RM Lecture Notes Unit 2
RM Lecture Notes Unit 2
LITERATURE REVIEW,
RESEARCH DESIGN
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
IDENTIFICATION OF SCHOLARLY SOURCES
I) Authors: Are author names provided? Are the authors’ credentials provided?
II) Publishers: Who is the publisher of the information? Is the publisher an academic institution, scholarly, or
professional organization?
I) Audience: Who is the intended audience of this source? Is the language geared toward those with
knowledge of a specific discipline rather than the general public? The language should be fairly technical,
not simplistic
III) Content: Are the sources cited? Are there charts, graphs, tables, and bibliographies included? How long is
the source?
IV) Bias: The information should be based on fact, not opinion. The authors should appeal to the reader's
sense of logic, not emotion.
V) Currency: Is the date of publication evident?
VI) Frequency: How frequently is the periodical published?
VII) Web Page Domain: What is the domain of the page (for example: .gov, .edu, etc.)? Who is publishing or
sponsoring the page?
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
SOURCES OF LITERATURE
• Literature refers to the collection of scholarly writings on a topic.
• This mainly includes peer-reviewed research work, such as:
• Journal Articles
• Books
• Book Chapters
• Working Papers
• Conference proceedings
• Theses
• Dissertations
• Research Reports
• Non academic source like:
- Newspaper/ Periodical Articles
- Blog articles and trade publications
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
LITERATURE REVIEW PROCESS
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
• Step I: SELECT THE TOPIC
-Select a topic you can manage in the time frame you have to complete your project.
-Establish your focus questions. Your focus questions must be specific enough to guide you to the
relevant literature.
Once the review is done, you can work on creating your conceptual maps to identify the research
gaps in your field of study.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
FORMATS OF DOING LITERATURE REVIEW
• Narrative literature review
• Narrative literature reviews critique and summarise a body of literature about the thesis topic. The
criteria for literature selection for a narrative review is not always made open to the reader. The
principle purpose of a narrative review is the give the author and reader a comprehensive overview of
the topic and to highlight significant areas of research.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
WHAT DOES A CONCEPT MAP INCLUDE?
A concept map has three basic elements – Shape, Arrows and Text.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
Step II: Create a focus question.
We have to narrow down the broader concept so that we can do a very in-depth examination and come up
with a neat map. So, we use a focus question – How has Covid-19 outbreak affected the education sector?
Student Motivation, Online learning Platforms, Teachers’ readiness, Teaching Effectiveness, Competency
appraisal, Student Evaluation, Offline Versus Online, Family Perception, Emergence of MOOCs, MOOC
retention rates, School from home, Parents reaction to virtual classes, Students Engagement.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
Step IV: Clubbing of Topics
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
CONCEPT MAP OF COVID-19 AFFECTING EDUCATION SECTOR
COVID-19
Impact of
Covid-19 on
Education
• A proper research design ensures the research is systematic and facilitates the smooth sailing of the
various research operations.
• It ensures research is as efficient as possible yielding maximum information with minimal expenditure in
terms of time, money and efforts.
• Research design also has a significant impact on the reliability of the results obtained.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
PERTINENT QUESTIONS W.R.T RESEARCH DESIGN
• The research design section of any work seeks to answer all these questions.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
ESSENTIALS OF A
RESEARCH DESIGN
#1. INTRODUCTION
Introduce the problem for the intended audience, state the need for conducting such study and why it
appeals to you.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#4. SCOPE OF STUDY
What is the academic scope of your study? Boundaries of your study
What is the geographic scope of your study? Region of your study
What is the time scope of your study? Timeline of your study
We generally tend to mention the assumptions made during the study in this section.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#6. CONCEPTUAL MODEL
This is a bird's-eye view of the extant literature, the underlying themes and how those themes are inter-
connected. How a concept model/ map is drawn up is mentioned in the earlier section of this PPT.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#10. GEOGRAPHICAL AREA
• Not possible to go for extensive study always (Govt backed Census/Large grants/ Small study
population).
• So, we narrow down our study to a specific region or province.
• Sample Locations – Area of fieldwork.
• Also known as geographical scope of the study.
• Depends on the purpose of the study and the resources available.
• Justification for choosing these locations?
• Generalization is key in every research.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#11. REFERENCE PERIOD
• When survey items are asked about the past, the time indicated in the request is called reference
period.
• It could be real time "Daily Internet Usage"
• It could be about the past "Holocaust Days"
• It could be about the future too, if the researcher is looking into variables like "Willingness to Buy."
• It could be about a number of years: "Profits for the last three years."
• There should be clarity in the mind of both the researcher and the respondent about the same.
• Difficulties in conducting studies that have a very old reference period.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
Wearable GPS
tracker that
enables real
time data
collection about
athletes
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#12. METHODOLOGY
• Overall typology of the design:
- Experimental, Correlational, Historical etc. Is discussed.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#13. SAMPLING DESIGN
• Universe (The total of the items or units in any field of inquiry)
• Population (The study population after adding time and geography filters)
• Sample (A part of the population, ideally should be representative)
• Sample Unit (Could be an individual, a household or an institution)
• Sample Size (Formula based or literature based or judgement based)
• Sample Technique (Probabilistic or Non probabilistic sampling)
• Sample location (Which states or cities or areas?)
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#15. PLAN OF ANALYSIS
• Quantitative?
• Qualitative?
• Triangulation Approach? (Data, Investigator, Theory, Methods)
• Which software? (SPSS/ STATA/ R/ Nvivo/ATLAS)
• Which specific technique? (Association, Correlation, Regression, Thematic)
• Testing of conditions before going for tests (Scale, Normality, No outliers)
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#17. TIME BUDGET
• Generally Gantt chart is used.
• Work is broken down into different components - Lit Review, Instrumentation, Pilot Testing, Field work,
Data Entry and Cleaning, Data Analysis, Report Writing, Publishing papers.
• Estimated completion times are also mentioned to keep track.
• Should include time for contingencies. (Field work during lockdown phase became impossible. It was
also difficult to collect data during demonetization).
• Helps you be ready for progress presentations.
• Identify areas of improvement.
• In case the project doesn’t finish on time, it is perceived as a sign of inefficiency and leads to additional
costs.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
#18. FINANCIAL BUDGET
• Breakdown of the costs involved.
• Purchase of hardware.
• Purchase of books.
• Subscription to premium journals.
• Paying the permanent research staff.
• Paying the contractual field staff.
• Printing and Stationery.
• Traveling expenses for fieldwork.
• Organizing conferences.
• Conference registration.
Sandeep Kr Singh,
Lecture Notes
APA Citation and
References
What is APA?
American Psychological Association
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Quoting Directly vs. Paraphrasing
Short Quotations
If you are directly quoting from a work, you will need to include the author, year of publication, and
the page number for the reference. Introduce the quotation with a signal phrase that includes the
author's last name followed by the year of publication in parentheses.
According to Jones (1998), "Students often had difficulty using APA style, especially when it was
their first time" (p. 199).
Long Quotations
Place direct quotations that are 40 words, or longer, in a free-standing block of typewritten lines,
and omit quotation marks. Start the content on a new line, indented 1/2 inch from the left margin.
Jones's (1998) study found the following:
Students often had difficulty using APA style,
especially when it was their first time citing sources.
(p. 199)
Paraphrase
If you are paraphrasing an idea from another work, you only have to make reference to the author
and year of publication in your in-text reference. According to Jones (1998), APA style is a difficult
citation format for first-time learners.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Parenthetical Citations—
One Author
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Parenthetical Citations—
More than One Author
oWhen a work has two authors, always cite both.
oReference in text:
oLast names of authors separated by “and” (year of publication).
oRowling and Cramer (2005) argue for the development of new
curricula.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Parenthetical Citations—
Works Without an Author
oWhen a work is signed “Anonymous,” cite the word “Anonymous.”
o(Anonymous, year)
oStatistics show a higher incidence of criminal activity during the summer
months (Anonymous, 2007, p. 89-96).
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Parenthetical Citations—
Groups as Authors
oCorporations, associations, government agencies, research groups, etc. are
usually listed each time they are used in text, unless an abbreviation makes the
group easily recognizable.
oReference in the text:
oFirst time mentioned: Full name (year).
oThe National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) reports…(2002).
oSubsequent mentions: abbreviation (year).
oThe NIMH reports…(2002).
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List
oIndicates where info presented in the article can be retrieved.
oThe first line of an entry is at the left margin, and subsequent lines
are indented one-half inch (hanging indent).
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List—
Capitalization
oCapitalize the first word in the title and subtitle, and any proper
nouns (cities, countries, peoples’ names) for book, article, and
chapter titles.
oCapitalize the first word, all nouns, verbs, adverbs, and adjectives
for names of journals.
oDon’t drop any words, such as A, An, or The, from the titles.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List—
Journal Articles (Print)
oF o u r m a j o r p a r t s :
Author, date, article title, and
publication information (periodical title, volume
number, issue number and page number).
oL a s t n a m e , F i r s t i n i t i a l . S e c o n d i n i t i a l . ( Y e a r ) . T i t l e o f
article. Title of Publication, Volume Number, Issue
Number, Pages.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Journal Articles (Electronic Sources)
Eight major parts: author’s name, year, title of article, title of publication, volume,
issue, page numbers, and where is it retrieved from.
Last name, first initial. (year). Title of article. Title of publication, volume, page
numbers. Retrieved from where/ DOI
Jackson, G. (2004). Multiple historic meanings of the Spanish civil war. Science
and Society, 68(3), 272-276. Retrieved from the Lexis Nexis Academic database.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List—
Working Papers
oA u t h o r L a s t n a m e , F i r s t I n i t i a l . S e c o n d I n i t i a l . Y e a r . T i t l e
of Paper (Working Paper Number). Retrieved from Website
and URL
oD e m i n g , D . ( 2 0 1 2 ) . T h e l e n g t h e n i n g o f C h i l d h o o d ( N B E R W o r k i n g
Paper No. 14124). Retrieved from National Bureau of Economic
Research website http://www.nber.org/papers/w14124
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List—Books
oFour main parts: Author, year, title, and publisher information
oLast name, first initial., Last Name, first initial., & Last Name, first initial… (year). Title.
City of publication: Press.
oBroadway, B., Carrol, L., Smith, T. (2007). How the lady sings. New York: Harper.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List—Books
oArrange references by the same author chronologically, with the earlier
date of publication listed first.
Van Delay, A. (1994). Venetian blinds: Contemporary study of compulsive
lying. New York: Pendant Publishing (not “Publishers”).
oVan Delay, A. (1997). Seinfeld: The show about nothing. New York: Penguin
Books.
Print Version:
Eg: Considine, M. (1986). Australian insurance politics in the 1970s: Two case studies.
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Web Version:
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Organizational Report
INSTITUTION
Organization or Agency. (Year Published). Title of report or grey literature in sentence
case (Associated number). Publisher Name. DOI or URL
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute of Health. (2017). NIH Turning
discovery into health. (NIH Publication No. 11-7634). https://www.nih.gov/sites/default/files/about-
nih/discovery-into-health/nih-turning-discovery-into-health.pdf
INDIVIDUAL
1st Author Last Name, First Initial. Middle Initial., & 2nd Author Last Name, First Initial,
Middle Initial. (Year Published). Title of report in sentence case (Associated number).
Publisher Name. DOI or URL
Gerling, M., & Wilson, T. (2019). Evaluating the June area survey’s field enumerator training (RDD-
19-01). U.S. Department of Agriculture, National Agricultural Statistics Service, Research and
Development Division.
https://www.nass.usda.gov/Education_and_Outreach/Reports,_Presentations_and_Conferences/re
ports/Evaluating_the_June_Area_Surveys_Field_Enumerator_Training
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Reference List-
Newspapers and Magazine Articles
Five major parts: author, date of publication, title of article, title of newspaper
or magazine, page numbers.
Last name, first initial. (year, month day of publication). Title of article. Title of
newspaper or magazine, page numbers.
Kramer, C. F. (2003, June 22). A health threat baffling for its lack of a pattern.
The New York Times, p. A14.
For magazines, the volume number is italicized, with the issue number in
parentheses after, and inserted after the magazine title; formatted:
Volume(Issue).
Chamberlin, J., Novotney, A., Packard, E., & Price, M. (2008, May). Enhancing
worker well-being: Occupational health psychologists convene to share their
research on work, stress, and health. Monitor on Psychology. 39(5), 26-29.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Online Daily/Newspaper
oFive major parts: author’s name, date of publication, title of article, title of
publication, and web address.
oLast name, first initial. (year, month day of publication). Title of article. Title of
publication. Retrieved date, from web address.
oForeman, R., Bennett, E., & Collins, T. (1999, February 16). In forecasting their emotions,
most people flunk out. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com.
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
YouTube
Teo CRi. (2018, September 16). Sergio Ramos – The Gladiator [Video].
YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cbkL7tU4bw4
Sandeep Kr Singh
RM Lecture Notes
Twitter & IG
Veletsianos, G. [veletsianos]. (2015, January 5). That moment when you wish
your article was out of peer-review already [Tweet]. Retrieved from
https://twitter.com/veletsianos/status/552195307555934208
First name Last name. (Year, Month, Date). Status update text [Facebook
update]. Retrieved from URL
Bill Gates. (2014, July 1). Yikes. One state in the U.S. uses as much electricity as
Sub-Saharan Africa (not counting South Africa): http://b-gat.es/1nIhMR5
[Facebook update]. Retrieved from https://www.facebook.com/photo.php
Sandeep
Sandeep Kr
Kr Singh
Singh
RM Lecture Notes
RM Lecture Notes