An Emperical Study of The Effects of AI On Job Security
An Emperical Study of The Effects of AI On Job Security
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND OF STUDY
The advent of AI technologies has revolutionized various industries, leading to automation
in sectors such as manufacturing, finance, healthcare, and logistics. AI systems can now perform
complex tasks such as analyzing data, making predictions, and even performing medical diagnoses
(Manyika et al., 2017). While AI’s potential for increasing efficiency and innovation is undeniable,
it also raises concerns about job displacement and wage inequality (Brynjolfsson & McAfee, 2014;
Ford, 2015). Various studies indicate that low-skill and middle-skill jobs are most vulnerable to
AI-driven automation, which may result in long-term job insecurity (Frey & Osborne, 2017). With
the decrease of the proportion of labor force and the increase of labor cost, the prospect of
traditional manufacturing industry relying on manpower development is not optimistic. At present,
artificial intelligence technologies such as computer vision, natural language understanding, cloud
computing, smart home and so on are increasingly widely used in the manufacturing industry (Ben
Goertzel, Pei Wang, Shane Legg, 2017). With the further construction of the industrial chain, it
will lead to a wider range of longer-lasting industrial changes. From the Worker's point of view,
artificial intelligence has an inevitable impact on the survival of their work or work characteristics,
the increase of production efficiency will force manufacturing enterprises to eliminate certain
sectors, and reduce the degree of the human-post fitness as well. In this case, workers are required
to have a clear understanding of their future career planning and learning abilities. And job
insecurity will occur when the anxiety caused by the intervention of new technologies reaches a
certain level, which affects the employee's status and work efficiency. Employees’ job insecurity
has a great negative effect, which is not conducive to the physical and mental health of the
employees, but also to the productivity and organization stability of the enterprises (Cheng, H. R.
Jia, D. Li and H. Li., 2019). Therefore, it is of great significance to analyze the psychological
impact of AI on employees' job insecurity from the perspective of labor force for employees'
employment, job performance and the development of enterprises.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has rapidly evolved from being a concept limited to theoretical
discussions to a transformative force in various industries. With the ability to analyze vast amounts
of data, perform complex computations, and execute repetitive tasks with precision, AI has
1
revolutionized sectors such as manufacturing, healthcare, finance, and transportation. However, as
AI technologies such as machine learning, robotics, and natural language processing become more
integrated into the workplace, concerns regarding their potential impact on job security have
emerged. Historically, technological advancements have always altered the workforce, replacing
certain types of jobs while creating new opportunities. From the Industrial Revolution to the rise
of the digital economy, automation and technological change have often led to a reallocation of
labor. However, the speed and scale at which AI is evolving have raised questions about its
implications for the future of work. Many routine and repetitive jobs, particularly those in the
manufacturing and service sectors, are at risk of being automated, leading to fears of large-scale
unemployment. (Schwab K., 2016). The challenge for workers, industries, and policymakers lies
in managing this transition—ensuring that the workforce is adequately prepared for the AI-driven
future while mitigating the negative impacts on job security.
This study seeks to empirically explore the effects of AI on job security, examining both
the opportunities and risks it presents, and providing insights into how individuals, organizations,
and governments can navigate this new era of automation. By assessing real-world data and case
studies, this research aims to contribute to a more nuanced understanding of AI's influence on
employment trends.
2
1.3 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
The primary objective of this study is to empirically analyze the effects of Artificial
Intelligence (AI) on job security across different sectors. The specific objectives are:
1. To examine the extent to which AI technologies are displacing traditional jobs, particularly those
involving repetitive tasks.
2. To investigate the types of new job opportunities that AI is creating, and the skills required for
these roles.
3. To assess the readiness of the current workforce to adapt to the changing job market brought about
by AI.
4. To explore the role of organizational and governmental interventions in managing AI’s impact on
job security.
5. To provide recommendations on how individuals, organizations, and policymakers can address the
challenges and leverage the opportunities presented by AI in the labor market.
3
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
4
2.2 AI APPLICATIONS IN VARIOUS INDUSTRIES
At the moment, artificial intelligence and machine learning are finding ready application
in various industries. Applications in the field of engineering include: bionics, neural networks,
adaptive management system, CAD, retro-and prognostic systems, expert systems, means of
leading scientific and technical information in design and other areas of engineering activity. These
applications have a significant impact on the economic effect and the quality of engineering
products. The use of these tools in the engineering and technology units of enterprises can be of
strategic importance. (A. Agrawal, S. Rothe, R. 2020) Today, only 30% of companies have
embarked on the use of AI-based products to integrate those products into their core business
processes (customer demand predictions, costly machinery maintenance, general problem-solving,
and so on). AI is becoming a part of the solution for mainly consumer goods, manufacturing, IT,
telecommunications, business services, logistics, advertising, and production. Data and content
management as well as all the content services provided for AI's interpretation, sense, and action
form the next AI practical application block. Businesses and industry leaders are still at the stage
of taking innovative steps in the data and information services arena. There is only a 16% use of
AI in their content services sector. They have the potential to launch a series of significant business
benefits. From process enhancement to the creation of entirely new data enhanced products or
derived services. In this era, many AI-based content services will disrupt the way businesses
operate. In situations where conventional human decision-making processes, such as diagnostics
and analysis of medical images or complex equipment, change fundamentally, large scale changes
are possible beyond the continuous improvement of existing processes.
5
ratio of the enterprises, the more the demand for the application of artificial intelligence
technology. If manufacturing enterprises want to adapt to the uncertain future, they need to
abandon the backward mode of production capacity, reduce the dependence of production mode
on manpower, step-by-step transformation of enterprise production model (Guan Hao, 2020).
6
AI and the Changing Skill Requirements:
In another influential work, Acemoglu and Restrepo (2019) examined the relationship
between automation and the changing demand for human labor. Their research suggests that
although AI displaces certain types of jobs, it simultaneously increases the demand for more
cognitive, creative, and emotional intelligence-based roles that AI cannot easily replicate. Their
work stresses the need for a workforce that is prepared to take on these more complex, higher-
value tasks that require human skills.
7
CHAPTER THREE
DICUSSION
1. Job Displacement through Automation: One of the most immediate and visible impacts of AI
is the automation of routine and repetitive tasks. AI systems excel in handling data-intensive
processes, such as customer service chatbots, automated manufacturing, and algorithmic trading.
This has led to job displacement in roles that are heavily reliant on predictable tasks. Industries
such as manufacturing, retail, transportation, and financial services are particularly affected by this
trend. For example, autonomous vehicles and AI-powered logistics systems are already reducing
the need for human drivers and manual operations in warehouses. Similarly, AI-driven chatbots
and virtual assistants are replacing customer service representatives in many companies. While
automation increases efficiency, it raises concerns for workers whose jobs are at risk of being
automated, especially in low-skill positions.
2. Job Transformation and the Rise of Hybrid Roles: While AI may displace some jobs, it also
transforms others. Rather than eliminating certain roles entirely, AI can augment human
capabilities, creating "hybrid" roles where humans and AI systems collaborate. Workers in these
8
hybrid positions use AI to enhance their productivity, while still performing tasks that require
creativity, critical thinking, or emotional intelligence. For instance, in healthcare, AI assists doctors
in diagnosing diseases through advanced imaging analysis and data interpretation, but the human
element in patient care remains crucial. In fields like marketing and design, AI tools help
professionals analyze data, predict trends, and automate mundane tasks, allowing them to focus on
creative strategies and human-centered work. The shift towards hybrid roles presents an
opportunity for workers to evolve and take on more complex, meaningful tasks.
3. Job Creation in AI-Related Fields: AI’s impact on job security is not entirely negative. As the
technology advances, it creates new roles in AI-related fields such as data science, machine
learning, AI system design, and cybersecurity. The development, deployment, and maintenance of
AI systems require specialized skills, leading to increased demand for professionals with expertise
in AI and technology. Job roles like AI engineers, data analysts, AI ethics consultants, and machine
learning specialists are rapidly growing as organizations adopt AI. These new roles offer promising
career opportunities, though they require significant investment in education and training to build
the necessary technical competencies. As AI transforms industries, the creation of high-skill jobs
may offset some of the displacement caused by automation.
4. Unequal Impact Across Sectors and Demographics: The impact of AI on job security is uneven
across different sectors and demographics. Low-skill jobs that involve repetitive tasks are at
greater risk of being automated compared to jobs that require high levels of creativity,
interpersonal skills, or strategic thinking. This disparity can exacerbate existing inequalities in the
labor market, particularly for workers in low-wage positions who may find it difficult to transition
into new roles requiring advanced skills.
5. The Gig Economy and AI-Driven Work Platforms: AI is also reshaping the structure of
employment itself, particularly through the rise of the gig economy and AI-driven work platforms.
Platforms like Uber, TaskRabbit, and Upwork use AI to match workers with temporary or
freelance jobs, giving rise to more flexible forms of employment. While these platforms create
opportunities for short-term work, they often lack the job security, benefits, and protections
traditionally associated with full-time employment. The gig economy, driven by AI algorithms,
has both positive and negative implications for job security.
9
3.2 HOW AI AFFECTS EMPLOYMENT NEGATIVELY
1. Healthcare: AI and automation affect healthcare employment negatively, as intelligent algorithms
may be able to replace certain human workers in the healthcare industry in areas like medical
imaging, lab work, record keeping, and other areas by automating some analysis and
administrative duties.
2. Job losses: Over time, AI, and automation of duties such as lab test interpretation, medical imaging
analysis, administrative functions, and even some clinical diagnostics may replace many
healthcare positions (L. Nedelkoska and G. Quintini, 2018).
3. Deskilling: Relying too much on AI tools for diagnosis and treatment recommendation runs the
risk of undermining the analytical and decision-making abilities that physicians have honed via
education and practice also, healthcare workers may need to learn new skills to integrate AI and
automation into their jobs. The workforce's shift to these new skill sets may present difficulties,
which could lead to short-term job disruptions.
4. Loss of human connection: Another concern associated with the increasing delegation of care
tasks to AI systems is the deterioration of important human relationships and compassionate
treatment in the patient-provider relationship (T. Shanafelt, J. Goh, and C. Sinsky, 2017).
Efficiency benefits should not come at the expense of interpersonal care. Therefore, even if AI
offers productivity and accuracy advantages, concerns about how it can negatively impact
healthcare jobs and the doctor-patient relationship if adoption outpaces adaptation persist.
5. Algorithmic bias: In healthcare AI, biased datasets and algorithms have the potential to spread
inequality by recommending subpar interventions or denying opportunity to existing marginalized
populations. Therefore, as algorithms take on more duties, efficiency will increase, but policies
governing matters like justice, safety, transparency, and maintaining characteristics of care that are
specifically "human" will also be required.
6. Education: Job losses: As administrative work and some instructional support functions become
more automated, there may eventually be less need for some non-teaching staff positions.
Academics have identified some shortfalls of AI in the educational sector such as job losses. As
previously indicated, even though automation increases productivity, it may cause certain
educational.
7. Deskilling teachers: An excessive dependence on curricular standardization and AI-driven
coaching runs the risk of undermining the educational expertise that instructors have acquired via
10
their education and practice (A. Nguyen, H. N. Ngo, Y. Hong, B. Dang, 2023). Researchers also
surmised that to effectively incorporate and use such innovations, instructors may need to
undertake extensive professional development when implementing AI in the classroom, which
could cause difficulties during the transition.
8. Student privacy concerns: Student privacy is a major concern raised using AI learning analytics,
student data tracking, and prediction models, which are currently poorly regulated by policies. It
highlights important concerns about the use of students' personal information considering the
extensive data gathering and analytics on students made possible by education technologies.
9. Loss of interpersonal relationships: Some caution that the social ties that enable effective
teaching and mentoring may weaken if AI tutors and standardization take on more roles. It runs
the risk of removing crucial social components from education as well as the freedom for teachers
to modify their lessons. Maintaining human agency in education is important.
10. Manufacturing: Job losses: Industrial robots, AI vision systems, additive manufacturing, and
other technologies that automate processes like assembly, machining, material handling,
inspection, and so forth have the potential to replace many current production jobs. Also,
manufacturing automation may affect jobs in supply chain management, logistics, and other
related industries as well as the factory floor, which could result in more significant issues for the
labour market.
11. High Cost and Changes: Robotics with AI come at a great cost. It requires a lot of power because
it uses sophisticated equipment. Its restoration and maintenance costs are also significant, in
addition to the installation costs. Adapting software programs to changing environmental
requirements necessitates multiple changes. In addition, procurement costs go up and recovery
takes a long period if there is a breakdown.
12. Mismatches in skills: When more automation occurs, workers may lose their jobs because they
do not have the technical skills or mobility alternatives necessary to move into the new, higher-
skilled roles. This will increase unemployment. Geographic impacts: Rather than balanced
transitions, certain towns or regions with a workforce specialized in automatable manufacturing
may see concentrated job losses and economic deterioration.
11
3.3 AI AND EMPLOYMENT: EXAMINING THE POTENTIAL FOR JOB CREATION
The influence of artificial intelligence (AI) on employment has been a topic of interest
among researchers in the past few decades. While concerns about job displacement due to
Artificial Intelligence (AI) have dominated much of the discourse, an equally important aspect is
AI’s potential to create new employment opportunities. As AI technologies continue to advance,
they are not only automating existing tasks but also generating demand for new roles, skills, and
industries. This section explores the potential for job creation through AI, focusing on AI-
augmented roles, new job categories, and the reshaping of industries.
1. AI-Augmented Roles
AI is increasingly being used to enhance human capabilities rather than replace them
entirely. This form of human-AI collaboration is giving rise to AI-augmented roles where humans
and AI systems work together to improve productivity and decision-making. In fields like
healthcare, finance, and education, AI systems are being used to analyze large datasets, identify
trends, and provide decision support, allowing human workers to focus on more complex tasks
that require creativity, empathy, and critical thinking.
For example, in healthcare, AI is being used to assist in diagnosing diseases through image
recognition and predictive analytics, enabling doctors to make more informed decisions. Similarly,
in finance, AI-powered systems are helping analysts manage vast amounts of financial data,
automating routine processes while allowing human workers to focus on strategy and higher-level
analysis. These hybrid roles are expected to become more common as AI technology becomes
more integrated into business operations.
12
and free from bias. This is particularly important as the role of AI in decision-making processes
grows, with implications for areas such as hiring, loan approval, and legal judgments.
13
solutions. These startups not only contribute to job creation by hiring talent but also spur the
growth of AI-related services such as consulting, software development, and cloud-based AI
solutions.
Moreover, AI is reducing the barriers to entry for new businesses by providing tools that
automate many of the traditionally labor-intensive aspects of starting a business, such as
marketing, customer service, and financial planning. This democratization of technology is
enabling more individuals to become entrepreneurs, thereby driving job creation in non-traditional
sectors.
7. AI in Creative Industries
Another emerging area where AI is driving job creation is in creative industries, such as
content creation, marketing, music, and the arts. AI tools are increasingly being used to assist in
generating creative outputs, from music composition to graphic design. For example, AI-powered
platforms can help create promotional materials, analyze market trends, and optimize content for
social media, driving demand for professionals who can integrate AI tools into creative processes.
While AI may automate some aspects of creativity, it also allows human workers to focus on
higher-level tasks, such as strategy, innovation, and the development of complex creative concepts.
8. AI in Cybersecurity
As AI becomes more prevalent across industries, the need for robust cybersecurity
measures has become more critical. AI is both a tool for enhancing cybersecurity and a potential
risk factor. This growing need for AI-driven cybersecurity solutions is creating jobs for
cybersecurity experts specializing in AI threat detection, algorithmic defense mechanisms, and AI
14
risk mitigation strategies. AI-powered cybersecurity firms are on the rise, and they require skilled
workers in fields like ethical hacking, cybersecurity consultancy, and AI system auditing.
Governments and corporations are increasingly prioritizing cybersecurity investments to protect
against AI-powered cyber threats, further contributing to job creation in this field.
9. AI in Healthcare Innovation
1. Upskilling and Reskilling Programs: One of the most significant interventions organizations can
make is investing in upskilling and reskilling their workforce. As AI technologies take over
repetitive and lower-skill tasks, workers need to acquire new skills to stay relevant in the evolving
job market. Many organizations are introducing internal training programs, partnering with
educational institutions, or utilizing online learning platforms to equip employees with the skills
needed to operate and collaborate with AI systems. Upskilling focuses on enhancing current
15
competencies, while reskilling prepares workers for entirely new roles within or outside their
current organizations. For example, IBM’s SkillsBuild initiative offers programs designed to help
employees adapt to the emerging digital landscape.
2. Human-AI Collaboration Strategies: Rather than replacing human workers, many organizations
are adopting strategies that integrate AI to augment human labor. AI can handle data-heavy and
repetitive tasks, while humans focus on more creative, strategic, and decision-making roles.
Organizations play a critical role in fostering environments where human workers and AI systems
collaborate effectively. By leveraging AI to enhance worker productivity rather than replace jobs
outright, organizations can reduce the impact of job displacement while maintaining
competitiveness. The implementation of AI in this way requires a thoughtful approach to task
distribution, employee engagement, and role redefinition.
3. Job Transition Support: For workers whose roles are at high risk of automation, organizations
can offer job transition support. This includes career counseling, mentoring, and helping
employees move into new positions either within the organization or in different industries. Large
companies such as Amazon have implemented Career Choice programs, which fund employees’
education in areas that are in demand and likely to grow in the AI age, ensuring that workers are
equipped for new job opportunities.
4. Ethical AI Deployment: To minimize adverse effects on job security, organizations must adopt
responsible AI practices. Ethical AI deployment involves creating systems that are transparent,
fair, and free of bias. Organizations have a responsibility to ensure that AI does not perpetuate
discrimination or marginalize certain groups within the workforce. By adopting responsible AI
practices, organizations can promote job security and foster an inclusive work environment, where
AI technologies benefit all workers, not just a select few.
1. Education and Workforce Development: Governments play a critical role in ensuring that the
workforce is prepared for the jobs of the future by investing in education and continuous learning.
AI is transforming skill requirements across industries, demanding proficiency in digital literacy,
data analysis, AI development, and other technical fields. Governments must work closely with
educational institutions to revise curricula and introduce programs that prepare students for an AI-
16
driven economy. In addition to formal education, governments can offer vocational training,
apprenticeships, and lifelong learning programs that help workers adapt to AI-induced changes.
For example, Singapore's SkillsFuture initiative provides funding for citizens to participate
in courses and training that will prepare them for the jobs of the future. Such initiatives ensure that
workers have access to the resources they need to upskill, reskill, and remain employable in a
dynamic job market.
2. Social Safety Nets and Labor Policies: To mitigate the impact of AI-related job displacement,
governments must strengthen social safety nets, such as unemployment benefits, healthcare, and
pension schemes. As AI transforms industries, workers may face periods of unemployment or
underemployment while transitioning to new roles. Governments need to ensure that during these
transitions, individuals have access to financial support and social protections. Additionally, labor
policies that ensure fair treatment of workers, including those in gig or freelance work, can protect
against exploitation in AI-dominated sectors.
Progressive labor policies can also address the challenges posed by AI-driven gig economy
platforms. For example, ensuring that workers on platforms like Uber or TaskRabbit receive
benefits and job security can prevent the rise of precarious employment conditions in an AI-
enhanced gig economy.
17
educational initiatives. Collaboration between the public and private sectors ensures that the
workforce is adequately prepared for AI advancements while enabling businesses to innovate
responsibly.
5. Support for AI Research and Innovation: Governments can also support AI research and
innovation by funding projects that explore the impact of AI on the workforce, identify areas of
job growth, and develop solutions to address job displacement. By investing in AI research,
governments can gain a deeper understanding of how AI will affect different industries and use
that knowledge to guide policy decisions. Moreover, research initiatives can focus on identifying
sectors where AI has the potential to create new jobs, helping governments and organizations
proactively prepare for these changes.
Individuals need to take charge of their career development to stay competitive in an AI-dominated
world. Key actions include:
Continuous Learning and Upskilling: As AI automates routine tasks, individuals should focus
on acquiring skills that complement AI. This includes technical skills (such as data analysis,
coding, and AI literacy) and soft skills (such as creativity, problem-solving, and leadership).
Online learning platforms like Coursera and LinkedIn Learning offer accessible courses on AI and
related topics.
Embracing Lifelong Learning: AI’s rapid evolution requires workers to continuously update
their knowledge. Lifelong learning, through formal education or self-directed study, will be crucial
for remaining relevant in an ever-changing job market.
18
Flexibility and Adaptability: Individuals should remain open to career shifts. While some jobs
may disappear due to AI, new roles will emerge. A willingness to pivot to new industries or job
functions will be critical for long-term career resilience.
Promoting an AI-Ethics Framework: Organizations need to ensure that AI systems are deployed
in a fair, transparent, and ethical manner. Establishing guidelines to govern AI's impact on workers
and adhering to responsible AI development can help avoid unintended consequences, such as
biased hiring algorithms or job discrimination.
Enabling Access to AI Education: Governments should promote education reforms that focus on
AI-related fields, such as STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics), while also
supporting the development of vocational and AI-specific training programs. Publicly funded
initiatives, such as those in Finland's free AI course (Elements of AI), demonstrate how
governments can make AI knowledge more accessible.
Ensuring Social Safety Nets: As AI transforms industries, some workers will inevitably face
displacement. Policymakers should enhance social protections, such as unemployment benefits,
job transition support, and retraining programs, to help displaced workers transition into new roles
without facing economic hardship.
19
Establishing AI Regulation and Labor Standards: AI regulations should address issues such as
fairness, transparency, and accountability in AI deployment. Governments should also adapt labor
laws to protect workers in AI-driven industries, particularly gig and freelance workers whose jobs
are increasingly influenced by AI systems.
20
CHAPTER FOUR
4.1 CONCLUSION
The impact of artificial intelligence on job security is multifaceted, involving both the
displacement of jobs and the creation of new opportunities. AI-driven automation has significantly
affected sectors involving routine, repetitive tasks, such as manufacturing and finance, leading to
job losses in these areas. However, AI has also created new roles in emerging fields, especially in
technology-related sectors, underscoring the importance of reskilling workers to adapt to these
changes. The findings of this study suggest that AI’s impact on job security depends largely on the
readiness of workers and industries to adapt to technological changes. Governments, businesses,
and educational institutions must play a proactive role in preparing the workforce for the future of
work. Reskilling programs, ethical AI deployment, and policies that promote continuous learning
are crucial to ensuring that AI benefits the workforce rather than undermines it. The study on the
effects of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on job security reveals both opportunities and challenges as
AI continues to integrate into the workplace. While AI has the potential to enhance productivity
and create new roles, it also poses a threat to traditional jobs, particularly those involving routine
tasks that can be automated. The findings suggest that while AI will not entirely replace human
labor, it will transform the workforce by shifting demand towards more skilled, AI-complementary
roles. It is, therefore, crucial for individuals and organizations to adapt by investing in skills
development, fostering innovation, and promoting AI literacy to ensure smooth transitions and
mitigate the impact on job security.
1. Longitudinal Studies: Continued research over extended periods to observe how the workforce
evolves with AI advancements across different industries.
2. Sector-Specific Analysis: Exploring how AI affects job security in specific sectors, such as
healthcare, manufacturing, and finance, which may exhibit unique dynamics.
3. Policy and Regulatory Frameworks: Investigating the role of government policies in ensuring
that the integration of AI into the workforce is equitable and does not disproportionately affect
vulnerable groups.
21
4. AI-Augmented Roles: Examining the nature of hybrid roles where AI complements human labor,
and understanding the skills required to excel in these jobs.
22