10 Research Progress of Road Intersection Design Analysis
10 Research Progress of Road Intersection Design Analysis
2Kim Chaek University of Technology, School of Mechanical Science and Technology, Pyongyang, 950003,
DPR of Korea
ABSTRACT
Article Info Intersection is one of the most important components of urban roads, and
Volume 7 Issue 6 traffic flow is the node that realizes route change. When the vehicle passes
Page Number: 245-256 through the intersection due to the need for traffic flow route conversion, the
Publication Issue : driver can slow down, change lanes, park, steer. A series of tasks such as
November-December-2020 acceleration, etc., must be completed, and this process must be completed at
the intersection and its neighboring area. Therefore, a number of traffic
conflict points are formed at the intersection and its adjacent area, and the
intersection between traffic flows in different directions, Traffic conflicts such
as merger and direction change occur. Traffic characteristics of intersections
are more complex than road sections, and road traffic bottlenecks and traffic
accidents are frequent. Good design of intersections ensures safe and efficient
operation of the entire road network. Based on the analysis of the serious
causes of urban traffic problems, the importance of intersections in improving
road traffic capacity, traffic jams and accidents is analyzed. The basic content,
types, forms, advantages and disadvantages of intersections are analyzed in
Article History detail. Carry out a specific analysis of the crossover design method classified by
Accepted : 11 Dec 2020 the crossover point, and demonstrate the existing and unsolved problems.
Published : 28 Dec 2020 Keywords : Road Intersection, Intersection Design, Analysis
Copyright : © the author(s), publisher and licensee Technoscience Academy. This is an open-access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-
commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited
245
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
Intersections are the throat of the city's road network 2.2 General understanding of intersection
and are a frequent occurrence of traffic jams and
accidents. For example, the travel time of motor An intersection is the intersection of two or more
vehicles in large cities in Japan in the city center roads. It is the necessary place for vehicles and
occurs approximately at intersections, and more than pedestrians to gather, turn and evacuate. According to
half of traffic accidents occur at level intersections the number of intersecting roads, it can be divided
and surrounding US traffic accidents. The traffic into three forks, four forks and multiple forks.
problems at intersections in china are more serious. According to the way of crossing, there are plane
First of all, many cities in china have low road crossing and grade crossing. In order to ensure traffic
network density, excessively large distance between safety and smoothness, traffic control facilities such as
arterial roads, shortage of branch roads, and chaotic signal lights and other traffic management facilities
functions. They are low-level traffic systems that are are often installed at intersections. Correctly
difficult to meet the needs of modern automobile designing road intersections and rationally organizing
traffic. Secondly, many cities Due to the limited land and managing intersection traffic are indispensable
area and small area of intersections, and there are a for improving traffic capacity and ensuring traffic
large number of non-motorized vehicles and safety.
pedestrians, motor vehicles, non-motorized vehicles,
and pedestrians are often intertwined to form a mixed 2.3 Classification of intersections
traffic flow, which seriously affects the traffic
capacity of the intersection. Therefore, rational design Intersections are divided into plane intersections and
of urban intersections, reasonable resolution of grade intersections according to whether the roads
various existing problems, and resolution of traffic intersect in the same plane. The main forms of grade
congestion and safety issues are important links in separation and plan intersections and their
solving urban traffic congestion problems. comparative analysis are introduced below.
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
246
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
247
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
2.4 Comparative analysis of grade separation and ✓ Carry out traffic organization and rationally
plane intersections arrange various traffic facilities;
✓ Check the sight distance of traffic at intersections
Grade separation uses space to separate the traffic to ensure safe visibility conditions;
flow, although it can avoid the formation of conflict ✓ Intersection elevation design, arrangement of
points in the traffic flow at the intersection, reduce rainwater outlets and drainage pipes.
delays, ensure traffic safety, improve traffic capacity
and transportation efficiency, and solve the problems
3.1.2 Design classification of road intersections
caused by level crossing, but it cannot completely
3.1.2.1 Intersection channelization design
replace the plane intersections. First of all, the
overpass project is huge, the construction cost is high,
① Basic principles of intersection channelization
the area is large, and the construction period is long.
design
Secondly, due to the nature of the intersecting roads,
land occupation, project investment and other
Separation principle: The channelization design
restrictions, it is impossible to construct all the
should minimize the interference between different
interchanges, and sometimes it is necessary to build
traffic flows, and guide traffic participants to follow
some of the interchanges. Type interchanges. This
the traffic method of lane separation and separation of
type of interchange retains part of the plane
mancar through traffic signs and markings, so as to
interchanges, and the problem of plane intersections
promote each lane.
still exists. Building an intersection in the city will
also divide the city, affect the sunshine conditions of
The principle of diversion: clarify the driving
the neighborhood, interfere with electric waves,
trajectory of different traffic flows, and divert the
obstruct the line of sight, destroy the landscape, and
traffic flow through measures such as one-way traffic,
bring pedestrians Inconvenience and other issues.
changing traffic, dedicated lanes, and prohibiting left
Therefore, level intersections are still the main form
turns.
of intersections in my country.
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
248
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
✓ Pay attention to the landscape of intersections, simple intersection design where roads are orthogonal
set up the greening of the intersections or close to orthogonal.
reasonably, and pay equal attention to functions
and landscapes ✓ Design contour method:
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
249
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
✓ The number of traffic signal phases should be ① Pedestrian traffic organization. The main task of
reduced as much as possible to increase the pedestrian traffic organization is to organize
effective transit time within the cycle. pedestrians to walk on the sidewalk and cross the
✓ Signal cycle duration Under the premise of street safely within the crosswalk line to separate
meeting the minimum cycle (the time for the people and vehicles with minimal interference.
traffic flow to safely pass through the ② Non-motorized vehicle traffic organization: at
intersection), the non-motor vehicle peak period intersections, non-motorized vehicle lanes are
should be as small as possible. usually arranged between motorized vehicle
✓ The signal timing design should be coordinated lanes and sidewalks; in intersections, non-
with the space design. motorized vehicles run on the right side
✓ The signal phase should be flexibly combined according to traffic rules at random under normal
according to the actual flow and characteristics of traffic flow, and there is no separation facility ;
the traffic flow When the traffic volume is large, separation belts
✓ Phase sequence design should follow the (or piers) can be used to separate motor vehicles
principle of minimizing lost time under the and non-motor vehicles to reduce mutual
premise of ensuring safety. interference; when the traffic volume is large and
the interference between aircraft and non-motor
3.1.2.4 Traffic organization design
vehicles is serious, three-dimensional non-motor
vehicles can be considered Train traffic
✓ Vehicle traffic organization method
organization and consider it together with
pedestrian bridges or underpasses.
① Set up dedicated lanes:
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
250
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
collision data is compared [1]. It was in the four passing through the intersection [11]. In offset
intersection points of the delivery priority non- intersection, a cellular automaton rule based on
limited signal at the intersection of t analyzing the analysis of traffic collision process is proposed, and
behavior of the receiving gap and the two-wheeled the relationship between road traffic flow and average
vehicle model [2]. Based on the analysis of the factors speed is studied [12]. Literature [13] introduced that
affecting the severity of the truck-related crash based on the sequencing strategy and pre-signal, the
accident at the t intersection, four partial pro problem of low intersection efficiency can be solved
portional odds models including fxed and unfixed at the left and right misaligned intersections through
parameters were created [3]. Various types of channelization and signal phasing, so that the
approach behavior were generated at the t- separation distance is used as the signal to reduce the
intersection and analyzed according to cooperation time loss in the signal cycle.
readiness, priority driving preference, and safety of
the situation through experiments [4]. Solutions and ③ Cross-road intersection design
applied approaches to eliminate the risk of blocking
the movement of road vehicles found at intersections Age, physical ability, and spatial composition of the
are presented in the form of an animated uml-based road were considered as major components of road
model [5]. The influence of both the driver's intended safety, and the quality and risk of intersection were
operation and gap duration on the gap acceptance analyzed in detail [14].The effectiveness of the newly
behavior at the stop control t-intersection using a designed crosswalk sign was evaluated in
driving simulator was specifically analyzed [6]. consideration of the vehicle-pedestrian interaction
Literature [7] proposed a cellular automaton model to [15]. In terms of efficiency and safety, a delay model
describe the traffic characteristics of unsignaled T- was created and the crossing pattern was analyzed in
shaped intersections on crosswalks, and studied the consideration of traffic and diagonal pedestrian
characteristics of vehicle flow of various parameters. movement [16]. Considering the influence of the
Various factors are optimized and analyzed for the upstream signal intersection, the operational
minimum traffic delay at a three-phase T-shaped performance analysis of the reverse left turn lane
intersection [8]. (CLL) design was conducted [17]. In order to solve the
problem of signal timing optimization at irregular
② X–shaped, Y -shaped and Offset intersection four-step intersections, a new design method based on
design the calculation of lane design capacity based on the
VISSIM program is proposed [18]. At signal
Using the Vissim and Surrogate Safe ty Assessment intersections, most factors such as pedestrian
models, the data extracted through the video graphic characteristics (age, movement restrictions, etc.),
survey were analyzed in detail for the stability of the traffic conditions and signal delays are
design at the T intersection and the x intersection comprehensively considered and modeled [19].
using the pedestrian vehicle collision analysis (PVCA)
method [9]. Literature [10] focuses on the dilemma of ④ Roundabout intersection design
passing at Y-intersections, and uses Intelligent Traffic
Point System (ITPS) to design and analyze the Environmental sustainability was analyzed by
simulation system of Y-intersections. Under the researching and comparing various construction
influence of pedestrians, the new traffic rules at y techniques for the road grade, embankment and
intersections proposed a signal distribution formula pavement at the roundabout Intersection [20].
and provided new ideas for the percentage of time Significant differences in emissions due to the type of
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
251
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
crossover control were analyzed through experiments In summary, the research on the design of
at roundabout intersections using statistical methods intersections in terms of vehicle passing capacity and
[21]. A vehicle noise emission model considering the pedestrian safety is basically completed. The research
acceleration effect was created using an experimental object is also based on a large area and few pedestrians,
method, and accordingly, traffic noise near the for research analysis and simulation. Without
roundabout and signal intersection was studied [22]. comprehensively considering the parameters in the
Correlation with individual variables such as traffic design, the hypothesis is basically established. The
mode and perception of carousel safety were VISSIM program is used for simulation, and the
evaluated, and processed and analyzed using the research content and analysis are very simple. The
Ordinal regression method and the Multiple research object is also mainly automobiles, without
Correspondence Analysis [23]. Literature [24] comprehensive investigation of various factors related
introduced four relatively new alternative types of to intersection design such as pedestrians and bicycles.
roundabouts-"turbo", "lower", "target" and "four cross-
border" roundabouts and their design, capacity and 1) 3.2.2 Interchange intersection design
traffic volume. Comparison-safe point. By applying The interchange area is a very critical area to improve
the gap acceptance theory widely used in the capacity vehicle and pedestrian capacity in a limited space.
analysis of roundabouts, we analyzed how the Research on the design of the interchange area is in-
frequency of priority violations varies according to depth.
traffic composition and volume, and created a model
to examine it in detail [25]. ① Overpass and underpass grade separation
From the perspective of topology and beautification,
⑤ Multiple intersection design the bridge and the upper-span intersection are studied,
and the characteristics of the reinforced soil are
A new multi-intersection (MI-phase) was proposed analyzed to play a functional potential in the field of
and a scalable optimization frame was designed for building structures [30]. Put forward the management
actual traffic control optimization called the and traffic adjustment methods to obtain the best
"Lagrangian decomposition using subproblem solution, and use the vissim program to evaluate the
approximation" approach [26]. In order to capture the adaptability of the intersection, and compare and
inner correlation between sequential traffic flow data, analyze the analysis results and the modeling results
an algorithm was created using a new learning [31].
method that includes a relevance vector machine for
traffic flow prediction [27]. A cooperative ② Separate grade crossing and interchange
autonomous transport organization design method for intersection
CAVs in a multi-intersection road network was
proposed [28]. Based on queuing theory and standard Combining the changeable design ideas and starting
technology, a new multi-way intersection general from the perspective of survey and design, several
traffic model was developed using M/M/1 single issues that should be paid attention to when
server [28]. Real-time traffic data from multiple optimizing the design plan are put forward to choose
intersections are used to analyze adaptive traffic the best plan and give full play to its functions[32]. It
control issues to ease congestion in terms of was redesigned as Diverging Diamond Interchange
maximum throughput traffic flow and minimize (DDI) by increasing the demand for turning to the left,
delays while keeping all network traffic lights fair thus conducting an in-depth analysis of different
[29]. factors that affect the sustainability performance
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
252
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
(operational and safety) of conventional Acts such as forcibly crossing the street, ignoring
exchanges[33]. Literature [69] proposed a new Offset signals, and violating traffic laws have increased the
Diamond Interchange (OD1) as an alternative design, burden on traffic operation at intersections.
which showed the potential to alleviate the
limitations of service exchange failures related to 4.2 Ways to improve intersection
transportation operations [34].
① Intersection engineering renovation
In summary, the design of interchanges is dominated A line type of the upstream and downstream sections
by the geometric designof interchanges, but from the of the intersection, the geometric line shape of the
perspective of traffic flow design, ramp and flow line intersection itself, and the central separation belt shall
connection is the focus of current optimization design, be reconstructed to a certain extent to compensate for
and the matching of upstream and downstream traffi the inherent shortcomings of the intersection.
c capacity of intersections is also increasingly being af
fected by people’s concern. ② Channelized traffic
Channelization means that in order to reduce and
IV. DISCUSSION improve the staggered number and nature of traffic
flow at intersections and intersections, appropriate
4.1 Basic problems at intersections settings are set at locations that are not used by
normal traffic flow. The driving position of vehicles is
① Congenital lack of structure design specified, and vehicles are induced to drive in the
In many urban road networks, due to inadequate normal direction to provide pedestrians with
traffic forecasts, unfamiliar environment, and lack of avoidance. At the parking lot, measures aimed at
understanding of the actual situation during the rectifying the traffic flow. It includes motor vehicle
construction period of the road, the planning, channelization and non-motor vehicle channelization,
geometry, and hardware facilities of the intersection and non-motor vehicle channelization is divided into
are unreasonable during the design. The traffic bicycle channelization and pedestrian traffic
congestion and chaotic vehicle operation in the channelization. The specific measures adopted often
intersection increase the risk of traffic accidents. include road markings and markings, physical traffic
islands, turn left twice to cross the street, pedestrian
② Unreasonable management control bridges and underpasses.
Inadequate traffic control at intersections is also one
of the reasons for the prominent traffic problems at ③ Management measures
intersections. Due to improper or even lack of Intersection management uses the actual situation of
channelization measures, poor phase setting, each intersection to manage the intersection problem
unreasonable signal cycle design, and improper by formulating reasonable rules.
manual traffic management, the traffic at
intersections will be confused. 4.3 Development Outlook
③ People lack awareness of traffic Based on the analysis and research on the domestic
Among all the factors affecting traffic, the human and foreign intersection design, the multi-purpose
factor is the most unstable factor. Because different optimization theory should be applied to the
individuals react differently to different traffic intersection design to optimize the design of the
conditions, they have different impacts on traffic. intersection with high traffic safety and traffic
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
253
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
efficiency, low accident rate, fast passage time, and Analysis and Prevention, 2020, 144:1-12.
high economic benefits. Here should [4]. Jonas Imbsweiler, Maureen Ruesch. Cooperation
comprehensively evaluate and consider various behaviour of road users in t-intersections during
factors of traffic and intersection design, scientifically deadlock situations, Transportation Research Part
determine the evaluation table and design coefficients, F, 2018, 58:665-677.
and optimize the design of various intersections. [5]. Roman Michalik, Ales Janota. Co-operation of the
control logic of the T-shape road intersection and
the near railway level crossing, Transportation
V. CONCLUSION
Research Procedia, 2019, 40:1465-1472
[6]. Vanessa Beanland, Michael G. Lenne. Gap
An intersection is the intersection of two or more
acceptance at stop-controlled T-intersections in
roads. It is the necessary place for vehicles and
asimulated rural environment, Transportation
pedestrians to gather, turn and evacuate. Correctly
Research Part F, 2013, 20:80-89.
designing road intersections and rationally organizing
[7]. H. Echab, H. Ez-Zahraouy. Dynamic
and managing intersection traffic are necessary to characteristics of traffic flow with consideration
improve traffic capacity and ensure traffic safety. of crossing pedestrians' behavior at a
Therefore, the thesis briefly explained the concepts, nonsignalized T-shaped intersection,International
classifications, advantages, and defects of the various Journal of Modern Physics C, 2017, 28(11):
intersections that currently exist, and focused on the 1750134.
recent design methods of intersections according to [8]. Hong-Ze Zhang. Analytical investigation on the
classification. A detailed analysis was conducted on minimum traffic delay at a three-phase signalized
the design methods of various intersections, and the T-type intersection, Modern Physics Letters B,
existing problems and problems to be solved in the 2017, 31(6):1750063.
future were analyzed. In addition, improvement [9]. Devika Santhosh, B.K. Bindhu. Evaluation of
methods of intersections and the development of pedestrian safety in unsignalized T and X–
future intersections were conducted through detailed Intersections through comparison of the
analysis of various intersections. Briefly mentioned frequency and severity of pedestrian conflicts,
the prospects. Case Studies on Transport Policy, 2020, 8:1352-
1359.
VI. REFERENCES [10]. Yongjie Wang, The impact of intelligent
transportation points system based on Elo rating
[1]. Mehmet Baran Ulak, Eren Erman Ozguven. on emergence of cooperation at Y intersection.
Assessment of traffic performance measures and Applied Mathematics and Computation, 2020,
safety based on driver age and experience: A 370:124923.
microsimulation based analysis for an [11]. Wei Feng, Wenwu Guo. The Conception of
unsignalized T-intersection, International Journal Improving Signal in Y-Intersection under
of Traffic and Transportation Engineering Influence of Pedestrian. Applied Mechanics and
(ENGLISH EDITION), 2019, 6(5):455-469. Materials, 2013, 438-439: 1932-1934.
[2]. Gopal R Patil, Jayant P.Sangole. Behavior of two- [12]. LIU Xiaoming, ZHENG Shuhui. Traffic Flow
wheelers at limited priority uncontrolled T- Model for taggered Intersection without Signal
intersections, IATSS Research, 2016, 40:7-18. Lamp, J Transpn Sys Eng & IT, 2012, 12(5): 82-89.
[3]. Li Song, Wei Fan (David). Combined latent class [13]. Zhengyi Cai, Manchu Xiong. Traffic design and
and partial proportional odds model approach to signal timing of staggered intersections based on a
exploring the heterogeneities in truck-involved sorting strategy, Advances in Mechanical
severities at cross and T-intersection, Accident Engineering, 2016, 8(4):1-9.
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
254
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
[14]. Sebastien Lord, Marie-Soleil Cloutier. Crossing [24]. Tomaž Tollazzi, Raffaele Mauro. Comparative
road intersections in old age-With or without Analysis of Four New Alternative Types of
risks? Perceptions of risk and crossing behaviours Roundabouts: "Turbo", "Flower", "Target" and
among the elderly, Transportation Research Part "Four-Flyover" Roundabout, Periodica
F, 2018, 55:282-296. Polytechnica Civil Engineering, 2016, 60(1): 51-
[15]. Yang Bian, Kun Liang, Xiaohua Zhao. Evaluating 60.
the effectiveness of new-designed crosswalk [25]. Arun Baby Zacharia, Harikrishna Madhavan.
markings at intersections in China considering Influence of Priority Violations on Entry Capacity
vehicle-pedestrian interaction, Accident Analysis at Roundabouts, J. Transp. Eng., Part A: Systems,
and Prevention, 2020, 139:1-12. 2020, 146(12): 04020136.
[16]. Liying Tang, Yugang Liu. Pedestrian crossing [26]. Peirong Wang, Pengfei Li. A mixed integer
design and analysis for symmetric intersections: programming formulation and scalable solution
Efficiency and safety, Transportation Research algorithms for traffic control coordination across
Part A, 2020, 142:187-206. multiple intersections based on vehicle space-time
[17]. Jiaming Wu, Pan Liu. Stationary condition based trajectories, Transportation Research Part B, 2020,
performance analysis of the contraflow left-turn 134:266-304.
lane design considering the influence of the [27]. Zhangguo Shen, Wanliang Wang. A novel
upstream intersection, Transportation Research learning method for multi-intersections aware
Part C, 2021, 122:1-20. traffic flow, Neurocomputing, 2020, 398:477-484.
[18]. Lu Wang, Liying Wei, Yu Zhou. Optimization [28]. Yunpeng Wang, Pinlong Cai. Cooperative
Model of the Cross Intersection Signal Timing autonomous traffic organization method for
Based on the Simulation. Applied Mechanics and connected automated vehicles in multi-
Materials, 2015, 713-715: 1244-1247 intersection road networks, Transportation
[19]. Nicolae Duduta, Qianqian Zhang. Impact of Research Part C, 2020, 111:458-476.
Intersection Design on Pedestrians’ Choice to [29]. Azura Che Soh, Marzuki Khalid. Modeling of a
Cross on Red, Transportation Research Record, multilane-multiple intersection based on queue
2464(1):93-99. theory and standard approach techniques,
[20]. Raffaele Mauro, Marco Guerrieri. Comparative Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory, 2009,
life-cycle assessment of conventional (double 17: 1081-1105.
lane) and non-conventional (turbo and flower) [30]. Karima Benhamza , Hamid Seridi. Adaptive
roundabout intersection, Transportation Research traffic signal control in multiple intersections
Part D, 2016, 48:96-111. network, Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems,
[21]. Claudio Meneguzzer, Massimiliano Gastaldi. 2015, 28: 2557-2567.
Comparison of exhaust emissions at intersections [31]. Gholamreza Pour Ebrahim1, Omid Pourebrahim.
under traffic signal versus roundabout control Architectural Approach to Application of
using an instrumented vehicle, Transportation Reinforced Soil in the Structure of Bridges and
Research Procedia, 2017, 25C:1597-1612. Urban Overpasses, International Journal of
[22]. Feng Li, Yushan Lin. Dynamic simulation and Science, Technology and Society, 2015, 3(2-1):
characteristics analysis of traffic noise at 70-74.
roundabout and signalized intersections, Applied [32]. J Arliansyah, R T Bawono. Study on Performance
Acoustics, 2017, 121:147-24. of Intersection Around The Underpass Using
[23]. Salvatore Leonardi, Natalia Distefano, Giulia Micro Simulation Program, Earth and
Pulvirenti. Italians public opinion on road Environmental Science, 2018, 124: 012014.
roundabouts: A web based survey, Transportation [33]. Wenhua Wang, Wending Zhao. A Study on the
Research Procedia, 2020, 45:293-300. Optimization Design of Jiang Yan Highway
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
255
Hwan NamGung et al Int J Sci Res Sci Eng Technol November-December--2020; 7 (6) : 245-256
International Journal of Scientific Research in Science, Engineering and Technology | www.ijsrset.com | Vol 7 | Issue 6
256