Introduction To Lab Grown Meat
Introduction To Lab Grown Meat
THE
DEMONIZATION
OF FAUX MEAT
DEMONIZATION
NOUN: THE PORTRAYAL OF SOMETHING AS WICKED AND
THREATENING.
GROUP E UGTERM3EF
WELCOME TO THE
OF
LAB
KRUPAL, TIA, KRITIKA, PRANAV, PRIYANSHI
HUMANITY
The hashtag the team has worked with is #FauxMeat.
VIDEO LINK
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
01. HOW AND WHY DID YOUR GROUP 03. WHAT WAS THE INTERVIEW
CHOOSE THIS TOPIC? PROCESS LIKE?
At Tapri, Flame campus, we debated Jain rules and the desire for We divided the interviews in 3 categories per page observations
chicken. Perspectives on vegetarianism and non-vegetarianism were each. We assessed the attitudes of
shared. We recognized India's potential to make its meat-eating 1)Our parents 2) A teenager 3) A different socio-economic palette
system more sustainable due to its expertise in breeding and medical resident.
technology. This idea arose from the discussion, emphasizing the need The interviewing process as a whole was very unpredictable and
for a sustainable approach to food. humbling for all of us, oftentimes we were met with the responses
we expected to find but more often than not we were met with
answers that we were just not aware of, some of these became the
base for our own research.
02. HOW DID YOU FIND YOUR 04. HOW DID YOU DIVIDE WORK?
INFORMATION? We all worked with our strengths. Pranav and Kritika did their best
A LOT OF RESEARCH!! for such an academic topic we referred to at research and scripting the shoot. Priyanshi and Tia ideated, and
papers, science journals, surveys, interviews and noted the immediate created supporting materials like base PPTs and arguments while
tendancies of those around us on this topic to assess the behavioural Krupal arranged for the video shooting and opposition, (also kept
and cognitive patterns in the population. us on time.)
OVERVIEW
SOLUTIONS AND
1 INTRODUCTION 6
CONCLUSIONS
3 PRESENTATION VIDEO YOU WILL GET THROUGH THIS PPT SMOOTH LIKE :
4 TOPIC EXPLANATION
DATA COLLECTION,
5
ANALYSIS AND
INTERPRETATION
WHAT IS
LAB GROWN MEAT?
Lab-grown meat (cultured meat) or cell-based meat, is
produced by in vitro cultivation of animal cell. It is upon
the extraction of stem cells from the stock and then
culturing it ina nutrient media until it grows as a
compund.
MEAT
maturation process where they develop
into muscle tissues, replicating the natural
growth of meat moulded into patties,
chicken nuggets etc.
COMPARISON OF LAB GROWN MEAT WITH
TRADITIONAL MEAT
01 02 03
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT NUTRITIONAL COMPOSITION CONSUMER ACCEPTANCE
1. Land Use Efficiency: In terms of nutritional value, lab-grown meat
has the potential to be tailored to meet specific
Livestock farming : Traditional Meat: 77% One key factor to consider is the taste and
dietary needs, such as reducing saturated fats or
of global agricultural land texture of lab-grown meat. Consumers are
increasing omega-3 fatty acids. However, since
Lab-Grown Meat: Could potentially this technology is still in its early stages, more often hesitant to try new food products if they
require 99% less land. research is needed to fully understand the believe they will not enjoy the taste or if the
2. Water Savings: nutritional profile of lab-grown meat compared texture is significantly different from what
Traditional Meat: Beef production to conventional meat.
they are accustomed to.
requires about 15,000 liters of water per
When it comes to composition, lab-grown meat
kg Secondly, it is the perceived health benefits of
typically contains fewer contaminants and
Lab-Grown Meat: suggested 90% less lab-grown meat. Many consumers are
antibiotics than conventionally produced meat,
water. which can be beneficial for human health. increasingly concerned about the use of
3. Greenhouse Gas Intensity: antibiotics and hormones in traditional meat
Traditional Meat: Produces around 26 As for the health implications, some experts production, leading them to seek healthier
kilograms of CO2 per kg believe that consuming lab-grown meat could
alternatives. Lab-grown meat has the
Lab-Grown Meat: potential to emit up to have positive effects on human health, such as
potential to be produced without these
reducing the risk of certain diseases associated
96% fewer greenhouse gases per unit of additives, offering consumers a cleaner and
with conventional meat consumption. However,
meat produced. more sustainable protein source.
long-term studies are necessary to determine
the overall impact on health.
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS
WHAT IS THE CAUSE IT WHAT ARE EXAMPLES OF MOVEMENTS WHY DOES IT MATTER?
HIGHLIGHTS? AROUND IT? As a means of solving urgent global
problems, the success of artificial meat
The cause that this presentation Multiple movements around artfiicial meat
must be ensured. There are ethical issues
highlights is: are -
about animal suffering, the depletion of
1) The concept of faux meat and how it is
natural resources, and environmental
more sustainable for the environment by 1. Memphis Meat’s $161 million Series B
degradation caused by conventional meat
a margin! fundraising, by far the largest funding round
production..In addition to its moral and
2)How media and conservatives are ever completed by a cultured meat
ecological advantages, synthetic meat
demonizing it on multiple fronts which company
might improve food safety, boost public
they can otherwise overcome through
health with its improved dietary profiles,
more R&D but cant currently because of 2. The Good Food Institute (GFI) and New
and stimulate new business ventures in the
the resistant propaganda and biases Harvest advocate for the development and
rapidly expanding alternative protein
circulated. acceptance of alternative protein sources,
market. Therefore, in order to shape a food
including artificial meat. They work to
system that is more sustainable, ethical, and
counter misinformation and promote the
reliable for future generations, it is
benefits of lab-grown meat for sustainability,
necessary to promote and invest in research
animal welfare, and human health.
and development of artificial meat.
HOW THE DIARY AND MEAT INDUSTRY
IS DEMONIZING LAB-GROWN MEAT
The meat industry has long since been employing dirty and
aggressive tactics to deter sustainable scientific advancements,
research and reform. This has displayed itself in lobbying politiicians
and the public, such as when the Guardian reported a massive
lobbying campaign aimed at the FAO to silence climate scientists
and policy makers sometimes going as far as to threaten scientists
directly.
In both the U.S. and EU, meat and dairy lobbies continue to outspend
most of their rivals: animal rights groups, climate groups and
scientists. In fact, meat lobby groups have spent about 200 million
to influence legislation in the U.S. alone. We can see their influence in
recent Farm Bills, court cases and even the recent EATS Act, where
they collaborate with Republican co-sponsors on messaging.
INTERVIEW
QUESTIONS
1.Are you a vegetarian/non-vegetarian/vegan/eggetarian?
2.What do you think is needed to cultivate the meat that you eat (or don’t)?
3.What is that you know about Lab-grown meat and what is your immediate reaction
to it?
4.What do you think could be the potential environmental benefits associated with
lab-grown meat?
5.From what you've seen or heard, how do people in the traditional meat industry feel
about lab-grown meat?
7.Would you consider trying it? your reason for the same.
KRITIKA’S INTERVIEW
NON-VEGETARIAN NON-VEGETARIAN NON-VEGETARIAN
Vegan
3.7% Heard of it
14.8
Vegetarian
33.3%
Non-Vegetarian No
55.6% 25.9 Yes
59.3
Eggetarian
7.4%
SURVEY RESULTS
AFTER READING THE DESCRIPTION DO SHOULD FAUX MEAT REPLACE WHAT WOULD YOU
YOU BELIEVE THAT FAUX MEAT CAN TRADITIONAL MEAT IN YOUR OPINION?
HELP BETTER THE ENVIRONMENT?
PREFER MORE?
Anything
14.8%
Plant-based Mea
No 40.7%
Yes 40.7%
Maybe 44.4%
48.1%
Yes
59.3%
Neither of them
40.7%
No Lab grown Meat
7.4% 3.7%
SURVEY IF YES WHY? AND IF NOT THEN WHY ?
LET’S HAVE A LOOK AT WHAT PEOPLE HAVE TO SAY ABOUT
Increase public awareness and understanding of Advocate for policies that promote the
the benefits of artificial meat alternatives, including development and adoption of artificial meat
their potential to reduce environmental impact, alternatives, such as research funding, tax
improve animal welfare, and enhance food security. incentives, and regulatory frameworks that
Education campaigns can help counteract facilitate innovation and market entry. This
misinformation spread by the dairy and meat can help level the playing field and create a
industries. more favorable environment for alternative
protein producers.
Reach out, collaborate and learn about movements that revolve around these labels, This is
where one can build contact, create initiatives and formulate plans of actions.
LISTEN!
1. Environmental sustainability: Compared to conventional meat production , lab-grown meat has great environmental benefits. Studies show that it can reduce
greenhouse gas emissions by up to 92% and land use is up to 95% (FairPlanet, 2023). This is very beneficial for a country like India with limited land resources and growing
population with environmental concerns. This also saves water and other unused resources that would be required for support.
2. Ethical Considerations: Conventional meat production often raises ethical concerns about animal welfare. Lab-cultured meat eliminates the need for animal slaughter,
potentially offering a more humane solution. This aligns with India's rich cultural values and growing vegetarian population who may still crave the taste and texture of meat
without ethical dilemmas.
3. Food Security and Growing Demand: India is ready to witness a rush in meat demand in the coming decades. Lab-cultured meat offers a scalable, resource-efficient
alternative to meet this demand without putting further pressure on land and water resources. This can contribute to India's food security, ensuring access to protein for a
growing population.
4. Economic Opportunities: Lab-cultured meat could produce new economic opportunities for India. This upcoming industry has the potential to attract investments, create
skilled jobs, and position India as a leader in this innovative food technology.
BUT ALSO...
1. Regulatory Hurdles and Cost: Lab-cultured meat is still in its early stages, and regulatory frameworks governing its production and
sale are yet to be established in India. Additionally, the production process currently requires specialized equipment and expertise,
making it expensive. This high cost could limit its accessibility for the average consumer.
2. Consumer Acceptance and Social Impact: Cultural and religious sensitivities, combined with a lack of public awareness, demonizing
lab-grown meat could hinder consumer acceptance of lab-cultured meat in India. Eg- Hindu wouldn’t prefer cows’ cells cultured meat
and Islam wouldn’t prefer meat cultured from pigs’ cells. The impact on traditional livestock farmers and livelihoods also needs
consideration to ensure a just and inclusive transition in terms of unemployment and other economical concerns (India being 2nd
largest exporter of meat)
3. Technological Challenges and Long-Term Impact: While the technology shows promise, further research is needed to optimize
scalability, affordability, and product quality. Long-term health and environmental impacts also necessitate thorough scientific
evaluation before large-scale adoption of cultured meat.
4. Ethical Concerns Remain: Some argue that even lab-cultured meat raises ethical questions, as it still involves extracting and
manipulating animal cells. Additionally, concerns about corporate control and ethical dilemmas surrounding intellectual property
rights need to be addressed. Also unless a constructive alternate for Fetal Bovine Serum (the media of culture) is found, this movement
can never truly be, cruelty free. Many companies are underway.
CONCLUSION AND KEY FINDINGS
In conclusion, artificial meat provides
benefits over traditional meat in nearly This case study shows that people are open
every aspect involved, especially if allowed to trying out artificial meat, especially
to develop further. Thus the meat and dairy people who are well educated as shown by
industry does everything In its power to the interviews of people from varying
stop scientists from developing it further, economic, cultural, and regional
either by influencing politicians to prevent backgrounds. In addition, University
sustainable policies coming in power, or by students seemed highly open to trying out
influencing the public covertly. But things artificial meat, with a sizable majority
wont go according to their way if the public outright supporting it.
take a stand for what’s right and fight for a
sustainable future.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
The Now: What is Lab-Grown Meat? Perceived naturalness and evoked disgust influence acceptance of cultured meat
By GCF Global Year: 2019 Container: GCFGlobal.org URL: By Michael Siegrist, Bernadette Sütterlin, Christina Hartmann Year: 2018 Container: Meat Science Volume: 139
Page: 213-219 DOI: 10.1016/j.meatsci.2018.02.007
https://edu.gcfglobal.org/en/thenow/what-is-labgrown-meat/1/
The Scaling-Up of Lab-Grown Meat Production: A Critical Analysis of Nutritional Profiling, Challenges, and Ethical
Environmental Impacts of Cultured Meat Production Implications.
By Hanna L. Tuomisto, M. Joost Teixeira de Mattos Year: 2011 Container: Environmental Science & By Siyal Khan, Maryam Zulfiqar, Sheza Imtiaz Year: 2023 Container: PAKISTAN JOURNAL OF BIOCHEMISTRY AND
Technology Volume: 45 Issue: 14 Page: 6117-6123 DOI: 10.1021/es200130u URL: MOLECULAR BIOLOGY Volume: 56 Issue: 2 URL: http://pjbmb.com/index.php/pjbmb/article/view/96
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es200130u
'Frankenfood': Would you eat a burger grown in the lab?
By By Scott Tilley Container: Florida Today URL: https://www.floridatoday.com/story/news/2018/10/11/frankenfood-
Cultured meat and cowless milk: on making markets for animal-free food would-you-eat-burger-grown-lab/1568508002/
By Michael J. Mouat, Russell Prince Year: 2018 Container: Journal of Cultural Economy Volume: 11
Issue: 4 Page: 315-329 DOI: 10.1080/17530350.2018.1452277 Consumer preferences for farm-raised meat, lab-grown meat, and plant-based meat alternatives: Does
information or brand matter?
By Ellen J. Van Loo, Vincenzina Caputo, Jayson L. Lusk Year: 2020 Container: Food Policy Volume: 95 Issue: 1 Page:
Could consumption of insects, cultured meat or imitation meat reduce global agricultural land 101931 DOI: 10.1016/j.foodpol.2020.101931
use?
By Peter Alexander, Calum Brown, Almut Arneth, Clare Dias, John Finnigan, Dominic Moran, Meat grown from animal cells? Here's what it is and how it's made
Mark D.A. Rounsevell Year: 2017 Container: Global Food Security Volume: 15 Page: 22-32 DOI: By Laura Ungar, Jonel Aleccia Year: 2023 Container: AP News URL: https://apnews.com/article/cultivated-meat-
10.1016/j.gfs.2017.04.001 grown-cells-d92a4efa67309eb670d6b13bcca11604
Meat and dairy industry lobbies to stifle competition from alternative meat products
Why Is Eating Meat Bad for the Environment and Climate Change By Anon Year: 2023 Container: News-Medical URL: https://www.news-medical.net/news/20230818/Meat-and-dairy-
By Rachel Graham Year: 2022 Container: Sentient Media URL: https://sentientmedia.org/why-is- industry-lobbies-to-stifle-competition-from-alternative-meat-products.aspx
eating-meat-bad-for-the-environment/
It’s not just Big Oil. Big Meat also spends millions to crush good climate policy.
By Sigal Samuel Year: 2021 Container: Vox URL: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/22379909/big-meat-
Meat without killing animals? ‘This’ process is one answer to multiple problems
companies-spend-millions-lobbying-climate
By Livemint Year: 2023 Container: mint URL: https://www.livemint.com/news/world/meat-
without-killing-animals-this-process-gives-one-answer-to-multiple-problems- ‘Gigantic’ power of meat industry blocking green alternatives, study finds
11678377762116.html By Damian Carrington, Damian Carrington Environment editor Year: 2023 Container: The Guardian URL:
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/aug/18/gigantic-power-of-meat-industry-blocking-green-
alternatives-study-finds