THE STRAITS TIMES SINGAPORE 

没什么 UN report on safety of lab-grown meats cites S’pore,

the only country selling them, as case study
点

Cell-cultured chicken kebab skewers can be bought at Huber’s Butchery in Dempsey. PHOTO: GOOD MEAT
 Shabana Begum

UPDATED 2023年4⽉7⽇ 下午7:15 SGT

SINGAPORE - Singapore is the only country in the world where consumers can buy cell-cultured
chicken, but how safe are such laboratory-grown meats for consumption?
Two United Nations (UN) agencies released a global report to address this issue, in efforts to
bring more of such foods to the dining table and assure consumers that they are safe to eat.
病原述
Traces of antibiotics in the meat product, pathogens in the animal cells that can spread to
humans and possible genetic changes in cells as they multiply were identified as some of the
potential hazards of cell-based meats in the report.
Put together by the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) and the World Health Organisation
(WHO), the report cited Singapore, which approved cell-cultured chicken for sale in 2020, as a
case study in the regulation of such meats.

The report concluded that many of the hazards identified in cell-based foods already exist in
conventionally produced foods and livestock agriculture, and hence the meats are safe for
consumption if produced and handled well.
Released on Wednesday, the report was largely a result of a meeting among experts and officials
from 15 countries and the two UN agencies in November 2022. The four-day meeting in
Singapore was convened to identify the potential hazards that cell-cultured meat could harbour
and ways to avoid them.
In Singapore, cell-cultured chicken by Californian start-up Eat Just was approved for sale three
years ago. It is currently being sold at Huber’s Butchery in Dempsey Road as kebab skewers with
couscous and fried chicken salad. Each dish costs $18.50.
 Get a round-up of the top stories to start your day

Enter your e-mail Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy and T&Cs.

Other cell-cultured meats, such as beef and fish, are still being developed, while some firms
abroad are seeking approval from the Singapore Food Agency (SFA) to sell their slaughter-free
thin-cut steaks and minced pork items here.
Currently, there are more than 100 cell-based food start-ups around the world.

Cell-based meat is made by taking cells from a cow, chicken or fish through a biopsy and then
growing the cells in a nutrient broth and media. The tissues are harvested, prepared and
packaged into meat products.

Such meats generated from cells may combine different cell types like muscle and fat cells to
replicate the structure and texture of meat. Extrusion techniques and 3D printing, as well as
flavouring and preservatives, are used to create products that are close to meat from livestock.
Titled Food Safety Aspects of Cell-based Food, the report listed a number of possible hazards
that could arise in each stage of the production process, from sourcing the cells to formulating
the final nugget or steak.

The spread of foodborne pathogens such as Salmonella, E. coli and Listeria from the biopsied
cells to the end product was one of the hazards highlighted in the report. But it noted that the
risk was much lower when compared with livestock breeding.
To avoid this problem, cell-cultured meat firms can ask for livestock and aquaculture health
certifications and inspection of the source animals to ensure they are disease-free. Testing for
pathogens can also be done before banking the cells, said the report.

MORE ON THIS TOPIC

Singapore to approve 16 species of insects like crickets and grasshoppers to be sold as food

What you need to know about cultivated meat

The use of antibiotics to prevent the cells from being contaminated by bacteria was also
identified as an issue as residual antibiotics in the meat products could be a health hazard and
contribute to antimicrobial resistance.

The report recommended that limited amounts of antibiotics should be used. Washing can help
remove or reduce the concentration of contaminants in the final product.

Mutations from changes to the genes as the cells multiply could build up and create novel toxins.

However, the mutations alone will not pose any significant problems to consumers, said
Professor William Chen, director of Nanyang Technological University’s Food Science and
Technology programme.

“DNA from meat, with or without mutations, will be degraded in our digestive system, and thus
they have a low possibility of integrating into our genes and leading to any potential health risks,”
said Prof Chen. He is the vice-chair of the panel of international experts who gathered in
Singapore in November.

Those allergic to seafood are likely to have the same reactions from eating cell-based shrimp or
shellfish, and scientific research can help to alleviate this.

Prof Andreas Lopata from James Cook University in Singapore is currently analysing and
comparing the tissues of different fish species to find out how much allergens they carry.

The aim is to find species with low amounts of allergens and use them to make safer cell-based
fish fillets or sashimi.
MORE ON THIS TOPIC

Plant-based fishballs and luncheon meat? Traditional food manufacturers offer meatless options

Josh Tetrick, co-founder and CEO of Eat Just, wants you to eat real meat without killing animals

The 146-page report included a case study on Singapore’s novel food scene and the SFA’s rigorous
regulatory framework for novel foods.
The agency, a co-host of the November meeting with FAO, works closely with novel food firms to
discuss safety assessment plans, and has also been offering virtual consultations for companies
since 2021.

A key aim of the global report is to equip the authorities, particularly in less-developed countries,
with knowledge about cell-based food production and help them shape their regulatory
framework.

The document also noted that cell-based meats are an “alleged sustainable alternative” to
conventional livestock, and more work is needed to prove that such meats are indeed greener.

The report concluded that hazard identification is only the first step of the formal risk
assessment process for cell-based food, and more scientific data, insights and the sharing of
information are needed to further the safety and trust in these future foods.

Prof Chen, who is also a consultant to FAO on alternative and novel foods, said: “The report
would help cell-based meat companies align themselves with the global standard and harmonise
their processes. This in turn would enhance food safety and boost consumer confidence.”

MORE ON THIS TOPIC

Can diners tell plant-based chicken from the real thing?

S’pore first to approve protein 'made from air'

Already a subscriber? Log in

 New year, New(s) Resolutions!
Kick-start your new(s) resolution with ST

ST One Digital
$9.90/month $4.95*/month
1 year

*$59.40 for the first year and $118.80 per year thereafter. Subscribe now

Unlock these benefits

All subscriber-only content on ST app and straitstimes.com

Follow up to 30 authors and 30 topics on myST

Access to subscriber-only giveaways and promotions

Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
 • SINGAPORE • TECH

• ASIA • SPORT

• WORLD • VIDEOS

• OPINION • PODCASTS

• LIFE • MULTIMEDIA

• BUSINESS

About Us  E-paper

Terms & Conditions  Facebook

Privacy Policy  Instagram

Need help? Reach us here.  Twitter

Advertise with us  LinkedIn

 Sign up for our daily newsletter  Podcasts

Enter your e-mail Sign up  RSS Feed

More newsletters  Telegram

By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy.

 Youtube

 TikTok

MCI (P) 066/10/2023. Published by SPH Media Limited, Co. Regn. No. 202120748H. Copyright © 2024 SPH Media Limited. All rights reserved.