T F L A: HE Rench AND Dministration
T F L A: HE Rench AND Dministration
1.
BACKGROUND
The French Cadastre derives from the napoleonian Cadastre and applies to all urban
and rural properties (built or not). The literal information is strictly linked to the
geographical one. A plot is defined as an entity linked to an owner and to a fiscal
division, following the napoleonian concept. Basically, the cadastre has a fiscal
function evoluting to an informative function and having, additionally, a certain
probative function. The "Conservation des Hypothques" Bureau keeps and
manages the Land Register.
The Cadastre is homogeneous on the whole French metropolitan territory with some
small discrepancies for the Alsace-Moselle cadastre whose juridical character is
more pronounced through the existence of a Register Book and the obligation to
mark the plots.
Until the revolution of 1789, the cadastre kept an essentially local nature in France
despite various attempts at the contrary. The kings Charles VII, Louis XIV and Louis
XV envisaged in turn the project of a regular cadastre, the basis of a coherent tax
system applicable to all the country.
The lack of finances, the shortage of sophisticated instruments and methods, the
resistance of the great vassals, and the disparity of the provinces (customs,
languages, measures ...) made these attempts fail.
Only a few provinces provided themselves with an institution whose advantages are
quite clear.
On the eve of the revolution, the basis of assessment of the tax relied on the same
method as that laid down by Roman law : declaration by owners of the content and
income from their property, under the supervision of commissioners.
2.
At the very opening of the States General of 1789, 73 electoral assemblies of the
Nobility and 58 of the Third Estats, demanded the realization of a general cadastre,
the only system capable of putting an end to the existing arbitrariness.
The Constituent Assembly, by the law of 1 December 1790, abolished the former
taxes - tallage, twentieh, capitation, and tithe - and replaced them by a single tax.
However, this law did not lay down the establishment of plans.
The decrees of 21 August and 23 September 1791 finallly authorized the department
directories to lay down the survey of the parcel plan of the territories. However, the
execution of this survey, payable by the communes was to remain limited.
The law of 22 brumaire year VI (12 November 1797) completed and extended by the
organic law of 3 frimaire year VII (23 November 1789) created the direct taxes
administration in charge of fair application of the tax.
However, a general parcel cadastre was not envisaged at this stage.
The system was still based on the declarations made by owners.
The Administration finally acknowledged the need for a general operation to
determine the content of each property and its income, but the cost of such an
operation and the time needed made the public authorities abandon the project.
A decree of the consuls of 12 brumaire year XI (3 November 1802) decided on a
"general cadastre by masses of crops" in 1915 communes. A plan drawn up to the
scale of 1:5000 presented the situation of the territory of theses communes in
masses marked out by natural limits. In each of these masses, the owners declared
the content of the parcels owned.
As the operation gave rise to complains by the mayors, general councils and owners,
it was abandoned after five years work.
The general surveying of all the parcels of the territory therefore became essential.
3.
The law of 15 September 1807 was at the origin of the French parcel cadastre.
Commenced in 1808, the works progressed rapidly until 1814 and then more slowly
from 1814 to 1821. after 1822 they took place at a swifter pace and were completed
in 1850 in continental France. They continued after this date in Corsica and in the
annexed territories (Earldom of Nice and Savoy).
The parcel cadastre, called the "old cadastre" remained unaltered however as no
updating was provided for.
The parcel situation was to be transformed with the general evolution of the rural
economy, and the development of towns, roads and railways, etc... It became
essential to update the plan (keeping the cadastre up-to-date).
An extra-parliamentary commission in charge of studying the questions raised by the
reform of the cadastre was created in 1891. Its works were completed in 1905
without having received legislative sanction.
Nevertheless, their usefulness cannot be denied as they inspired the works which
finally led in 1955 to the reform of real estate registration and to the new rules
applying to the renewal of the cadastre and speeking it up-to-date.
Finally, the law of 16 April 1930 laid down an exceptionla revision of the evaluation
serving as the basis for the property tax of undeveloped properties. It set out the
prerequisite of a general renewal of the old cadastral plans, chargeable to the State,
and keeping them up-to-date on a permanent basis.
4.
The law of 1930 limited the complete redrawing of the cadastre to the sole
communes where it proved necessary for the basis of assessment of property tax.
A simple updating of the plan was laid down in the other commune when the value of
the framework of the old cadastral plan was acknowledged as sufficient and when the
parcels had not undergone too many modifications since the beginning. The renewal
laid down by this law is today completed. This is still not the case in the departments
of Alsace and Moselle where the renewal of the Napoleonic cadastre has been
undertaken pursuant to a German law of 31 March 1884.
The principle of renewal was reintroduced within the framework of the reform of real
estate registration of 1 January 1956 making it compulsory for properties to be
designated by their cadastral identifiers in any act subject to real estate registration
formalities (this is the case in particular of notarial acts).
There are now close relations between the cadastre and the real estate file held at
the mortgage registries, recounting the legal events of property (in Alsace-Moselle,
the system in force is that of the property book held by a magistrate, inherited from
German law).
Finally, a law of 1974 authorizes a further renewal of the cadastre, called a "revision"
whenever required by the lack of adaptation between the plan and the evolution of
the parcel fabric.
5.
6.
In France, the main characteristic is that the approach is from the fiscal side.
Thus responsibility for the registration of property in the Land Register and the
Cadastre is under the control of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Finance and
Industry (MINEFI) and is discharged through the 354 mortgage offices (land registry
offices) and the 315 cadastral offices.
All contract preparation and the decision on legal acceptance is carried out by the
Notary Public. The Notary public then presents the Deeds to the Land Registry Office
for registration. The Land Registry only receives a summary of the Deed, the original
is given to the applicant. A detailed survey plan is produced by the private surveyor.
This is checked in detail by the cadastral office before acceptance.
Basis of registration
The basis of registration is the Registration of the Deed, except in 3 French
departments (Bas Rhin, Haut Rhin and Moselle, where a German type landbook
system is operational)
Objects of Recording
The Object of Recording is the Deed of transfer, servitude, easement or charge. This
is recorded at the Land Registry Office (also called the Mortgage Office in French).
The boundary information is recorded by the 315 cadastral offices.
Valuation
This is the responsibility of the Ministry of Economic Affairs through the Land Offices.
Property valuation and land taxation are considered to be extremely complicated in
France, and are not discussed in any detail in this presentation.
Mortgage
Mortgages are recorded at the Land Registry Office (Mortgage Office), in the same
manner as any other charge, restriction, servitude or transfer, by the lodging of the
Deed and the cross reference to the parcel in the cadastre. This is under the
authority of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Finance and Industry. However, they
are recorded in a separate Mortgage Register.
Apartment Registration
Transactions involving apartments are registered in the same manner as any other
transaction involving a real estate object. There are some differences in the
procedure, and in the agreements/ documents that are needed to support the
process.
The Deed is registered at the Land Registry (Mortgage Office) and the flloorplan,
building footprint is provided to the cadastral office who approve it before
acceptance.The cadastral office simply archive this information and refer to it by
parcel number. On a yearly basis, cadastral information updates are supplied to the
municipalities, who maintain their own copies of the cadastre data by regulation
Openness of the Records
The records are completely open to the public
Guarantee.
The public notary guarantees the content of the Deed and the Land Registrar is also
responsible for the content on behalf of the administration in law.
7.
TECHNOLOGY
The French system is mostly contained in the Ministry of Finance, which has
its own applications and networks.
Maintenance of cadastral data and land registry data is decentralised to the
land registry and cadastre offices (more than 300 of each)
The land register and cadastral data are linked by property identifier.
100% of the land registry records are available in computerised extract form
24% of all cadastral maps are available in digital vector format. (scheduled for
completion in June 2003)
Municipalities do not yet have access to cadastral and land register data on
line, but it is planned for the near future.
8.
Accurate good quality sales and price information is monitored and published
by a special department (dept of state property of the Ministry of Finance)
From the outset users have had access to the cadastral documents.
Anybody can consult these documents and obtain copies at the cadastre offices.
A copy of the cadastral registers is also consultable in town halls.
Copies and extracts from the register and the plan are given for various purposes :
- people seeking fiscal information (basis of assessment of local taxes ...) or
property information (situation and contents of property ...),
- accomplishment of real estate registration formalities for property transfers.
Microfiches ... leur demande : Microfiche and cadastral register each containing the
same quantity of information. (In the cadastre offices all information is already on
microfiches . Town halls are equipped with this facility on request).
Furthermore, some users have access to "mass" information on microfiches and
magnetic disks. This selective and closely supervised circulation concerns only
regional or local authorities, administrations and organizations under public control.
9.
The cadastre is the instrument of direct local taxation : it localizes, identifies and
describes property and taxpayers. It determine the evaluations serving as the bases
for the tax and various levies corresponding to the services rendered by authorities.
These evaluations are adjusted annually in terms of certain parameters (rents,
inflation) ; they are furthermore periodically revised to take account of the evolution of
the rental market. Finally, the cadastre takes a permanent inventory of changes
affecting the tax bases (new constructions, construction additions, demolitions,
changes in the nature of crops ...).
The cadastral plan, an essential instrument to localize and identify real estate
(parcels, buildings, highways, etc...) is redrawn when the density and economic value
attained by the property fabric so require.
This is why the cadastre is a privileged partner of local authorities for which it also
provides other services :
- providing communes with a copy of the cadastre, comprising register
information (the cadastral register is available on microfiches) and the plans.
This documentation is updated every year.
-
sale of magnetic disk files of property : the cadastral information is keyed into
computers and enables authorities to have a better approach to the use of
land, to create local development strategies and to choose property and
agricultural policies,
The cadastre is also developing a policy based on agreement with authorities which
equip themselves with territorial data banks making use of cadastral information.
10.
The revision of the cadastre consists in redrawing the renewed cadastral plans which
have become unsuitable of hard to use (scale too small, lack of precision). The case
arises mainly in areas which have undergone large-scale urban development.
The new plan is based on land or photogrammetric (i.e. made using aerial
photographs) surveys with acknowledgement of limits in the presence of owners.
Delimitation operation.
SEQUENCE OF WORKS
With these points air photographs can be coupled to obtain a stereoscopic vision of
the land, i.e. with an illusion of depth and relief.
PLOTTING
Aerial photographs are made use of by means of very high precision equipment
called stereoplotters. This equipment enables drawing at the same time as the
observations, a "stereominute" which is a draft of the future plan.
DELIMITATION
The position of property limits are given by owners to the surveyor in charge of the
revision works.
On this occasion, the latter makes measurements to complete and adjust the
stereominutes obtained by plotting.
11.
Between 1986 and 1990, the Tax Office progressively, introduced the Application
MAJIC 2 system (2nd generation of updating of cadastral information) in 315 property
tax centres in the country (CDIF).
Under MAJIC 2 :
12.
13.
STAFFING
The French system uses a government based staff of almost 7500 (this does
not include the cadastral surveyors who do the site surveys)
Additional players
Lawyers. There are only a small number of legal companies involved
Notaries there are 7600 pubic notaries in France employing more than 40,000
people in 4561 practices.
Licensed Private Surveyors, there are an estimated 2200 private surveyors
active in cadastral surveying, (note the public surveyors also carry out this
work)
Valuation for sale is carried out by private valuers and by Notaries
Valuation for tax purposes is carried out by the cadastre valuers
There are an estimated 20,000 real estate agent companies. Most of these
companies also carry out valuations for private sales.
Hydrography,
Buildings,
And, optionally:
Plots marks and fences and their neighbouring status (shared property or
other),
The buildings are represented by their projection on the ground. Buildings are
identified through a character added to the plot identification code. This character,
recently created, refers to the Owners File.
The documentary information:
In addition to the cadastral maps containing the above described graphic information,
the Cadastre is made of a set of documents displaying the information needed for the
fulfilment of its various missions. The Section File and the Cadastral Matrix are kept
along with complementary documents to facilitate their manipulation and
consultation.
The Section File is the legend of the cadastral mapping. It shows, for each plot the
following information:
Address
14.
The local taxation is based on the return (profit) instead of the value of a given
property. The concept is the same as the one still in use in Spain although the
method of of evaluation operates in a very different manner.
To use the return as a criterion supposes that the choice is made of a system which
ensures the fiscal equality without the drawback of a frequent up-dating due to the
variations of the market values in place and in time. The taxation system on realestate does not aim at attaching a weight to its value. It weights on the potential
income the property could produce. Thus, more emphasis is put on the equitable
repartition of the fiscal burden between the owners than on the collection of a tax
proportional to the property's real market value
15.
Juridical effects:
In Napoleon's mind, the Cadastre aimed at increasing the juridical security. It is why
he endowed it with juridical effects. The cadastral documents, however, could not
apply this concept in reality and their efficiency remains limited to the fiscal effects.
The Cadastre juridical value was reinforced in 1955 when the Land Publishing
system was reformed. Starting then, a plot identification in the Real Estate File is
done by its cadastral number. The Cadastre does not have the juridical efficiency of
the Germanic Countries "Land Books". It does not report the juridical changes if they
do not alter the property or its physical characters. The Cadastre, nevertheless, has a
strong probative value. Links between the Cadastre and the Real Estate File has
been reinforced to such an extent that the File could not be kept without an exact and
up-dated cadastre.
The cadastre takes into consideration the changes altering the property when they
entail a change in who is the real-estate tax payer. However, it cannot prove the
transmission of ownership. Other juridical mutations or charges related to the
properties are only taken into account if they are mentioned in the Real Estate File.
The Real Estate File:
From the administrative point of view, it is worthy of a mention that the Real Estate
File, kept by the "Conservation des Hypothques" Bureau in France is under the
aegis of the Ministry of Economy, Finances and Budget, more particularly of the
General Direction of Taxes to which the Cadastre belongs. Thus, both the Cadastre
and the "Conservation des Hypothques" Bureau belong to the same organism and
are integrated into a single structure.
Starting in 1956, a new tool for a sound operation of the French Land Publishing
system was introduced: the Real Estate File. It facilitated handling of the
documentation and improved the Institution's general operationality. It is through this
File that a perfect correspondence is obtained with the cadastral data.
The Real Estate File is contrived as an instrument to synthesise the information on
mortgages. Created for an easier exploitation of the data regarding the Land
Publishing it lacks any juridical value in itself. The mortgage protection is obtained
through the completion of formalities and not through the mentions written in this file.
Its shortcomings in terms of juridical efficiency do not diminish its importance in other
fields. It is considered in France as the creation principle of a Land Book akin to the
ones existing in the Countries of German traditions.
16.
COMPUTERIZATION
Public Finance
Taxpayer
Information
Third
Real Estate
Files
Town Council
Cadastre
Income property
tax list / Tax
Office Tax
Departments
("DSF")
Tax
Offices
Customs
Building Reserve
Land Registration
Offices
Right of
lease
Real Estate
Assessment
Offices
Computerised Wine
Not Build
Cadastre
Offices
Reference cadastral
documentation
Base " CATALOGUE "
District Authorities
Agricultural
Social
Mutual
Real
Estate
Tax
Changes
about BP