Rethinkinhg Shantinagar Bazaar: Hafsa
Rethinkinhg Shantinagar Bazaar: Hafsa
By
Department of Architecture
Brac University
December 2022
i|HAFSA
Declaration
It is hereby declared that
1. The thesis submitted is my/our own original work while completing degree at Brac
University.
2. The thesis does not contain material previously published or written by a third party, except
3. The thesis does not contain material which has been accepted, or submitted, for any other
ii | H A F S A
Approval
The thesis/project titled “Rethinking Shantinagar Bazaar” submitted by Hafsa Tasnim Ali
(18108005) of Fall, 2022 has been accepted as satisfactory in partial fulfillment of the
requirement for the degree of Bachelor of Architecture on 28/12/2022.
Examining Committee:
Supervisor:
_______________________________
(Member)
Fuad Hassan Mallick, PhD
Professor and Dean, School of Architecture and Design,
BRAC University
Supervisor:
_______________________________
(Member)
Iftekhar Ahmed, PhD
Associate Professor, School of Architecture and Design,
BRAC University
Supervisor:
_______________________________
(Member)
Naim A Kibria
Guest Lecturer, School of Architecture and Design,
BRAC University
iii | H A F S A
Abstract
A bazaar is a location where people enjoy to purchase their daily necessities and has existed
since the dawn of time. However, it is also a hub for social interaction and a variety of cultural
events, and it is currently a small and large mall complex located across the city. And the causes
of this shift are the increase in urbanization, the high cost of land, and the lack of available space.
The technique of creating a commercial space where a bazaar and other functions can mix so that
the space can be dynamic all the time is thoroughly explained in the following chapter of this
paper. Shantinagar Bazaar is the oldest bazaar in Dhaka city. Geographically located in
Shantinagar near Paltan area, the site has the potential to expand its commercial and economical
side of it.
iv | H A F S A
Acknowledgment
Above all, I want to express my gratitude to the Almighty for providing me with the chance,
perseverance, and strength to overcome so many obstacles and complete my thesis project. I'm
grateful to the Almighty, who made it possible for me to finish everything. And I am thankful to
I have my deepest gratitude towards my course instructor, Professor Iftekhar Ahmed, and Naim
A. Kibria, who helped me through the whole thesis process and constantly encouraged me to put
I am really grateful to Mumtahena Ali Rasty for her unwavering support and inspiration
Last but not least, I want to express my gratitude to Arif Raihan, Sarah Nafisa Hussain, Fayez
Ahmed, Sunny, Piu, Mim, Nahiyan, Shoily, and Elma for your assistance and for making my
journey better.
v|HAFSA
Table of Content
1 Declaration ii
2 Approval iii
3 Abstract iv
4 Acknowledgment v
5 Table of Content vi
1.5 Programs 4
2.2 Development 5
2.4 Bazaar 8
vi | H A F S A
8 Chapter 3: Context Study 13-24
6.3 Flexibility 45
13 Reference 56
vii | H A F S A
Chapter 01
Introduction
The oldest and busiest area in Dhaka, Shantinagar, is part of Paltan thana and is run by Dhaka
South City Corporation. It used to be a residential region, but as the city expands, new projects
including shops, markets, hardware stores, bazaars, malls, offices, schools, and colleges as well
as flyovers happen. Although there are many things, a decent shopping center is still necessary
so that all different types of people may go shopping on a daily basis. Business operations
depend heavily on commercial buildings, both for those who own them and for those who rent
them. Retailers, restaurants, offices, manufacturing facilities, and other sorts of enterprises might
all be housed in a commercial structure. Residential regions are in addition to business facilities.
The housing or residential regions are spreading as time goes by. Despite the rising cost of
the property, there are still numerous reasonable residential structures with essential amenities
nearby. The demand for housing will reach its pinnacle because of how quickly the population is
expanding. Shantinagar Bazaar stand is a small piece of land which is fulfilling neighborhoods
need for a long time but it lacks hygin, open space, MGC and other standard measurement for a
space that’s why it need to rethink and redesign so that it can be vibrant all the time.
1|HAFSA
1.2 Project brief
gradually it became a mixed-use area. Commercial, institutional, and more residential buildings
to accommodate the overloaded population of the city. This paper explores the academic
focusing on how to turn the project into an interactive, iconic landmark that is also energy-
efficient.
Shantinagar bazar is one of the oldest bazar but as day goes by the bazar is becoming more
unhygienic and harder to navigate since the surface is uneven, and when it rains, water blocking
becomes an issue. In addition, zoning wise this bazar is mixed in except for the fish and meat
bazars. In certain cases, it might be challenging to locate the product. Vendors are obstructing
2|HAFSA
both the highways and pedestrians. A very vital feature of market design has become the ease of
circulation, parking and maneuvering of vehicles (White, 1999). And the bazar doesn’t have any
dedicated parking lot. Adopting one way circulation, central zoning of markets and ring road
system is better for wholesale kitchen markets according to Food and Agriculture Organizations
appropriate designated unloading and loading bays should be available. Since just the ground
level of a sizable portion of the property was used for market activities, different uses of the site
could be implemented. Both a social hub and a green space are absent on the site. The system
ought to be improved in this area. Additionally, there must to be room for auctions.
Aim:
The project aims to create an iconic architectural landmark at the national level to look up to and
Objective:
• • To create various areas that, for optimal efficiency, fit both the demands of the users
3|HAFSA
1.5 Programs
- Kacha Bazar
- Super shops
- Convention hall
Office Space
- Restaurant
- Café
- Indoor Sports
-Gym
- Day Care
- Library
- HVAC Room
- Generator Room
- Parking
4|HAFSA
Chapter 2
Literature Review
Massive changes have been made to the social, economic, political, morphological, and
psychological aspects of the city of Dhaka. Three facts are all that are necessary to convey an
idea: in 1947, the capital of Provincial East Pakistan had 336,000 residents; in 1971, 1 million
people called it their home; and in 2001, more over 10 million people called it their home. Dhaka
has officially joined the global family of megacities. Savar, Narayanganj, Gazipur, Kadamrasul,
and Tongi are the five contiguous municipal areas that make up Dhaka, the fifth-largest megacity
(BBS, 1991). Dhaka Mega City has a total area of 1,353 km2, of which DCC takes up 276 km2
(BBS, 2001). The population of the megacity of Dhaka, which includes DCC, is currently above
12.3 million, according to the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA). The population of
Dhaka mega metropolis and DCC, respectively, is roughly 9.9 million and 5.3 million, according
to the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS, 2001). More than twice (19,286 per km2) as many
people live in DCC per square kilometer than the average for megacities, which is 7,918.
2.2 Development:
The process of establishing conditions that offer opportunities for improving everyone's level of
living within a community. Development typically aims to improve people's living conditions,
economic institutions that uphold human dignity and respect. Additionally, it aims to establish
conditions that can promote the development of one's own sense of worth.
Development that integrates two or more land uses, either vertically or horizontally, within a
single building, or numerous structures with different purposes on a different development site.
Depending on the zone and location, the uses may be combined horizontally or vertically;
nevertheless, a typical mixed-use complex frequently consists of ground-floor retail with either
housing or office space above. Some mixed-use developments go beyond the confines of a single
structure and may encompass entire communities where several uses are coexisting in close
crucial to the revitalization of urban and industrial regions. Mixed-use is often associated with
terms like “Smart Growth,” “New Urbanism,” “Transit-Oriented Development” and “Traditional
neighborhood development.” Mixed-use, however, is only one potential element present in these
development plans that may assist in achieving goals like boosting density, lowering the number
6|HAFSA
of automobiles, generating localized jobs, gentrifying urban districts, and offering vivacious
living spaces.
2.3.1Brief History
In the US, a mix of uses used to be commonplace before the adoption of contemporary zoning
and land-use policies. Until the invention of the vehicle, which drastically altered development
trends and patterns, mixtures of commercial and residential usage thrived. Human settlements
have often grown in mixed-use patterns. However, as a result of industrialization and the
development of the skyscraper, zoning laws were established by the government to distinguish
between distinct uses, such as industry, and residential zones. Separate-use zoning peaked in the
United States during World War II, but since the 1990s, mixed-use zoning has had a resurgence
Mixed-use development has once again become a strategy for urban rejuvenation, frequently as a
scales. They were more incorporated into urban environments and frequently connected to older
buildings or neighborhoods.
7|HAFSA
The expressions of sustainable design, walkable urbanism, and "smart growth" programs are
Urban planners and other experts started to realize during the latter half of the 20th century how
beneficial mixed-use development was and how it need to be pushed once more. Less emphasis
was placed on separating homes from hazardous industry as American cities became less
industrialized. Nowadays, a variety of uses is widely regarded as essential and necessary for a
healthy urban environment by both experts and residents. The concept of mixed-use
developments is not new. These photos from the Plaza area before the turn of the century show
how, prior to the establishment of zoning, living above shops was common in town centers.
2.4 Bazaar
Bazaars are open-air markets with several little stalls or businesses, particularly in the Middle
East, India, and Northeast Africa. The term "bazaar" is derived from Persian and refers to the
main public market area of a town.The "network of merchants, bankers, and craftspeople" that
operate in that region are also referred to by the term "bazaar" on occasion. Markets in Northern
Bazaars or souks have been documented since about 3,000 BCE. Bazaars are thought to have
originated outside the city walls, where they were frequently linked to meeting the demands of
8|HAFSA
caravanserai, despite the fact that the absence of archaeological evidence has hindered in-depth
examinations of their evolution. These bazaars developed along roads that spanned from one city
gate to another gate on the other side of the city as towns and cities flourished in population.
Walkways with covers replaced souks. These bazaars eventually connected to form a network of
trading hubs where goods and information could be traded. Large bazaars and stock exchanges
grew in popularity throughout the Muslim world, which facilitated the establishment of new
capital cities and eventually empires. Along trade routes and bazaars, new and prosperous cities
like Isfahan, Vijaynagara, Surat, Cairo, Agra, and Timbuktu were built.
Dhaka was chosen as the provincial capital of East Pakistan following the British Colony's
independence in 1947. Following the partition, there was an increase in the population of 103%
due to the influx of migrants from India. From 6 square miles in 1947 to 25 square miles in 1962,
Dhaka's size expanded. As a result, the city's rapid expansion started in 1947 as its population
rose. The expansion of New Market, on the other hand, enhanced the growing commercial
significance in and around the Azimpur area. The rise of private retail business centers in this
region was influenced by New Market's development as well. The earliest of them, Gausia
market, opened its doors in 1965. As a result, this road projected retail trade locations towards
the city's northwestern regions. As it split the Old Elephant Road in half in the center, it was
given the name New Elephant Road. Additionally, due to its proximity to New Market, the
western portion had a quick and unplanned expansion of businesses. However, the ancient
business district, which only served the old part of the city, was still made up of the Chawk,
9|HAFSA
Following the liberation struggle, Dhaka became the capital of a new country, Bangladesh, in
1971. As a result, the city rose to prominence as the biggest and most important center for all
national activities, including commerce and business. The "City of Mosques" and "City of
Gardens" were previous names for Dhaka. The outcome is, Dhaka has rapidly urbanized since
follow.
markets
Dhaka has rapidly urbanized as a result of its organic growth throughout the years in response to
the population's socioeconomic needs. The economics of urban land pricing are influenced by
the high value land use of retail, which in turn affects the specialization of other land uses. It also
10 | H A F S A
affects patterns of urban activity and space utilization and serves as a primary attractor land use.
Finally, for rural migrants moving to cities, retailing typically offers the initial job opportunity,
Retail trade is observed to be growing toward the northern portion of the city as a result of
changes in the socioeconomic position of the population and an increase in residential areas for
the high and upper middle classes. Despite the 1980s' concentration of the largest commercial
structures in the Motijheel region, CBD's activity gradually subsided (Ahsan, 1991). As Gulistan
became the center for political functions, the shopping areas were dispersed from Gulistan to a
number of shopping streets as a result of this shifting land use pattern. New business hubs began
to appear in the north in the New Market area, Elephant Road, Mag Bazaar, Mouchak, Farmgate,
and Gulshan and Uttara due to their closeness to the planned residential zones. Migration from
rural to urban areas was a major factor in the demand's explosive growth. As more and more
people began to migrate, the number of residential areas also began to grow, which boosted
trade. Thus, private initiatives were launched to satisfy public needs. Lack of unexpected growth
resulted in the disorganized construction of shopping centers throughout the city. The other well-
liked approach is grouping enclosed shopping centers together at nodal areas to take advantage
of their convenient placement. Dhaka City Corporation estimates that in 1983, the city's total
commercial area was around 1500 acres. By 1995, this had almost quadrupled in size (Hossain,
1995).
11 | H A F S A
12 | H A F S A
Chapter 3
Context Study
The site is located in Shantinagar Kacha Bazar which is just in front of Bir Uttam Samsul Alam
road. In front of the site there is Moghbazar Mouchak Flyover. It is basically a mixed use area.
The front façade of the road is commercial building. Nearby there are Baily road, Moghbazar,
These map shows that the site is surrounded by mixed use buildings. The first row from the road
is commercial building. It is a mixed-use development site where around the site there is less
14 | H A F S A
3.3 Figure Ground and Vegitation Map
The site has no open space or breathing space due to human increase. Therefore, it requires a
place where people can occasionally go and breathe. It is preferable to extend vertically rather
than horizontally. Having vegetation is crucial. The number of trees likewise decreases with
time. Therefore, the property needs more green and water-absorbing space.
15 | H A F S A
Figure: Vegetation Map, Source: Author
16 | H A F S A
3.4 Accessibility and Connectivity
Bir Uttam Samsul Alam Rd, Shantinagar Rd, Baily Rd, Circuit House Rd, VIP Rd, Shantinagar
Bazar Rd, and other roads surround the property. Everyone has easy access to everything since it
is all linked together. The Moghbazar Mouchak flyover is located in front of the site.
17 | H A F S A
3.5 Climate Analysis
18 | H A F S A
Figure: Inside the Bazaar, Source: Author
19 | H A F S A
3.6 Site and Surrounding Images
There are numerous office buildings, as well as a hospital, shopping center, mosque, and other
structures. The commercial belt is the first layer of the road. Although mixed-use business or
20 | H A F S A
Figure: Images of the Site, Source: Author
21 | H A F S A
3.7 Existing situation of Shantinagar Bazaar
There are several types of shops in Shantinagar Bazaar. Such as- vegetable, fruits, fish, meat,
mobile phone, kitchen gadget, tea stall, garments shop etc. There are some informal shops at
edge of the site and infront of the site blocking the footpath and road.
22 | H A F S A
Figure: Existing condition of Shantinagar Bazar, Source: Author.
23 | H A F S A
24 | H A F S A
Chapter 4
Case Study
For case study three projects have been selected. They are-Rotterdam Market Hall,
Architect – MVRDV
25 | H A F S A
Built Area – 95,000 m2
Markthal is the largest weekly open-air fresh food and hardware market in Rotterdam, located
next to Binnenrotte Square. On the bottom floor, behind an arch of flats, there is a sizable market
floor. Markthal creates a one-of-a-kind spectacle with its form, vibrant interior, and height. 120
meters long, 70 meters broad, and 40 meters tall make up the arch's present volume.
There is an underground grocery with refrigeration, storage, and preparation spaces, as well as
three stories of parking. Six goods lifts are available to convey products to the food and flower
market on the bottom floor, while the first floor now has 15 food stores and eight restaurants.
With triple glass and two layers of wall paneling, the public market's noise and annoyance are
The whole supply for the hall, the stores, and the eateries is buried. An expedition court is
located on the first basement floor, from which freight elevators may be used to access the
market hall for van deliveries. In this manner, residents are not impeded by distribution
26 | H A F S A
The glass façade of the hall really provides natural ventilation by allowing fresh air
to enter, climb toward the ceiling, and escape through roof ventilation ducts. The
A market hall, parking, and houses are all combined in the Markthal. The market hall is located
in the middle of a two-mass of dwellings that leans upward in the shape of an arch. The covered
patio doubles as a restaurant area after hours and a market during the day. As a result, the market
has no back and is an accessible, highly visible edifice. The arch's present dimensions are 120
The first level, ground floor, and basement are accessible to the general public. The market has
two main points of entry and departure on the ground level, compared to the inhabitants' six
27 | H A F S A
Figure: Circulation
28 | H A F S A
Structural Details:
29 | H A F S A
A cable net façade with minimum structural components was chosen to keep the closure as
transparent as feasible. Its basic structural layout is similar to that of a tennis racket, with the
Source: https://www.theplan.it/eng/architecture/en-markhal-rotterdam-1
30 | H A F S A
4.2 Case study 02: Mohammadpur Krishi Market
Market, a market for agricultural products, in 1978 on a 5-acre site in Mohammadpur, Dhaka.
The directorate's central office and district office are located in the south section of the main
structure. The market is bordered on the south by the Shiah Mosque and on the west by the
Shekhertek residential neighborhood and the Shyamoli link road. The river ghat (boat landing
point) on the market's west side was a benefit of its former position. But now that the ghat and
the nearby riverbed had been covered by new buildings and housing complexes, the market had
In the 1950s, Mohammadpur was intended to be a residential neighborhood. Before the Beribadh
[embankment] was built, this region had access to a canal from the west. New housing
developments including PC Culture Housing, Adabor, Nobodoy Housing, Japan Garden City,
31 | H A F S A
and many more continued to expand this residential region. One of the most active areas in
Mohammadpur is Krishi Market, which was built on land owned by the Directorate of
Agriculture Ministry for Agricultural Marketing of Bangladesh. The whole Mohammadpur and
Adabor Thana region uses this market as a center for the storage of rice and lentils.
Currently, Dhaka North City Corporation is in charge of running the market. Two main sections
make up the entire region. Between a few residential plots, there is a single large Aarot (entry
top) on one side and a large Kacha Bazar and grocery store on the other. The Aarot is located in
the front and spans a considerable area [more than 5 acres], with approximately 150 stores. More
32 | H A F S A
than 1400 employees and day laborers are employed by the storage. The government created
Krishi Market Kacha Bazar in 1982 on roughly 2 acres of ground. At first, there were 400
businesses in the market selling affordable clothing, food, jewelry, plastic goods, stationery,
The market was built in accordance with contemporary urban planning norms. It boasts spacious
hallways, excellent lighting, and ventilation. Every day, hundreds of pickup trucks, rickshaw
33 | H A F S A
vans, and trucks transport items to the market. It currently has 150 stores. 400 people work in the
shops, 200 people work as day laborers, 200 people pull rickshaws, and 200 women and children
community-square-mohammadpur-aiub/
34 | H A F S A
4.3 Case Study 03: KOHINOOR SQUARE
35 | H A F S A
Floor: 52 stories, 32 stories Count
Located in Shivaji Park, Mumbai, India, Kohinoor Square is a 52-story, 203-meter (666-foot),
semi-twin skyscraper with mixed uses that was once owned by Kohinoor Mills. It is located
where LJ Road and Gokhale Road intersect. A primary tower and a residential skyscraper with
mixed uses make up the Kohinoor Square complex. The Kohinoor Group is building homes,
hotels, apartments, and upscale shopping malls under the Kohinoor CTNL Infrastructure
Corporation. As of 2013, the building is one of South Asia's and India's tallest mixed-use
skyscrapers.
36 | H A F S A
The building's design is environmentally friendly and makes use of technology like floor-to-ceiling
insulated windows to retain heat and maximize natural light as well as an automatic daylight dimming
system. Kohinoor Square is the first high-rise neighborhood in Mumbai. Given that it was one of the first
skyscrapers in India to get a gold (lead) accreditation from the Green Building Council for environmental
sustainability and that it makes use of cutting-edge building techniques, it serves as a prime example from
A high-end shopping center occupies the first five levels of the main building, while a five-star
hotel and office space are located on the remaining 47 stories of the structure. On the fifth story
of the main structure, there is a five-star hotel. From the sixth through the fourteenth floors, there
37 | H A F S A
is separate office space with individual restrooms and shared restrooms available on each floor.
Office spaces and refuge areas are 24 meters tall and encircle the central core. Both structures'
parking garage is located on the first 13 levels of the residential building, while the remaining 19
storeys are homes. Personalized entry controls and super-efficient driveways offer parking for
around 2000 automobiles. core center (Office tower) Three lobbies and six lifts make up the
central core (office tower), which serves levels 25 to 39. When a lift lobby is not available, the
spaces between the elevators are utilized as restrooms, with dust on either side..
38 | H A F S A
39 | H A F S A
Chapter 05
Program Appraisal:
The following chapter explores the proposed programs for remodeling Shantinagar Bazaar. The
main components of the programs are authoritative facilities, commercial facilities, restaurants,
recreational space, residential facilities and supporting facilities, all of which have undergone
revisions to improve their efficiency in terms of space utilization in accordance with standards,
40 | H A F S A
Commercial Facility:
4 Restaurant
5 Library
E-library 1 - - 600
Storage 1 - - 400
6 GYM
Lobby 1 20 10 200
41 | H A F S A
No Name No. Of No. Of Area per Total Total
unit users unit area
(In sqft) (In sqft)
Locker Room 1 - - 500 4,500
Storage 1 - - 400
7 Office Type- A
Storage 1 - - 400
8 Office Type- B
42 | H A F S A
No Name No. Of No. Of Area per Total Total
unit users unit area
(In sqft) (In sqft)
General Manager 1 1 150 150 3,550x3=
Room 10,650
Assistant 1 1 150 150
Manager Room
Workstation 1 20 100 2000
Storage 1 300
43 | H A F S A
Chapter 06:
Design Consideration
The design consideration will serve as guidance to construct the market by taking into account
the findings of the investigations provided in earlier chapters and the demands of market users.
neighborhoods, all of which are 500 meters away from the site. The property has a well-designed
pedestrian pathway connecting it to these nearby places, which has the potential to encourage
more people to visit the site. As a result, promoting and improving foot traffic at the location will
improve the market's usability and effectiveness. Additionally, this will ease the impact on traffic
congestion.
People from all socioeconomic backgrounds must have access to it. A barrier-free inclusive
design that offers universal accessibility as well as positive settings appropriate for all ages and
types of people will ensure the participation of the various user and customer groups.
44 | H A F S A
6.3 Flexibility
Flexibility is an issue because there is limited room to move about and the location is highly
crowded. Ally will be 2 meters wide to make it easier for people to walk about.
Optimal use of sunlight will assist in lowering the bazaar's maintenance costs, making the space
more sustainable and economically viable. Natural ventilation is necessary to maintain a healthy
atmosphere for the well regulation of the market that serves both katcha and pacca bazaar. The
site's microclimate will be conducive to hosting public events thanks to the use of landscaping in
45 | H A F S A
Chapter 07
Design Suggestions
46 | H A F S A
Figure: Other Floor Plan, Source: Author
47 | H A F S A
Figure: Other Floor Plan, Source: Author
48 | H A F S A
Figure: Other Floor Plan, Source: Author
49 | H A F S A
Figure: West Elevation, Source: Author
50 | H A F S A
Figure: South Elevation, Source: Author
51 | H A F S A
Figure: Section AA’, Source: Author
52 | H A F S A
Figure: Section BB’, Source: Author
53 | H A F S A
54 | H A F S A
55 | H A F S A
Reference:
• Ahmed, B., Ahsan, R., & Ahamed, S. (2006). A case study of the morphological change
of four wards of Dhaka over the last 60 years. BUET.
• Hossain, N. (2009). Benign or Exploitative and Space Ref 027 The Changing Pattern of
Shopping Development in a Rapidly Developing City Dhaka. Stockholm.
• Sengupta, P. (2020). BRAC Tower - A mixed use multistorey, Dhaka,
Bangladesh. BRAC Tower - A Mixed Use Multistorey, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
• “Bazaar | market". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 2021-10-13.
• Sengupta, P. (2020b). BRAC Tower - A mixed use multistorey, Dhaka, Bangladesh Payel
Sengupta. BRAC Tower - A Mixed Use Multistorey, Dhaka, Bangladesh Payel Sengupta.
• Dani, A.H.; (1956); Dacca: A Record of its Changing Fortune. Dhaka: Asiatic Press
• Mumford, L.; (1970); The Culture of Cities; Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc.; New York.
• Dhaka Structure Plan for 2035, Government of Bangladesh
56 | H A F S A