised conference, training event or seminar.
further training Provide payment for a short course or formal training qualification
Example
Summary
• The team can share their working practices, learn from one another and provide
support for better work practices.
• Developing ground rules for the team can help identify ways of working better.
• It is important to be transparent, inclusive, fair and equitable when allocating
team responsibilities.
• Before allocating roles to team members, it is critical to determine the skills and
strengths of each person.
• Thinking, challenging and collaborating are important proactive aspects of
innovation and time needs to be set aside for them.
• For innovation to happen, it is essential to plan and schedule thinking,
challenging and collaborating activities in and around core activities.
• Individuals and teams need to be rewarded in ways that are meaningful and
useful to them.
Supportive
Participative
Achievement-oriented
Directive
Here are some characteristics that you can display in your interactions with the team
that allows for innovation.
Collaborative
Equitable
Fair
└ Don’t offer a judgment on any idea or contribution too quickly or without giving
sufficient attention to it.
Fun
Hard-working
└ Demonstrate a willingness to put in whatever effort it takes, which helps others see
that their efforts will also be valued and rewarded.
Reflective
Responsible
└ Show maturity and the ability to acknowledge personal successes and failures.
Example
Communication strategies
Sharing ideas in a team can involve a number of steps.
Steps for sharing information or knowledge or ideas might look like this:
1. A discussion is initiated, such as organising a meeting.
2. Background information is provided, such as a work issue or opportunity for
improvement.
3. Information is shared, such as insights, experiences and thoughts on continuous
improvement processes and systems.
4. Evidence is presented that supports the rationale for a new idea or a change in the
way things are done.
5. Responses, reflections and feedback from the team are provided, such as email
suggestions, insights and input where possible.
Sometimes a team member may initially discuss their ideas with one other team member
who does the same work. Then they may choose to share this information with the
whole team.
Different communication strategies are suitable at the various stages of the innovation
process.
└ Brainstorming
Questioning
└ Probing
Active listening
└ Exploring options
Challenging
Creative thinking
└ Collaborating
Providing positive reinforcement
└ Debriefing
Obtaining feedback
Forums
Meetings
Newsletters
Reports
Reports are based on agreed reporting systems. For example, they could
provide research into an area where opportunities have been identified or they
might report on advice about ways to enhance processes and systems.
Here are some strategies to adapt a communication style to different audiences, and
ensure that your message is communicated in an effective and respectful manner.
Plan methods
Communicate clearly
• Ask direct questions to ensure the audience understands the message you
are communicating.
• Rephrasing a question can make it clearer to understand.
• Allow time for people to think before responding.
• Take into account the language and literacy skills of the audience to ensure
they understand the whole message.
• Consider cultural aspects; in some cultures it is insulting for people to say
‘no’ and so they would rather tell you they understand.
• Actively listen.
• Consider body language – non-verbal communication accounts for up to 70
per cent of meaning in spoken interactions.
Written communication
Example
Challenge ideas
For some, having an idea challenged by a work colleague can be a negative
experience.
Challenge should be seen as a way of turning an idea into reality. Challenging and testing
are not about arguing, or about winning or losing; they are about ideas.
Individual team members will have their own ways of thinking. People who develop ideas
easily might enjoy brainstorming activities and interacting with others. Others may
think better on their own and find it hard to come up with ideas under pressure.
The team as a whole needs to make allowances for different interaction styles to ensure
everyone is able to participate. To do this, set up activities or sessions that include a
range of different strategies for collecting ideas, such as small group activities, one-on-
one activities as well as verbal and written tasks.
Activities to test and challenge ideas need to allow time to explore things in detail. The
information around the idea needs to be checked that it is reliable and trustworthy, and
tested for its practicality or appropriateness as a solution.
Strategies to use with a team to challenge and test ideas can involve one or more of the
following:
Based on the premise that no idea is all good or all bad, this is a great way to
find out what is good and what is bad about an idea. This can also be used as a
way of comparing competing ideas.
A SWOT analysis
Example
SWOT analysis
The following is an example of a SWOT analysis for the introduction of a new product.
The analysis provides information in terms of change requirements.
Summary
• Demonstrating appropriate behaviours is vital in supporting innovation.
• To support innovation, you need to encourage participation, treat people equally
and not rush to judge them or their ideas.
• Innovative ideas are more likely to succeed if a team is allowed dedicated time to
challenge and test the ideas.
• Knowledge and ideas should be communicated proactively and openly to others.
• Ideas need to be explored and challenged in a collaborative environment.
Was the idea new and For an idea to be innovative, it’s not a case of trying something that
original? may have failed before.
Was the idea An innovative solution needs to be put into practice for it to
implemented as be successful. If it can’t be implemented or there are issues in
planned? implementing it, then it is not a successful innovation for your
workplace.
Did it address a real Innovations need to provide a solution to an actual problem. Identify
challenge? the problem the innovation aimed to address and consider whether
the innovation has resolved that problem.
Does it add value to the The team needs to benefit from the innovation for it to be viable and
team? considered a success. This may be evident in time or money saved,
increased morale and/or productivity. This criteria that will need to
be monitored and measured to determine success.
Establish criteria
Benchmarks are criteria that can be used to evaluate the innovation’s successes.
A review process will determine whether a change process is working properly to achieve
its objectives. Improvements need to be monitored to determine if there is benefit and
the initial problems have been rectified.
Measure of improvements may fit under one or more of these categories:
Productivity Has the innovation increased productivity in the team or in their output?
Individual and Has the innovation improved individual performance and overall
organisational organisational performance?
performance
Data as evidence
To support your evaluation, you need evidence of improvements.
You can collect the data through review of documentation and figures, or interviews
with and questionnaire responses from staff or other stakeholders, such as customers
and suppliers.
Look for valid data and information that is:
• accurate (calculated correctly)
• current (related to the period of time you are investigating)
• reliable (from a reliable source, such as an internal sales figures from the
marketing department).
This will ensure you get a clearer picture of the success of the innovation. If the data
you use is poor quality, it will be difficult to identify, compare and report on actual
performance. Examples of data you might collect include timesheets, maintenance
reports, WHS incident reports, waste reports, stocktake reports, customer feedback,
budget reports and system user reports.
Example
Reflection allows you to consider the decisions made, how they were
implemented and what did and didn’t work.
Reflection is essential for continuous improvement, but first you need to gather all the
facts to ensure you are considering the whole picture.
• to determine what problems arose and how these might be prevented in future
• to identify areas for improvement
• to identify and quantify successes, and give recognition to team members for a job well
done
• to reinforce ideas and reach decisions
• to identify team and individual strengths and weaknesses
• to inform the planning of further development activities for individuals and the group.
Effective debriefing
Here are some strategies for ways to carry out effective debriefing.
└ This is a democratic approach, but some people may not feel comfortable sharing
their thoughts in an open forum.
└ This approach that allows for greater self-disclosure, but it can create barriers to
communication if it is not managed well.
└ These can generate useful information, but can also generate too much or too little
information, depending on how questions are framed and how team members
respond to them.
└ This is an objective approach, but it can make the process less friendly and more
clinical.
└ This approach allows for greater creativity and personal preferences, but makes it
harder to compare responses.
Reflect on activities
Reflections can be based on personal performance, team performance or both.
Reflection activities need to be managed carefully – you want team members to be
honest and open about their experiences, but you do not want them to focus on the
performance of other team members. Each person must take personal responsibility to
ensure the atmosphere remains positive and helpful. Positive statements about the way
others worked or contributed are appropriate. Pointing the finger at someone who did
not pull their weight or achieve outcomes is not.
All team members should participate in debriefing and reflection activities, regardless of
their role; they should also encourage and support others during the process.
• What was your experience (your thoughts, feelings, reactions, level of control, overall
satisfaction)?
• What did you learn about the work, yourself and others in the team or organisation?
• How could things be improved next time?
• How can you review, analyse and measure your performance against standards or
benchmarks?
Example
Learning ‘I have learnt a great deal about the organisation and that some
people in it have great organisational skills we can tap into.’
Self-knowledge ‘I realised it doesn’t matter how much we improve this area, this
is not the kind of work I will ever really enjoy. It has been good
to see there are other teams and places I can work in at the
council.’
• the team
• customers or clients
• customer service team
• managers and supervisors
• other departments whose work aligns or is affected by the team
• human resources team members
• WHS team members
• consultants
• subject matter experts.
It is important to ensure the person asked to provide the feedback is qualified to do so.
For example, there is little point in asking a customer whether they like the fact that you
invested in a faster printer, but they can comment on the speed of your service.
Feedback may be given without being asked for, such as when a customer complains
about the service they received. In this case it would be good to follow up with the
customer and ask further questions or find other ways to ensure the person provides the
right kind of information.
Focus groups
Focus groups are used to consult with groups of stakeholders. They are often
the most efficient method for obtaining information from large groups. When
facilitating focus groups, prepare questions to promote discussion in the areas
that feedback is required. The facilitator, or a note-taker, is responsible for
taking notes throughout the discussion to capture the feedback.
Surveys
Surveys are an excellent tool for obtaining feedback from large groups of
stakeholders, particularly when they are situated across a number of locations.
Surveys typically involve preparing a questionnaire for respondents to
complete.
Interviews
Formal interviews are very similar to focus groups except that they are
conducted one-on-one. As with focus groups, it is important to prepare a set of
questions to obtain feedback in the areas required.
Team meeting
Informal discussions
Observations
Example
Respond to feedback
You should welcome any feedback and respond with respect and courtesy –
regardless of whether the information is positive or negative.
When you receive feedback, try to understand clearly what the other person is telling
you. Assess the information on its merits to determine its validity and use your wisdom
to determine whether it can help you to improve in the areas suggested.
You may have to share the feedback with others in a report or by giving a verbal
presentation with a summary of your reflections.
Although you don’t need to take on board and agree with every piece of feedback you
receive, you do need to consider its merits in an analytical and unemotional way.
Example
• Discuss if the risk is too high and the consequences too damaging. If so,
determine ways to avoid the risk, such as looking for alternative processes.
• Develop a contingency plan as a way of managing the negative consequences or
impacts.
To manage the challenges that have been identified, there may be suggestions to limit the
risk or make sure failures are not repeated. This may include actions such as arranging
for training or team-building exercises to improve collaboration and trust within
the team.
• Actions arising from discussions may also involve:
• regularly monitoring and evaluating systems and processes
• monitoring the external operating environment for the business
• continuing to encourage innovative thinking among staff to identify ways to
improve performance
• continuing to capture, assess and implement innovative ideas.
Example
Example
Documenting feedback
One of Joel’s objectives for the year was to promote innovation within his team.
Joel has worked actively on this throughout the year and has a number of examples
to discuss with his manager during his performance appraisal. Joel has collected
feedback from team members and stakeholders, minutes from meetings and financial
data, along with his own reflections, to discuss with his manager. Joel is prepared to
talk about his successes, but he has also documented the lessons he has learnt and
where he thinks he can improve in future. His manager is impressed with the work he
has done to prepare for his appraisal.
Summary
• Criteria needs to be established for what makes a successful innovation.
• Sharing innovation successes fosters a positive work environment and sets a
benchmark for others.
• Individuals and teams need to give themselves opportunities to debrief and
reflect on innovation processes and their outcomes.
• Feedback is important in order to ensure innovation is working in the best
interests of common goals and stakeholder interests.
• Identifying risks and meeting challenges are important parts of innovative
practice.
• Feedback needs to be documented so lessons are learnt and changes
implemented in future activities.