Blessing Project
Blessing Project
BY
SAMUEL BLESSING
KPT/CST/15/10136
SEPTEMBER, 2021
i
CERTIFICATION
This is to certify that this project titled STRATEGIES FOR IMPROVING THE
Technology Education, College of Technical and Vocational Education, Kaduna Polytechnic has
Electrical/Electronic Technology Education. The work embodied in this project is original and
has not been submitted in part or whole for any other diploma or degree of this or any other
university.
_________________________ ____________________
Blessing Samuel Date
KPT/CST/15/10136
ii
APPROVAL PAGE
This project has been read and approved as meeting the requirement for the award of Bachelor of
_______________________ __________________
Mal. Hadi M. Adamu Date
Project Supervisor
________________________ ____________________
Project Coordinator
_______________________ __________________
Dr. S. S. Imam Date
Head of Department
_______________________ __________________
External Examiner Date
iii
DEDICATION
This Project is dedicated to God Almighty for his love and protection over my life throughout
my studies.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Glory be to God Almighty for His mercy and kindness towards me. I wish to thank my project
supervisor Mal. Hadi Mohammed. Adamu for his patience, endurance, support and
encouragement. Despite his tight schedule, he still gives his to me for the success of this study.
My special appreciation to the Head of Department, Dr. S. S. Imam and all the lecturers of
Electrical Technology Department for their advice guidance and encouragement towards the
I cannot forget my beloved parents and families who supported me morally and financially
I would also like to appreciate my course mates and friends in the school whom assisted me
throughout the period of this study Abraham, Maria Innocent, Mustapha and Hissah Ibrahim just
to mention but a few. Thank you for everything you’ve done. See you at the very top.
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title page ________________________________________________________________i
Approval page_____________________________________________________________ii
Declaration_______________________________________________________________iii
Dedication iv
Acknowledgment v
Table of contents vi
List of table viii
Abstract ix
CHAPTER ONE: Introduction
Background of the study 1
Statement of the problem 2
Purpose of the study 3
Research questions 4
Significance of the study 3
Scope of the study 4
CHAPTER TWO: Review of Related Literature
The development of Safety Standard in Nigeria 5
Measures to be taken to reduce accident in technical workshop and laboratories 6
Type of Accident that Commonly Occur in Technical Workshop/Laboratory 9
Strategies for Enforcement of Safety in Technical Workshop/Laboratory 10
Empirical Framework (Review of Empirical Data) 11
Summary of review of Related Literature 15
CHAPTER THREE:Methodology
Research Design 17
Area of the Study 17
Population of the Study 17
Sampling and Sampling Techniques 18
Instrument for Data Collection 18
Validation of the Instrument 19
Reliability of the Instrument 19
vi
Method for Data Collection 19
Method of Data Analysis 19
CHAPTER FOUR: Data Presentation and Analysis
Data presentation and analysis 21
Discussion of Findings 24
CHAPTER FIVE: Summary, Conclusion and Recommendations
Re-statement of the procedure 26
Summary of Procedure Used 26
Major Findings 27
Implications of the study 27
Conclusion 27
Recommendations 28
Suggestions for further studies 28
Limitation 29
References 30
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Population Distribution Table ____________________________________________19
Table 2: Mean of response of students and teachers on how often accident occur
APPENDIX
vii
Appendix B
Appendix C
viii
Abstract
This project Strategies for improving the implementation of Safety Practices in Technical
Workshops and Laboratories in Government Technical Colleges, Kaduna State was carried out
at Government Technical Colleges in Kaduna state. Three research questions were formulated to
guide the study. The design adopted was a descriptive survey. The population of the study was
105 which consist of 84 students of Government Technical College and 21 technical teachers
including Heads of Departments of the Department, 3 schools were sampled, the total population
for the sampled schools were used. A structured questionnaire was used to collect data for the
study and the instrument was personally collected by the researcher and mean statistics was
employed to analyze data relating to the research questions. Some findings of the study reveal
that accidents occur frequently in workshops, there is no adequate level of workshop safety
awareness among the students. Based on the findings of the study, it was recommended that:
students should be more careful while working in technical workshops. School Management
should ensure that tools and equipment are adequately maintained in the workshops of
Government Technical Colleges. New students should be giving safety orientation before they
start using the Technical Workshops and equipment.
ix
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 INTRODUCTION
It is an indisputable fact that where ever work is done with machine or hand tools
tools and materials in a work place. Alake, (1998). This accident may be caused by the
worker’s commission or omissions, in technical schools’ workshops and laboratories that are
equipped with a variety of tools, machines, equipment and substances for teaching and
learning. These schools, full of inexperienced students, need to be protected and prevented
from engaging in acts capable of causing accidents. As a result, safety rules and regulations
must be devised and enforced for smooth interaction and operation. They must be encouraged
in whatever ways feasible to observe these rules and regulations. These safe working habits,
if imbibed in Technical Schools workshops, would help school leavers function safely in
industries. As such, some of these rules and regulations are going to be carefully analyse in
this study as personal safety, safety at the work bench, safety on machines and general safety
people would choose to sympathize with victims of accidents even when the victims are the
interruption in the completion of an activity. Accidents have serious effect upon the
individual worker, equipment, materials and production output. It causes significant loss of
time to the establishment, work hours and time to attend to the victim. Jain (2008) pointed out
that accident effect the family of its victim causing on anxiety to members. It becomes worst
if the accident is fatal and results in death of its victim, his skill is lost forever, his family is
1
indirectly broken up, and his place in the technical workshops/laboratories may take some
time or years to be filled by a substitute. This increases a burden on the establishment where
the concern of this investigation is to assess the extent to which safety practices are being
It has been observed that a lot of accidents that occur in workshops or industries are
because of what Alake (1998), referred to as lack of safety awareness among workers in both
workshops and industries. The workshop which is the back bone of any functional Technical
Education is according to Simpson (1998) home of all kinds of materials, equipment and
tools and machines that move during work process. These pose a danger not only to shop
workers but materials, tools machinery and installations. It has become of paramount
serves as guide for his conduct, behaviors and even actions to the end that he will be free
from injury accident or danger, Jadas, (2015). It could also mean mental or emotional guide
for personal conduct while working and living in highly mechanized world. Dnuoh (2001),
Sara (2004) and Jain (2008) the way of avoiding accident in the workshop is ways of
Safety
turn will improve stability reduce cost of maintenance and medical bills.
2
3. Safety rules and regulations in workshop will also be adhere to mode of dressing,
Workplace safety is very important for each and every student and staff in the
workshop because it is their desire to work in a safe and protected atmosphere. Safety
practices is the key to the safety of all users of the workshop. Safety practices is the key to the
safety of all users of the workshop. Safety practices apply to employees involved in the
operation and maintenance of the work environment, tools, materials and equipment. This
includes instructors, workshop technicians, machine operators, cleaners, and other operations
machines as well as persons. However, there is still poor compliances of students to the use
the necessary safety gadgets such as muffler and respirator during practical in the workshop
(Azodo, Adinife & Adejuyigbe, 2013); poor concern for minor faults and problem of
workshop tools and equipment (Omeje & Omeje, 2014); and poor application of important
safety skills in managing the school workshop (Omeje & Omeje, 2014). These prompted the
researcher to carry out a study on the strategies for implementation of safety practice in
3
1.3 Purpose of the Study
The purpose of the study is strategies for improving the implementation of safety practices in
1. Find out the causes of accidents in the workshops and laboratories in Technical
2. Find out the level of safety awareness among the students of Technical College in
Kaduna state.
3. Identify the measures that need be taken to reduce the rate of accidents in the
1. What are the causes of accident in the workshops and laboratories of Kaduna state
Technical Colleges?
2. What is the level of safety awareness among staff and students of Kaduna state
Technical Colleges?
3. What measure need to be taken to reduce the rate of accidents in Kaduna State
Technical College?
The findings of this study will be of immense benefit to the students of the Technical
College in Kaduna state who will understand the importance of safety rules and regulations
because it will assist them in the workshops and laboratories. The Technical workshops and
laboratories instructors would also benefit from the study since there are strategies that could
Educational researchers would also benefit from the study since it provides more
researchable recommendations. The Administrators, teachers, the board and parents will also
4
benefit from this study by providing guidelines for obeying rules and regulations in technical
The study will be conducted in Technical College Kaduna state owned by Kaduna state
government all other technical colleges are therefore not within the scope of this study. The
study is also limited to safety practice in the Workshops and Laboratories of this College.
5
CHAPTER TWO
This chapter reviewed literature relevant is the study under the following sub-headings:
Conceptual framework
Strategies
Workshops and laboratories are typically considered as highly hazardous place in the
school when addressing safety issues, therefore the improvement of implementation of safety
The purpose of this study was to determine the strategies for improving the
Safety standards are laid down rules and guidelines written down and backed by
registration to check the menaces of increasing rate of industrialization. Sani etal, (2000),
describe that safety standards have evoked out of necessity as the higher percentage of
6
accidents in the world today. Safety standard are either prescribed by government, industries
concerned or organization where non safety environment prevail. Faulty machine design and
installation without regard to the provision of factories act (2009) section 15, which state that
every part of machine and all dangerous parts of other machineries etc. must be securely
guarded, unless they are in such a position or of such construction as to be safe of every
person working on the premises as they could be securely guarded. Worn spanners, files
without handles and loose hammer heads are potential causes of accident is the Technical
workshop. Equally, carrying sharp cutting tools in overall pockets, walking through restricted
areas marked with barriers or long pieces of material or equipment unasserted can cause
accident as they may hit other equipment or work man on machine operation .
Jain (2005) classified causes of accident in the Technical Workshop and Laboratory in
to the following:
1. Environmental factors like illumination or lack of proper illumination will in pair vision
2. Human factors which include ignorance or failure of the shop worker to understand
hazards involved. Taking chance, forget fullness, alcoholism, fatigue, bore down and
3. Material factors: - These include broken down safety guards, equipment inadequate
maintenance which causes accident in the Technical workshop and laboratory but
reduces the useful life span of equipment poor and distribution of safety signs in the
Technical workshops/laboratories.
According to Onuaha (2001) silent or brief on safety in the Technical workshops and
laboratories and the silence presupposes that safety is left to the discretion of the instructors.
7
Introduction of a comprehensive safety programmed in the School Technical Workshops and
laboratories are given safety orientation to new students even before using the Technical
workshops/laboratories. Attah (2007) provide instruction in the use of all hand tools, machine
and equipment keeping a record of each student’s safety training and other personal
protective equipment in place, while working in the Technical Workshops and laboratories.
This provide protective guide and ensure that they are used whenever a machine is operated
in the Technical workshop. Beware of emotional disturbance and accident proven students as
some of those that have accident on jobs that seem quite safe where they require close
supervision.
Check Technical workshop facilities regularly to ensure safe condition. Given special
attention to machine layout, equipment guarding, storage and condition of hand tools and
described that students and other shop workers on their own part can reduce occurrence of
loose fitting, outer garments, roll up shirt sleeves above elbow, wearing protective clothing
and use of safety shoes or leather shoes with thick sole that can reduce the chance of accident.
Removal of jewelry, wrist watches, bangles, neck tie, neck laces, when working with
metal/keeping ones workspace clear and avoid walking in restricted areas. Walk not runs in
the Technical Workshops and laboratories. Keep your work bench tidy, remove scraps and
Do not carry too many cutting tools at once and when passing a pointed tool or sharp
tool to a shop mate, pass then through the handle. Do not carry sharp or edge cutting tool on
your open pocket. When carrying sharp edge or pointed tool such as chisel, bits, knives,
scribers, etc. hold them close to the edge with their cutting edge point down wards. Store
8
tools in tool kit or tool rack in their respective places immediately after use to avoid
Dully tools can cause accident from extra effort require to use them and jagged edge
can cause an injury for someone. To reduce accident resulting from machine faults, see that
machine parts, such as guides belts fence, tool rest, cutters, etc are properly filled. Do not use
a machine with faulty parts and make sure the machine tools are properly oiled.
Guards should be positioned and secured and obtain permission before using a
machine. Always observe mechanical safety rules, check materials for safe use on machine
tools. Select and use tools and machines correctly. Loose work piece could get through out of
the machine and course severe injury to persons in their direction. Taking measurement while
Electrical terminals should be protected to prevent accidental contact with live parts.
Wires connected to them, must have the minimum exposed conductors, treat all conductors in
the vary connection must be safe and electrically sound. High voltage equipment should have
an earth connection attached and all metal part must be adequately earthed. Knowing the
position of alarms, five extinguishers, buckets with sand fire exist and know which fire
The best way to reduce Accidents in the Workshops and laboratories is to be proactive
with prevention. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. There are many ways to
prevent Accidents but implementing these methods, you need to be consistent and
9
3. Communicate your expectations for a safe work environment.
5. Have the right tools available so that the Students don’t have to improvise.
6. Schedule regularly training for all scenarios that pose a risk for Accidents.
7. Make sure your Workshops and laboratories entrances and exits are fully operational and
easily accessible.
8. Clearly mark potential safety concern with the proper signage and instruction.
The Technical workshops and laboratories is a place where all sort of equipment and
tools are used. An accident according to Sara (2004) Stated that accident is an unexpected
by Ajasafe et al, (2007) maintained that, it is not necessary, but most often resulting to
Laboratories
Talking of Technical workshops and laboratories accident, work shop accident is that
laboratories.
technical workshop:
10
4. Accident from loose dresses, neck ties and dwell having caught up by moving
machine parts.
outbreak, etc.
The main goals of strategies for enforcement of safety in technical workshop are to
laboratories and to encourage all Technical Workshops and Laboratories users to obey rules
Enforcement is one of the complementary strategies that use to enable more students
to work in the technical workshops and laboratories safety. But enforcement used alone will
not likely have a long-term effect. Teacher and Technologist must utilised the combination of
needs of their school Technical workshops and laboratories and achieve long- term results.
In order to ensure the condition that warrants safety, health and reduction in Mean
Time between Failure (MTBF) of tools and machinery in the technical workshops and
laboratories and Sara (2004) referred to it as safety consciousness. It is possible to reduce the
students, participation in safety awareness and a corrective action when rules are ignored,
safety programmed are enforce to students, through safety orientation of all new students in
the technical workshops and laboratories for accident preventive measures even before using
11
the technical workshops and laboratories. Despite the enforcement of safety rules as
stipulated above, students don’t seem to comply fully. However, if accidents are to be
avoided in the technical workshops and laboratories, students must develop positive attitude
towards safety and observation in totality of all safety rules and regulations.
state technical colleges. A descriptive research survey design guided the study. The
electrical/electronic trades. There were no sample and sampling techniques due to small
population size. Four research questions were answered. The instrument used for data
collection was a structured questionnaire which was validated by two experts. The instrument
for the study was partitioned into four sections. Sections A to D were patterned after Likert 5
point rating scale of agreement. A reliability coefficient of 0.85 was established for the
instrument using Cronbach Alpha coefficient reliability method. Mean and standard deviation
were used to answer the research questions. The reviewed study is similar to the present
study. Both studies targets safety practices in the technical college’s workshop. The reviewed
study is different from the present study because the highlighted study was carried out in
Rivers state while the present study will be carried out in Kaduna state. The reviewed study
focuses on Electrical/electronic workshops while the present study focuses on the workshops
and laboratories.
Qasim, Bashir, Shan, Malik, Anees, Ghani, Khalid, Malik & Hanan (2014) carried out
a study on Concept of occupational health and safety and evaluation of awareness level
among employees. Study was conducted at shoe factory of Gujrat (Pakistan). In this study,
both primary and secondary data is used primary data collected through observation/walk
12
through survey and structured questionnaire by 655 employees of the industry. The required
secondary data and information was collected from various publications such as books,
journals, magazines published and unpublished dissertations, newspapers and internet and
also primary data collection through closed ended questionnaire, exploratory as well as
descriptive methods are used to analyze the data and information. Presentation of produced
data is used in tables and necessary maps and a diagram is used whenever appropriate. After
analyzing and interpreting the data and information, a conclusion is drawn and a
recommendation is made. The highlighted study is similar with the present study. Both
studies are concerned with the safety of users of a workplace/workshop. The reviewed study
and the present study are different because the reviewed study examines the concept of
occupational health and safety and evaluation of awareness level among employees while the
present study will examine the strategies from implementation of safety practices in
workshop in technical college Kaduna. The reviewed study was carried out in India while the
accidents in automotive repair workshops in Spain. To analyze the effects of the factors
associated with different types of injury (superficial wounds, dislocations and sprains, bone
fractures, concussion and internal injuries, burns scalding and freezing) caused by
89,954 industry accidents reported from 2003 to 2008. Odds ratios were calculated with a
95% confidence interval. Results from the shows that belonging to a small company is a risk
factor for suffering three of the five types of injury studied. Women are less likely to suffer
burns and superficial wounds, and more like to suffer dislocations or sprains. Foreign
workers are more likely to suffer concussion and internal injuries. In conclusion, health and
safety strategies and accident prevention measures should be individualized and adapted to
13
the type of worker most likely to be injured in each type of accident. Occupational health and
safety training courses designed according to worker profile, and improving the participation
of the workers in small firms creating regional or roving safety representative would improve
working conditions. The highlighted stud is different from the present study in the
highlighted study analyzed workplace accidents in automobile workshop while the present
study seeks strategies for implementation of safety practice in workshops and laboratories in
The highlight study was carried out in Spain while the present study will be carried
out in Kaduna, Kaduna Nigeria. The two studies are similar because they both targets
accidents in the workshop. Also, Asconcelos & Junior (2015) carried out a study on the
causes of work place accidents and their relation to construction equipment design. This
study aims to analyze a workplace accident on a construction site, in the area of solid waste
recycling, in order to identify the causes of the accident and propose solutions to the design
of the construction equipment. A technical analysis of the fatal accident was designed based
on an on-site inspection of the accident, meetings and testimony gathering, a report on the
nature of the event, a probable description of the accident and a proposal for corrective and
preventive measures. Amongst the possible causes of this fatal accident are: failure in the
design of the mobile crushing equipment, inadequate instructions from the manufacturer
regarding the use of the bridge, inappropriate operating procedures, and lack of training on
the part of the management team. Finally, corrective and preventive measures were proposed,
focusing on the design of the product involved in the accident. The highlighted study is
different from the present study. The highlighted study studies construction workplace
accident while the present will study accidents in the workshop in technical colleges. The
reviewed study was carried out in Brazil while the present study will be carried out in
14
Kaduna, Kaduna state. The reviewed study is similar to the present study because both
school workshops. A total of 130 National Diploma Engineering Student participated in the
survey, who filled out questionnaire with 15 items measuring awareness of workshop safety
precautions. Descriptive statistics was used to analyse the data. The results showed that a
majority of students have between moderate to high level of awareness of workshop safety
precaution excepts in 3 items where students have between low and zero level awareness.
Furthermore the results showed 3 items with high mean scores of 3.09, 3.24 and 3.01
respectively. The overall result indicates that students have quite awareness on safety has
Hrymak & Perezgnozalez (2007) carried out a study on the costs and effects of workplace
accidents. Twenty workplace accidents were investigated from various work sectors and
locations around Ireland. The term accident was broadly define and includes stress and
violence related incidents. The twenty case studies comprised an almost equal mix of public
and private sector employments; including health, manufacturing, construction and local
authority sectors. The injured employees were from a range of occupations; the majority
worked in larger sized companies or organizations. The work based accidents included falls,
accidents while using machine or equipment, manual handling incidents, driving or motor
vehicle accidents, stress related incidents, and verbal and physical abuse. The accidents
occurrence between 1995 and 2006. Eleven of the injured employees were male, nine were
female. The reviewed study is different from the present study. The reviewed study focused
on the costs and effects of workplace accidents while the present study focused on strategies
15
for implementation of safety practice in the workshops in government technical college
Kaduna, Kaduna.
This chapter reviewed literature on the study which covered the development of safety
standard in Nigeria, the causes of accidents in Technical Workshops and laboratories, the
measures to reduce accidents in Technical Workshops and Laboratories and the types of
students, participation in safety awareness and a corrective action when rules are ignored,
safety programmed are enforced to students through safety orientation of all new students in
The Technical Workshops and Laboratories is a place where all sort of equipments
and tools are used. An accident according to Sara (2004) stated that accident is an unexpected
Ajasafe et al, (2007) maintained that, it is not necessary, but must often resulting to damage
The best way to reduce accidents in the Workshops and laboratories is to be proactive
The main goals of strategies for enforcement of safety in Technical Workshops are to
Laboratories and to encourage all Technical Workshops and Laboratories users to obey rules
16
CHAPTER THREE
3.0 METHODOLOGY
This chapter describes the method and procedure adapted in carrying out the research
work, such as the design of the study, Area of the study, population, Sampling, Description of
the instrument for data collection, Validation of the Instrument, Reliability of the Instrument,
The study will adopt a survey design method. According to Osuola (2001) survey
design focus on people’s beliefs, opinion attitudes, motivation and behavior, by collecting
and analyzing data from the sample considered to be representative of the entire population.
The area of the study is Kaduna state North-western Nigeria. Kaduna state share the
land boundary with Zamfara state, Katsina state, Kano state to the North, Bauchi and Plateau
State to the East, Nasarawa state to the South, Niger to the West, Abuja to the South West.
The population for this study constitutes all the Technical Teachers and all Students
17
Table 1: Population Distribution Table
The stratified random sampling technique was adopted to select the schools. One
school from each senatorial zone were selected at random. Government Technical College
Malali was selected in Kaduna Central, Government Technical College Kajuru in Kaduna
North and Government Technical College, Samaru Kataf in Kaduna South was selected at
random. While the entire population of the school selected were used, this make the total
sample to 56.
The instrument used for data collection was a structured questionnaire. The
questionnaire was structured according to four (4) point rating scale. The four point rating for
the respondent is designed with Strongly Agree (SA), Agree (A), Disagree (D) and Strongly
Disagree (SD). For all categories of respondents. The questionnaire has two parts: part A for
personal data where the respondents are expected to fill in some blank spaces. Part B
Section “1” contains 5 items to find out how often do accident occur in the workshops of
Section “2” has 6 items on the level of safety awareness among the staff and students.
18
Section “3” has twelve items seeking to elicit information on measure need to be taken to
reduce the rate of accidents in the workshop and laboratories of Kaduna state Technical
Colleges.
The respondents are expected to respond by ticking () in the provided boxes
The questionnaire was validated by two experts from College of Vocational and
Technical Education Kaduna Polytechnic. They examined the appropriateness and adequacy
of all items of the questionnaire in providing appropriate response or data for answering each
of the item.
Pilot test instrument was carried out to determine the reliability of the Instrument. In
this regard, the questionnaire was administered to twenty Teachers and thirty-seven Students.
The data was collected and analyzed. The instrument was found to be 0.75 reliability
coefficient.
The researcher and the research assistant collected the data from the respondents. To
ensure proper retrieval of the questionnaire, the research assistants were trained for a day for
The data collected was presented in a tabular form and responses was calculated using
statistical mean followed by detailed interpretations. The mean of each item was computed.
From the raw score obtained from the responses to the items on the questionnaire. A decision
rule of 2.50 (cut off mean) was used. This implies that any item with mean response of 2.50
and above is considered Agree and any item with mean response below 2.50 is considered as
19
The mean response with appropriate nominal values (raw score) and dividing by the
Efx
The mean formula is x =
N
Where E = Summation
F = Frequency
x = Weight of scale
N = number of subject
20
CHAPTER FOUR
This chapter deals with presentation and analysis of data that was collected for this
study and discussion of the findings. The items with mean score of 2.50 and above are
considered as agreed while the items with scores below 2.50 are considered as disagreed.
The data was presented and analyzed based on the research questions which guided
the study.
Table 2: Mean of Response of Students and teachers on how often accidents occur in the
From the above table, five items were presented to answer research question 1. Table 1 shows
that respondents agreed with items 1, 2, 3 and 4, and disagreed with 5 on the question how
21
Table 3: The mean of response of students and teachers on the level of safety awareness
6. Staff and students are aware of the workshop safety rules 3.30 Agreed
7. Staff and student are aware of the appropriate workshop 3.30 Agreed
safety wears.
8. Staff and students are exposed to adequate safety training. 3.00 Agreed
rules
10. Staff and student are not adequately aware of accident 2.10 Disagreed
11. Staff and student are non-challan of the safety rules. 2.80 Agreed
From the above table, six items were presented to answer research question 2. Table 2 shows
that the respondents agreed with items 6, 7, 8 and 11, and disagreed with item 9 and 10 on the
level of safety awareness between staff and student of Government Technical College
Kaduna State.
22
Table 4: The mean of responses of students and teachers on the method of reducing the
13. Never take a job for which you have not been train for. 3.20 Agreed
16. Use proper tools for the job at hand. 3.70 Agreed
18. Keep the walkway free from obstacles and moisture. 3.50 Agreed
22. Turn on the current at the switch box before any repair job. 3.70 Agreed
From the above table, twelve items were presented to answer research question 3. Table 3
shows that the respondents agreed with all the items on the measures that need to necessarily
be taken to reduce the rate of accidents in Government Technical College Kaduna state.
23
4.2 Discussion of Findings
The discussion of the findings is based on the research questions. Under the research
question one, the findings of the study from table 1 shows the respondents agrees that
accident occurs often in the school workshops daily and sometimes blood spilling accidents
are reported annually in a school. This supports the work of Hrymak & Pérezgonzález (2007)
which indicated that accident occurs daily in the workshop, most of which are unreported.
Even though the findings showed that serious accident that require medical attention does not
occur two to three times in a term and also no serious accident is reported in the school for
the past three years, accident do not occur. The data clearly shows there is no adequate record
In research question two, findings from the study under table 2 shows that the
respondents disagree on the level of safety awareness between staff and students of
Government Technical College. Findings indicated that students are not well supervised in
the observation of safety rules. Also, staff and students are aware of accident management
issues and the use of first aid. This does not support the work of Kaduna et al (2014) that 95
percent of workers do not have training how to use fire extinguisher in emergency and 89
percent of workers don’t know how to use alarm in emergency. The findings of this study is
not in consonance with the work of Abdullahi (2017) who revealed that a majority of students
Furthermore, findings indicate that students have quite a high level of awareness of workshop
safety. The work of Abdullahi further revealed that students’ high level of awareness on
safety has influenced the environmentally safe working condition in the polytechnic
workshops.
personal protective equipment, Never take a job for which you have not been train for,
24
Always follow safety of the workplace, use proper tool for the job at hand, keep the walkway
free from obstacle, always read manufacturers instruction before usage, keep the work way
free from obstacles and moistures, regular orientation on safety, train and retrain workshop
attendants and regular orientation on safety as measures to be taken to reduce the rate of
accident in Government Technical College, Kaduna. This is in consonance with the work of
Deebom, Tambari, & Obulor. (2018) in identifying some measures for minimizing the rate of
accidents in the workshop. Also, Osang, Obi & Ewona as cited in Deebom et al
(2018)discovery was in consonance with the present finding that to avoid or minimize
accidents in the laboratory or workshop, these workshop safety and precision need to be
observed: read carefully and understand all the rules before using the workshop; do not run in
the workshop; wear strong shoes plus thick soles; get first aid immediately for any injury; be
sure you have sufficient light to see clearly; don’t wear ring, watches, bracelets or other
jewelry that could get caught in moving machinery; keep the floor free of oil, grease or any
25
CHAPTER FIVE
This chapter present the summary of the study under the following sub-headings:
(e) Conclusion
(f) Recommendation
Based on the objectives of the study, the problem of this study is to identify the
Technical Colleges in Kaduna state. Onuaha (2001) described carelessness of Students in the
The research was based on the strategies for improving safety standards in Workshops
The administration of the questionnaire was carried out directly by the researchers
with the assistance of research assistants who went to the Government Technical College in
26
The data collected was analyzed by using four points rating scale. Discussion of data
was carried out item by item which the research findings were obtained. The total number of
the Teachers and Students used for this study are 105 in Kaduna Technical College. The
questionnaire contained 23 items. Each of the items was structured in four points rating scale
for the respondents to tick in the appropriate column. It was validated by my project
supervision and two other experts in the College of Technical and Vocational Education,
Kaduna polytechnic.
1. Accident happens daily in the school workshops but most of them go unnoticed or are
not reported.
3. There is not enough level of safety awareness between staff and students of
safety, use of proper tools for the jobs at hand, and constant training of workshops
College, Kaduna.
5. Staff and students are not adequately aware of accidents management issues and the
The implication of the findings of the study is to support the fact that all Technical
Workshops and Laboratories accidents are directly or indirectly attributed to unsafe acts like
27
students’ carelessness in the Workshop. These result to accidents such as burns from hot
metal. However, if proper maintenance of Workshop tools and equipment are carried out and
effective Safety education programme are given to students the rate of occurrence of
will be reduced.
5.5 Conclusion
Workshops and Laboratories in Technical Colleges in Kaduna state is poor considering the
rate of awareness and knowledge of safety itself. In this regard, strategies have to be taken to
The result obtained from the study confirmed that there is high rate of accidents in the
workshops. There is not enough safety awareness between staff and students and measures
Kaduna state.
Finally, from the result of this study, the researcher sees the reason why safety
Laboratories as the Students are ready to comply with the strategies for improving the safety
5.6 Recommendations
Based on the findings drawn from this study, the researcher has made the following
recommendations to the School Management, the Ministry of Education and the Students
which if implemented will go a long way to improve the enforcement of safety standard in
28
2. Students should use personal protective equipment where necessary
3. School Management should ensure that tools and facilities are adequately maintained
orientation before they start using the Workshops and Laboratories of Technical
5. Students and staff should always follow safety rules of the workshops and
laboratories.
For further research, the following areas are suggested for other researchers to
undertake.
Kaduna state.
state.
The study is limited to finding out the strategies for improving the implementation of
Kaduna state. It’s does not covers the entire technical schools in the country. It is limited to
29
References
Abdullahi, M. L. (2002). Maintenance of Workshop Tools and Equipment. Kano: Yamble
enterprises.
Ajasafe (2007), Study of safety practice in Secondary Schools
Alake, J. T (1998) Need for safety precaution in Technical Workshop. Technical Education
Today (NBTE) 8(1 & 2)
Attah, E. B. (2007). Students’ organization and dynamics of human behaviors Strategy for
making instruction in Vocational/Technical Teacher. Journal of Technical Teachers
Education (JOTTED).
Arquillos, A & Rubio-Romero, J. (2016).Analysis of Workplace Accidents in Automotive
Repair,Workshops in Spain. Safety and Health at Work.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
j.shaw.2016.01.004
Bello Birchi Abdullahi. (2017). Exploring Polytechnic Students’ Awareness of Safety
Equipment and Precautions for Sustainable Working Environment in School
Workshops. International Journal of Science, Technology and Society. Vol. 5 (6), pp.
210-213. doi: 10.11648/j.ijsts.20170506.16
Deebom, T., Tambari & Obulor, L. (2018). Implementation of Safety Practices for Enhancing
Quality in Instructional Delivery in Electrical/Electronic Workshops in Rivers State
Technical Colleges. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Tambari
Deebom/publication/333666920f
Hrymak & Pérezgonzález (2007) Carried Out A Study On The Costs And Effects Of
Workplace Accidents. Health and Safety Authority Research Series. Retrieved from
https://www.hsa.ie/eng/Publications_and_Forms/Publications/Research_Publications/
The_costs_and_effects_of_workplace_accidents_-
_Twenty_case_studies_from_Ireland.pdfJain, R.K (2008). Production Technology
Khanna Publisher Delhi.
Onuash, S.A (2004).A Study Of Safety Practices In Selected Secondary Schools Chemistry
Laboratory In Bida Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Technical Education
Osang, J. E., Obi, E. O., &Ewona, I. O. (2013). Evaluation of the Effect of Workshop/
Laboratory Accidents and Precautionary Steps Towards Safety Practice. Journal of
Electronics and Communication Engineering. 6 (3): p. 16 – 22.
Osuala, T.C (2001). Research Methodology. African Feb Publisher Limited
30
Patizhiko, I.M (2008). The Importance of Equipment maintenance and Repair to Effective
Operation of Technical Education Institutions in Nigeria. The Gusau Journal of
Education
Qasim, M., Bashir, A., Shan, A., Malik, M., Anees, M., Ghani, U., Khalid, M., & Malik, J.
&Hanan, F. (2014). Concept of Occupational Health and Safety and Evaluation of
Awareness Level among Employees.World Applied Sciences Journal. 32. 904-909.
10.5829/idosi.wasj.2014.32.05.81132.
Rahama, S. M, Ganga, A. D, Joseph, E, etal (2004). Safety standards (Occupational laws)
Rules. An Unpublished Research Term paper of B. ED (tech) programme in the
Department of Education (Technical), Kaduna Polytechnic.
Sani etal (2000). Strategy for making instruction in Vocational/Technical Teachers Education
Sara, H.A (2004). The Concept of Industrial Safety. An unpublished Lecture Notes for B. ED
(Tech) Programme in the Department of Education (Technical), Kaduna polytechnic.
Uzoagulu, A.E. (2003). Practical Guide to write Research Project Report in Tertiary
Institution. John Jabo’s classic publisher Ltd.
Vasconcelos, B & Junior, B. (2015). The Causes of Work Place Accidents and their Relation
to Construction Equipment Design. Procedia Manufacturing. Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net
31
APPENDIX A
DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL/ELECTRONICS EDUCATION, COLLEGE OF
TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL EDUCATION, KADUNA POLYTECHNIC IN
AFFILIATION WITH FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY, MINNA.
AUTO-MECHANICS TECHNOLOGY,
BUILDING TECHNOLOGY
ELECTRICAL/ELECTRONIC
TECHNOLOGY
METAL WORK TECHNOLOGY
WOOD WORK TECHNOLOGY
YOUR REF:
OUR REF: KPT/CST/15/10136
STATE.
it would be highly appreciated if you could supply her with the necessary information she
may require from you. All information supply will be used solely for this research work and
SAMUEL BLESSING
KPT/CST/15/10136
Name of Student
APPENDIX B
32
LETTER OF VALIDATION
through and respond to the items in the questionnaire according to the best of your
Your respond will be treated with at most confidentially and will be used for the purpose of
Yours Faithfully,
Blessing Samuel
KPT/CST/15/10136
Validator's Name: _________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Signature: _________________________________________________________________
33
APPENDIX C
QUESTIONNAIRE ON
1. Teacher ( ) Student ( )
Please read the questionnaire item carefully and tick the response that best suit your
opinion on each item.
Agree (A) 3
Disagree (D) 2
34
4. No serious accidents is reported in the school for the past
three years
5. Accidents do not occur at all.
SECTION B
Research question Two: What is the Level of Safety Awareness between Staff and
Student of Government Technical Colleges in Kaduna State?
S/N ITEM SA A D SD
6. Staff and students are aware of the workshop safety rules
7. Staff and student are aware of the appropriate workshop
safety wears.
8. Staff and students are exposed to adequate safety training.
9. Students are well supervised on the observation of safety
rules
10. Staff and student are not adequately aware of accident
management issues and the use of first aid box
11. Staff and student are non-challant of the safety rules
SECTION C
Research Question Three: Method of reducing the rate of Accidents in Government
Technical Colleges in Kaduna State
S/N ITEM SA A D SD
12. Wearing of personal protective equipment
13. Never take a job for which you have not been train for.
14. Always follow safety rules of the workshop.
15. Always work according to instructors’ directives
16. Use proper tools for the job at hand.
17. Always read manufacturers instruction before usage.
18. Keep the walkway free from obstacles and moisture.
19. Train and retrain workshop attendants
20. Regular orientation on safety.
21. Place materials of safety sign in workshop
22. Turn on the current at the switch box before any repair job.
23. Avoid using equipment with damages insulator.
35