SPM Unit 5
SPM Unit 5
5.4 Motivation
Motivation Theories
There are various theories formulated by different persons for motivating
the people to work. They are,
Taylorist Model
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory
Expectancy Theory of Motivation.
5.4.1 Taylorlst Model
Inthis model, Taylor emphasis on the piece-rates and day-rates.
> Piecerates are those where the workers are paid a fixed sum for each single
item they produce whereas day-rates refer to the daily pay that is given to the
workers on atimely basis.
The tendency towards dispersed or virtual projects where the staffs either
wotk in organization or work at home has adifference in the payment based
on time worked.
> The amount paidto the workers willnot directly relate to maximize the output
in order to maximize their income.
> The amount of output will normally depend on the working group and not
based onan individual.
> Areward based on piece-rates is directly proportional to the work produced.
But a support team cannot be adjudged by asingle person, instead it is group
activity and the reward must be given to the group as a whole.
> In Taylorist model, the reward system makes excessive distinctions between
co workers that result in damaging morale and productivity.
> This can be balanced by giving bonuses to project team members after
completion of asuccessful project.
2.Security or Safety Needs: These are the needs to be free of physical danger and
of the fear of losinga job property, food, or shelter.
3. Affiliation or Social Needs: Since people are social beings, they need to belong.
to be accepted by others. It includes friendship, the need to love and be loved,
socializing, etc.
4. Esteem Needs: Once people begin to satisfy their need to belong, they tend to
want to
be held in esteem both by themselves and by others. This kind of need produces
such satistactions as respect, power, prestige, status, and self-confidence.
º A hygiene factor makes the person dissatisfied if they are not rightly used.
For example, the working condition of the worker.
> Motivators can make the person feel that the job is worth doing it, like a
sense of achievement or the challenge of the work.
Higher-level of maintenance factors can be provided by large organizations
whereas better motivation can be provided to workers who work in smaller
organizations.
> Expectancy is a belief that working harder will lead to better performance.
Instrumentality is the belief that better performance willbe rewarded.
Percelved value denotes the resulting reward.
r When all these factors are high. then the
motivation level will also be high. At
the same time, azero level for any one of the factor can
remOve motIvation
completely.
For example, when the developer is suppose to get a software package
Supplied by athird party to work and it contains a bug, the worker gives up
since how much hard work the worker puts in it will not lead to success
denotes zero expectancy.
On the other side, if the user is not using the package supplied by the
developer, instead the user work_ on an alternative tool, it makes the
developer feel that it is waste of time and leads to zero instrumentality.
Suppose if the user is using the package but keeps on complaining about the
package and makes the developer responsibility for all short-comings, then at
some point of time the developer will not like to get involved for implementing
a newer package which leads to low perceive value of reward.
5.5 The Oldham-Hackman job characteristic model
Oldman and Hackman coined a rule that managers should group together the
elements of tasks that is carried out must be meaningful and satisfying
assignments.
The satisfaction of any job willdepend on the following factors:
Skillvariety
" Task identity
Task significance
Autonomy
Feedback
Ethics relates to the moral obligation to respect the rights and interests of others -
goesbeyondstrictly legal responsibilities.
the
Treatment
owners or employees of competitive businesses Uniform
One example of organizational ethics is the uniform treatment of all
employees. Small business owners should treat all employees with the same
respect, regardless of their race, religion, cultures or lifestyles. Everyone should
also have equal chances for promotions. One way to promote
unitorm
treatment in organizations is through sensitivity training. Some companies hold
one-day seminars on various discrimination issues. They then invite outside
experts in to discuss these topics. Similarly, small company managers must
also avoid favoring one employee over others. This practice may also lead to
lawsuits from disgruntled employees. It is also counterproductive.
Social Responsibility
Small companies also have an obligation to protect the community. For
example, the owner of a small chemical company needs to communicate
certain dangers to the community when explosions or other disasters occur.
The owner must also maintain certain safety standards for protecting nearby
residents from leaks that affect the water or air quality. There are state and
federal laws that protect people from unethical environmental practices.
Business owners who violate these laws may face stiff penalties. They may
also be shut down.
Financial Ethics
Business owners must run clean operations with respect to finances,
investing and expanding their companies. For example, organizations must not
also
bribe state legislators for tax credits or special privileges. Insider trading is
prohibited. Insider trading is when managers or executives illegally apprise
affecting publicly traded
investors or outside parties of privileged information
Commission. The information
stocks. according to the Securities and Exchange
returns on their investments at the
helps sorme investors achieve greater
companies must strive to help all
expense of others. Executives in small
They must also avoid collusive
shareholders earn better returns on their money.
companies to deliberately harm other competitors.
arrangements with other
Considerations
Asmall company's organizational ethics can also include taking care of
employees with mental illnesses or substance abuse problerns, such as drug
and alcohol dependency. Ethical business owners help their employees
overcome these types of problems when possible. They often put them through
employee advisor programs, which involves getting them the treatment they
need. Employees may have issues that lead to these types of problens.
Therefore, they deserve a chance to explain their situations and get the help
they need.
Professional ethics
Professionals have knowledge about the technical domain that the
general public does not. Ethical duty of the expert to warn lay people of the risks
involved in a particular COurse of action. Many professions, or would be
professions, have codes of conduct for their members
5.7.1Becoming a team
Making people work together is the most difficult task that the project
manager has tocarefully handle.
º Ateam cannot perform instantly; it has to develop over time.
Any project team must be formed with the best mix of different personalities.
>
balanced teams based on individual
Belbin formulated the need of
characteristics of people.
at conducting meetings, must be
Chair: these people must be good
Need not be excellent leaders.
calm, strong and tolerant. giving
these people must be good at generating ideas and
Plant:
problems.
potential solution to
must be good evaluators and best inselectina
Monitor-Evaluator: they
the most feasible solution.
Shaper. helps in directing the team's attention to important issues.
" Team worker. must be efficient in
creating a good working
environment.
Resource investigator. helps in finding resources in terms of both
physical resources and information.
Complete-finisher. people who are concerned with completing the
tasks.
Company-worker. must be good team player willing to undertake less
attractive work for team's success.
r To be agood team member, the person must be flexible, restrained, timely
and keepingthe common goals of the team in mind allthe time.
58 Decision rmaking
5.8.1Categories of Decisions
structured and unstructured
} Decision marirg process can be categorized into
applied in
Structured decisions are generally sinple where the rues are
a straight-forwards way
a great
Unstructured decisions are often more complex and require
degree of creativity
The anourt of risk and the uncertainty invotved in the development process
}
can affect the decision making process.
Making
5.8.2 Obstacles to Good Decision
decision mking process are
Few factors that affect g00d
rules of thurnb or heuristics are useful but can be
Fauty heuristics: the
mere stereotypes.
misleading. These are based on made
thís happens when a wrong decision is
Escalation of commitment
altered easily later. the
which cannot be information also might lead
much of
Information overload: too
cho0se a wrong one.
decision process to
Making stakeholders
5.8.3 Group Decision specialists and point of
view of
discussions, different
In aroup
can be brought together to
make a better decision.
Decisions made by a team can be approved and
accepted easily than
decisions imposed by individuals.
> Every group meeting takes the collective responsibility of
briefed solving complex
of having properly
problems.
ºA grOup can arrive at better
solutions for complex problems because the
members the group have complementary skills and
of
Group meetings provide an opportunity for expertise.
people to communicate freely and
easily among the members of the
group.
Often, groups are less effective for poorly
structures problems where
brainstorming techniques can be used to helps the groups to
make it
structured
} Even though, group decision making is
effective in achieving solutions, it has
been proved by research that people come up with
more ideas individually
than in groups.
The chief programmer defines the specification, design, code, tests and
documents the entire software.
The chief programmer can have a co-pllot whocan assist in writing some code
and discussions.
An editor can be used to write up the documentation drafted by the chief
and a
programmer, along with a program clerk who maintains the actual code
The chief programmer team is
nuch responsibility and authority issubject to single point failure since too
ince the chief assigned to the chief prograrnirner
programmer carries out
Rnger of information overload on the rmany tasks indrvidually, there is 3
chief prograrnmer
DemocraticTeam Structure
The democratic team
structure, as the name
formal team hierarchy. Decisions are taken based onimplies, does not enforce
memberis free to discuss with any other
discuSsions, where any
administrative leadership. At different
matters.Typically, a manager provides the
technicalleadership.
times,different mermbers of the group provide
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
Consequently, it suffers from less man-power turnover
4Control Team Structure
draws upon the ideas
e mixed team organization, as the name implies,
tester whovalidates the code.
The disadvantage of chief programmer teams is that the chief programmer is
Overloaded with lots of information and cannot manage at some point of time.
Extreme programming concept can overcone this disadvantage where the
software is developed by pairs of developers with a chief programmer / co-pilot
relationship.
Chief programmer
Team Members
Advantages
The chief programmer provides an authority, and this
structure is arguably
more efficient than the democraticteam for
well-understood problems.
However, the chief programmer team leads to lower team morale, since
team-members work under the constant supervision of the chiet
programmer.
This also inhibits collective and their original
thinking.
from both the democratic organization and the
chief prograrrime
organization. This team organization incorporates both hierarchical
reporting and democratic set up.
The democratic connections are shown as
dashed lines and the reporting
structure is shown using solid arrows.
The mixed control team
organization is suitable forlarge tearn sizes.
The democratic arrangement at the
senior engineer's level is Used tO
decomposethe problem into small parts. Each democratic setup at the
programmer level attempts solution to a single part. Thus, this
organization is eminently tearn
suited to handle large and
complex programs.
This team structure is extremely popular and is being used in many
development companies. software
Same Place
Place/Different
Place.
Same Time Different Place
Meetings, Interviews
Different Time Notice Boards Telephone, Instant Messaging
E-mail, Voice mail,
The nature of the
information to be
Documents
o What is conveyed:
the extent and
complexity of the information to be
0 ls it
Aphone
conversation if
message is simple
conveyed?
easyto
understand? Is the context well known to both the
and the recipient?
sender
Twoway communication
o Where the communicationis personally sensitive
Face-to-face contacts
At different stages of a project - different communication genres will be preferred