Load Flow - 2
Load Flow - 2
METHOD )
14:24
These equations provide the calculated value of net real power and net reactive
power entering bus ‘i’. The equations are non-linear and only a numerical
solution is possible. There are different methods could be implemented to solve
these equations. Among those are the Gauss-Seidel and Newton-Raphson
methods.
Gauss-Seidel Method
Consider a system of non-linear equations having “n” unknowns x1 , x 2 , .........., x n
f 1 ( x1 , x 2 , .........., x n )
f 2 ( x1 , x 2 , .........., x n )
.. .. .. .. .. ..
14:24
f n ( x1 , x 2 , .........., x n )
1
Rearranging,
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
then Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
UAE University
x i f i ( x1 , x 2 , .........., x n )
ELEC572, 04/05
Eq. 1
x1o , x 2o , .........., x no
Substituting the initial values in Eq. 1, then All values are initial values
xDr.1o A.M. o
, xGaouda o
2 , .........., x n
first iteration
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
first variable
x 1 x 11 from previous step
x f ( x , x , .........., x )
1
2 2
1 1
1
o
2
o
n
and all other values are
initial values
x 2o , .........., x no
x 31 f 31 ( x11 , x 21 , x 3o .........., x no )
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
x 1 x 11 & x 2 x 21
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
and
Or in general x 3o , .........., x no
x i1 f i 1 ( x11 , x 21 , ....., x io ,....., x no )
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
k 1
The changes inGaouda
Dr. A.M. the magnitude of each
UAE University
variable
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
x ik from its value xi
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
at
the previous iteration is:
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
x i x ik x ik 1
If x i then the solution has converged.
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
2
EXAMPLE
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
1: Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
For the following equation, find an accurate value for x up to 5 decimal places.
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
2 x log( x ) 7
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
Using Gauss-Seidel
x 0.5 ( 7 log x )
x 3.788287
3
x 0.5 ( 7 log 3.788287 ) 3.789221
4
x 5 3.789274
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
x 6 3.789278 0.000004
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
EXAMPLE
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
2: Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
For the following equations, find an ELEC572,
x and 04/05 y after 4 iterations.
UAE University
x 1 0.51111
y 1 0.51465
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
x 2 0.516497 y 2 0.510241
x 0.520211
3
Dr. A.M. Gaouda y 3 0.509722
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
x 4 0.522520
ELEC572, 04/05
y 4 0.509007
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
3
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 Gauss-Seidel Method for Load Flow Analysis
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Advantages
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
Disadvantages
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Assuming a power system in which the voltage controlled buses are absent. If the
system has n buses, then; one bus will be considered as a slack bus and the other n-1
buses are load buses Dr.(PQ-buses).
A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Using Gauss-Seidel Method, we assume the initial values for the magnitude and
phase shift angle of (n-1) buses. These values are updated at each iteration.
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
4
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
For an
ELEC572, 04/05‘n’ bus system
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
n
I i Yii Vi Yip V p ….. Eq. 3
p1
p i
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
1 n
UAE University
Vi I i Yip V p
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
….. Eq. 4
Yii p 1
p i
InDr. A.M.
power
14:24
Gaouda
systems, power is known rather than currents. The complex power
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda
injected
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
th
into the i bus is: ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Si Pi jQi Vi I *i
UAE University UAE University
….. Eq. 5ELEC572, 04/05
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Substituting inGaouda
Dr. A.M. Eq. 4 Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
1 Pi jQi n
Vi
Yii Vi*
Yip V p
….. Eq. 8
p 1
p i
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Since bus 1 is the slack bus “reference”, then Vi represents n-1 set of
equations for i= 2, 3, …., n. These equations will be solved using G-S
method for the unknowns V2, V3, …..V n.
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
5
NOTES:
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
1. Eq. 8 can be written as:
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
n Y
1 Pi jQi
NOTE
The values for P and Q
Vi
Vi*
Yii
ip
p 1 Yii
Vp ….. Eq. 9
are the scheduled Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University p i
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
values for PQ Bus. ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
n
Ki
Vi *
Lip V p ….. Eq. 10
Vi p 1
pi
P jQi Yip
Ki i and Lip
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Yii
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Yii
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
The values for Ki and Lip are computed once in the beginning and used in every
iteration.
2. The voltages at all the buses in a power system are close to 1.0 pu.
Therefore, we can start the G-S iteration process assuming
UAE Universityinitial values for the
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Vi Lip V p L
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Vp
ELEC572, 04/05 ….. Eq. 12
ip
Vi* p1 p i 1
The most updated voltage
Therefore, for the (kth+1) iteration, values are from the previous
iteration
i 1 n
Ki
Vi k 1
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
( Vi k )*
Lip V p( k 1 )
p1
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
L
pi 1
ip V pk ….. Eq. 13
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
for i 1 ,2 ,..........n
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
6
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
4. The
UAE University
ELEC572,
Dr.ith
04/05current and complex power at UAE
A.M.bus
Gaouda are:
University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05 1
2
i
Network
And Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Si Pi jQi Vi I *i
UAE University UAE University Vi
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 n
Reference
S Pi Qi V I i
*
i i
*
Or
Pi jQi Vi* ( Yi 1 V1 Yi 2 V2 ...... Yii Vi ...Yin Vn )
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
The two equations are known as the rectangular form of the load flow equations.
They provide the calculated value of net real power and net reactive power
entering bus ‘i’. Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
EXAMPLE 3:
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
G1ELEC572, 04/05
For the three bus system. Write the
ELEC572, expression
UAE University
04/05
V2* p 1
p 2
3 Y
1 P2 jQ2
2p
V2 *
Vp
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
V2 Y22 p 1 Y22
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 p 2 ELEC572, 04/05
7
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
1 P jQ2 Y21 Y
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda UAE University
V2 * 2 V1 23 V3
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
….. Eq. 15
NOTE V2 Y22 Y22 Y22
The values for P and Q
are the scheduled
values
1 P jQ3 Y31 Y
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
V3 * 3 V1 32 V2
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
….. Eq. 16
V3 Y33 Y33 Y33
Using GS method, select the initial values for the unknowns as:
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 V2o V3o 10
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
1 P2 jQ2 Y21 Y
V21 o *
V1 23 V3o ….. Eq. 17
( V2 ) Y22 Y22 Y22
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
1 P3 jQ3 Y31 Y
V31 o *
V1 32 V21
Dr. A.M. Gaouda ….. Eq. 18
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University ( V3 ) Y33 Y33 Y33
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
….. Eq. 21
| V22 | | V22 | | V21 |
….. Eq. 22
| V32 | | V32 | | V31 |
If 14:24
Eqs. 21, 22 are not satisfied then start a new iteration.
8
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
EXAMPLE
UAE University 4: Dr. A.M. Gaouda UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University ELEC572, 04/05
For the system shown in the figure, the line impedances are as indicated in per
ELEC572, 04/05
1 2
256.6
0.02 j 0.04 pu MW
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
G ELEC572, 04/05
Formulation
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 of the Bus Admittance Matrix
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
1 UAE University
2ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05 256.6
0.02 j0.04 pu
MW
1 G
y12 10 j 20 y 21 0.01 j0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
0.02 j 0.04 Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda 110.2
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
V1 1.05 0 o pu UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 MVAR
1
y13 10 j 30 y 31
0.01 j 0.03
1 3
y 23 16 j 32 y 32
0.0125 j 0.025 138.6 45.2
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
MW MVAR
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
20 j 50 10 j 20 10 j 30
Ybus 10 j 20 26 j 52 16 j 32
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda
10 j 30 ELEC572,
1604/05 j 32 26 j 62
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
9
Classification
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University of buses: Dr. A.M. Gaouda 1
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University 2 ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05 256.6
0.02 j 0.04 pu
Bus 1: Slack Bus MW
G
0.01 j 0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
V1 1.050 o pu
Dr. A.M. Gaouda V1 1.05 0 o pu Dr. A.M. Gaouda
110.2
MVAR
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
S 2 ,sch ( P2 , g P2 ,d ) j ( Q2 , g Q2 ,d )
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
( P2 , g P2 ,d ) j ( Q2 , g Q2Dr.UAE
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
,d )University
UAE University A.M. Gaouda UAE University
S 2 ,sch
ELEC572, 04/05
pu Reminder
ELEC572, 04/05
Base MVA
ELEC572, 04/05
The bus admittance matrix
is
20 j 50 10 j 20 10 j 30
( 0 256.6 ) j ( 0 110.2 )
S 2 ,sch Dr. A.M. Gaouda pu Dr. A.M. Gaouda 10 j 20 26 j 52 16 j 32
100
04/05 MVA
UAE University
ELEC572,
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
10 j 30 16 j 32 26 - j62
V 1
V1 23 V3o
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
2
o *
( V2 ) Y22 Y22 Y22
S *i ,sch Pi ,sch jQ i ,sch
1 2.566 j 1.102 10 j 20 16 j 32
V21 1.05 1 .0
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
26 j 52 26 j 52 26 j 52
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
*
( 1 .0 )
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
10
OR, to simplify the calculations, we have:
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
Reminder
n Y
1 Pi jQi
ip The bus admittance matrix
Vi Vp is
Vi* Yii Y
p 1 ii 20 j 50 10 j 20 10 j 30
p i
10 j 20 26 j 52 16 j 32
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
n
K2
UAE University UAE University
10 j 30 16 j 32 26 - j62
L2 p V p
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
V2
V2* p 1
p 2
V 2
1 K2
( V2o )*
L21 V1 L23 V3o
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University UAE University
The values for Ki and Lip are computed once in the beginning and used in every
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
iteration.
P2 jQ2 Y21 Y23
K2 L21 and L23
Y22 Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Y22 Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Y22
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
K3
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
( V3o )*
ELEC572, 04/05
Start the second iteration K 2 , K 3 , L21 , L23 , L31 , L32 constants will be the same.
V22
K2
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
1 *
( V2 )
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
L21 V1 L23 V31 VDr.22A.M.Gaouda
0.9816 j 0.0520
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
V32
K3
( V31 )*
L31 V1 L32 V22 V32 1.0008 j 0.0459
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
11
Start the third iteration
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
K 2 , K 3 ,Dr.UAE
LA.M.
21 ,Gaouda
L23 , L31 , L32 constants will be the same.ELEC572,
University
UAE University
04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
V 2
3 K2
2 *
( V2 )
L21 V1 L23 V32 = 0.9808 - j0.0578
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
K3
V33 L31 V1 L32 V23 = 1.0004 - j0.0488
( V32 )*
V24
K2
( V23 )*
L21 V1 L23 V33 = 0.9803 - j0.0594
V34
K3
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/053 *
( V3 )
L31 V1 L32 V24 Dr. A.M. Gaouda
= 1.0002 - j0.0497
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
After 7 iterations,
V27 0.9800 j 0.0600 0.98183 3.5035o pu
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
1 2
256.6
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University 0.02 j 0.04 pu Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University MW
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
G
0.01 j 0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
110.2
V1 1.050 pu o
MVAR
3
138.6 45.2
MW MVAR
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
V1 1.05 j 0.0 o pu
12
Using the rectangular form of the load
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
flow
Dr. A.M. Gaouda equations,
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
then the net active and reactive powers at04/051th bus are:
UAE University
ELEC572, Reminder
The bus admittance matrix
is
1 2
P1 4.0938 pu 0.02 j 0.04 pu
256.6
MW
Q1 1.8894 pu
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University G UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 0.01 j 004/05
ELEC572, .03 pu 0.0125 j0.025 pu
110.2
Base MVA=100 V1 1.050 o pu MVAR
P1 409.38 MVA
3
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Q1 188.94 MVA
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda 138.6 45.2 Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 MW MVAR ELEC572, 04/05
Assuming a power system has n buses, then; one bus will be considered as a
slack bus and the other buses are load buses (PQ-buses) and voltage controlled
buses (PV-buses). Let the system buses be numbered Dr.UAE
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University as: A.M. Gaouda
University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
i 2 , 3 , ..... , m PV buses
i m 1 , m 2 , ...... , n
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University PQ buses
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
The second requirement for the voltage controlled bus may be violated if the
bus voltage becomes too high or too ELEC572,
small.
University It is to be noted that we can control
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
04/05 UAE University
the bus voltage by controlling the bus reactive power.
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
13
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Therefore,
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 during any iteration, if the PV-bus reactive power violates itsELEC572,
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
limits
UAE University
04/05
NOTE
For PQ bus
And treat this bus as PQ-bus. Pi and Qi are known
& | Vi | and δi are unknown
i 1
Qi( k 1 ) | Vi |speci |Y
p1
ip || V p( k 1 ) | sin ( i( k ) p( k 1 ) ip )
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
| Vi |speci |Y
p i
|| V (k
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ip p
ELEC572, 04/05
)
| sin ( i( k ) i( k ) ip ) Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Set | Vi | | Vi | speci
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Qi ,min Qi Qi ,max
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
14
Use | Vi | speci and ik 1 For the PV-bus voltage.
Voltage magnitude is known for PV
Reset the magnitude |Vi k 1 | |Vi |Speci bus, therefore the new calculated
magnitude will not be used.
k 1
i Only the calculated angle
Vi k 1 |Vi |Speci will be updated and used.
EXAMPLE
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
6: Dr. A.M. GaoudaEach line has an impedance of 0.05+j0.15
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
1 2 0.0500 0.1500
2 3 0.0500 0.1500
2 4 0.0500 0.1500
5 3 4 0.0500 0.1500
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
G1 Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
1 5 0.0500 0.1500
G
UAE University
ELEC572, 204/05
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
4 5 0.0500 0.1500
1
The shunt admittance is neglected
Bus Data for the the 5 buses Network Before load flow solution
Load
Bus Bus VoltDr. A.M. GaoudaVolt Load Gen.Dr. A.M.Gen.
Gaouda Q Q Inject
MW
No. code Mag.ELEC572, Angle
UAE University
04/05
MVAR MW ELEC572,
MVAR
UAE University
04/05
Min. Max. MVAR
15
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda UAE University
Qmax 0.6 pu
Qmin 0.2 pu
3 4
5
G1
G2
1
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Ybus Construction
1 1
y Dr. A.M. Gaouda 2 j 6 Dr. A.M. Gaouda
z 0.05 ELEC572,
j 0.15
UAE University UAE University
04/05
2
ELEC572, 04/05
5
G1
Y11 y12 y15 4 j 12 G2
1
Y22 y 21 y 23 y 25 6 j 18
Y12 y12 2 j 6
Y33 y 32 y 34 4 j 12
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Y15 y15 2 j 6
Y44 y 43 y 45 4 j 12
Y13 Y14 0
Y55 y51 y52 y54 6 j 18
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
16
The net scheduled power injected at Dr.each
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
bus is:
A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
3 4 Load
Bus Bus Volt Volt Load Gen. Gen. Q Q Inject
MW
No. code Mag. Angle MVAR MW MVAR Min. Max. MVAR
2
1
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Slack 1.0200 0 100 Dr.50A.M. Gaouda ? ? 0 0 0
UAE University UAE University 200 ? 20 60 0
2 PV 1.0200 ? 0 0
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
5 3 PQ ? ? 50 20 0 0 0 0 0
G1
4 PQ ? ? 50 20 0 0 0 0 0
G2
1 5 PQ ? ? 50 20 0 0 0 0 0
S 1 ,sch ( P1 , g P1 ,d ) j ( Q1 , g Q1 ,d )
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
S 2 ,sch ( P2 , g P2 ,d ) j ( Q2 , g Q2 ,d )
S 2 ,sch ( 2.0 0 ) j( Q2 , g 0 )
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
S
UAE University
3 ,sch
ELEC572, 04/05 ( 0 0.5 ) j ( 0 0.2 ) ELEC572,
UAE University
04/05
V1 1.020 o
ELEC572, 04/05
4.0 - J12.0 -2.0 + J6.0 0 0 -2.0 + J6.0
-2.0 + J6.0 6.0 -J18.0 -2.0 + J6.0 0 -2.0 + J6.0
0 -2.0 + J6.0 4.0 -J12.0 -2.0 + J6.0 0
0 0 -2.0 + J6.0 4.0 -J12.0 -2.0 + J6.0
Using GS method, select the initial values for the unknowns as:
Q21 Im{ V2* ( Y21 V1 Y22 V2o Y23 V3o Y24 V4o Y25 V5o )}
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Q 0.2448
1 ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
ELEC572, 04/05
2
17
Q2 ,min Q2 Q2 ,max i .e .; 0.20 0.2448 0.6
Bus 3 is PQ Bus
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
K3
ELEC572, 04/05 UAE University ELEC572, 04/05
( V3o )*
K3
UAE University UAE University
L31
ELEC572, 04/05
L32 L34
ELEC572, 04/05
L35
Y33 Y33 Y33 Y33 Y33
K3 = -0.0275 - j0.0325 L31 = 0.0 L32 = -0.5000 L34 = -0.5000 L35 = 0.0
V41
K4
( V4o )*
L41 V1 L42 V21 L43 V31 L45 V5o
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Y42
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
Y43 Y45
P jQ4 Y L43 L45
UAE University UAE University
K4 4 L41 41
ELEC572, 04/05
L42 ELEC572, 04/05
Y44 Y44
Y44 Y44 Y44
K4 = -0.0275 - j0.0325 L41 = 0.0 L42 = 0.0 L43 = -0.5000 L45 = -0.5000
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
14:24
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
18
Bus 5 is PQ Bus
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University Dr. A.M. Gaouda UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05
K5 UAE University ELEC572, 04/05
( V5o )*
K5 = -0.0183 - 0.0217i L51 = -0.3333 L52 = -0.3333 L53 = 0.0 L54 = -0.3333
Dr. A.M. Gaouda Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Q22 Im{ V21* ( Y21 V1 Y22 V21 Y23 V31 Y24 V41 Y25 V51 )}
Q22 0.0290
The reactive power limits are violated
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
Dr. A.M. Gaouda
UAE University
ELEC572, 04/05 ELEC572, 04/05
Example 7:
1 2
400
0.02 j 0.04 pu MW
G
0.01 j 0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
250
V1 1.050 pu o
MVAR
3 | V3 | 1.04
200
MW G
14:24
19
1 2
1 400
y12 10 j 20 y 21 0.02 j0.04 pu MW
0.02 j 0.04
G
0.01 j 0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
1 250
y13 10 j 30 y 31 V1 1.050 o pu MVAR
0.01 j 0.03
1
y 23 16 j 32 y 32 3
0.0125 j 0.025 | V3 | 1.04
200
MW G
20 j 50 10 j 20 10 j 30
Ybus 10 j 20 26 j 52 16 j 32
14:24 10 j 30 16 j 32 26 j 62
Classification of buses: 1 2
400
0.02 j 0.04 pu MW
3
Bus 2: Load Bus (PQ bus) | V3 | 1.04
200
MW G
14:24
P3 ,sch 2.0 pu
20
Using GS method, select the initial values for the unknowns as:
Bus 2 is PQ Bus
n
K2
V2 *
L2 p V p
V2 p 1
p 2
V21
K2
o *
( V2 )
L21 V1 L23 V3o
K2 = - 0.0692 - j0.0423 L21 = - 0.3846 L23 = -0.6154
Bus 3 is PV Bus
V31
K3
( V3o )*
L31 V1 L32 V21
K3 = 0.0274 + j0.0208 L31 = -0.4690 + j0.0354 L32 = -0.5310 - j0.0354
14:24
21
Start the second iteration
K 2 , L21 , L23 are constants and will be the same.
Bus 2 is PQ Bus
V22
K2
( V21 )*
L21 V1 L23 V31
V22 0.9711 - j0.0434
Bus 3 is PV Bus
V32
K3
1 *
( V3 )
L31 V1 L32 V22 L31 and L32 are constants and will be the same.
K 3 is changed as Q3 change
P3 jQ32
K3 K3 = 0.0305 + j0.0194
Y33
14:24
V32 1.04 - 0.4028o 1.0400 - j0.0073
22
Newton - Raphson Method
• Newton Raphson is the most widely used method for solving simultaneous
non-linear algebraic equations.
• Assume that x(0) is a small, then the 2nd and higher order terms can be neglected.
( 0)
df
c ( 0)
c f ( x ) x ( 0 )
(0)
dx
• The second approximation will be:
c ( 0 )
x (1)
x ( 0)
x (0)
x ( 0)
( 0)
df
dx
• Successive use of the above procedure yields the Newton – Raphson
algorithm.
(k )
df
c (k )
c f ( x ) x ( k )
(k )
dx
x ( k 1) x ( k ) x ( k )
14:25
23
Example 1
Use the Newton Raphson technique to find a root of the following equation,
assume initial estimate = 6: f ( x ) x 3 6 x 2 9 x 4 0
Solution: df ( x)
3x 2 12 x 9
dx
c ( 0 ) c f ( x ( 0) ) 0 6 66 96 4 50
3 2
( 0)
df )
3(6) 2 12(6) 9 45
dx
c ( 0 ) 50
x ( 0) (0)
1.11
df 45
dx
Example 1, continue
The subsequent iterations result in:
13.4431
x ( 2 ) x (1) x (1) 4.8889 4.2789
22.037
2.9981
x (3) x ( 2 ) x ( 2 ) 4.2789 4.0405
12.5797
0.3748
x ( 4 ) x (3) x (3) 4.0405 4.0011
9.4914
14:25
24
Example 2
Use the Newton-Raphson technique to find the solution of the following
equation, Assume initial solution = 1
f ( x) x 2 2 0
Solution: df ( x)
2x
dx
c ( 0 ) c f ( x ( 0) ) 0 1 2 1 2
( 0)
df
2(1) 2
dx
c ( 0 ) 1
x ( 0 ) ( 0)
0.5
df 2
dx
x (1) x ( 0) x ( 0) 1 0.5 1.5
14:25
Example 2
c (1) 0.25
x (1) (1)
0.0833
df 3
dx
14:25
25
Newton - Raphson Method
x1
2
x
n
x
.
( 0) (0) ( 0)
f f
f n (0) f n x1
(0)
n x2 ... n xn ) cn
( 0) ( 0)
• Or in matrix form:
f ( 0) f1
( 0)
f1
( 0)
1 . ... ..
c1 f1 ( 0) x1 x2 xn
( 0)
x1( 0)
c2 f 2 f 2
( 0) ( 0) ( 0)
f 2 f 2 ( 0)
.
. ... .. x2
x1 x2 xn .
. . (0)
( 0) xn
( 0)
cn f n f ( 0) f n
(0)
f n
n
. ... ..
1
x x2 xn
Jacobian Matrix
• In short form: C (k )
J X (k ) (k )
So:
X ( k ) J ( k )
1
C ( k )
And the Newton-Raphson algorithm becomes X ( k 1) X ( k ) X ( k )
14:25
26
Example 3
Use the Newton Raphson method to solve the following system of equations,
assume initial estimate = 1:
2 2 2
x1 x2 x3 11
2
x1 x2 x2 3 x3 3
Solution:
x1 x1 x3 x2 x3 6
Example 3 ,continue
2(1) - 2(1) 2(1) 2 -2 2
J (0)
(1) (1) 2(1) 3 1 3 3
1 (1) (1) - (1) (1) 0 1 0
4.75 5.75
X ( 0)
J 0 1
C ( 0)
5.00 And X (1)
X (0)
X (0)
6.00
5.25 6.25
And the process continues till the error is within certain limits.
14:25
27
Example 4
Use the Newton Raphson method to solve the following system of equations,
assume initial estimate = 1:
f1 ( x) 2 x12 x22 8 0
f 2 ( x) x12 x22 x1 x2 4 0
Solution:
f1 f1
x1 x2 4 x1 2 x2
J 2 x x
f 2 x1 2 x2
f 2 1 2
x1 x2
4(1) - 2(1) 4 2
J (0)
2(1) 1 1 - 2(1) 3 - 1
14:25
Example 4-continue
1
4 2 1 - 1 2 0.1 0.2
J ( 0 )1
3 -1 4 6 - 3 4 0.3 - 0.4
c1 f1 ( 0) 5
C ( 0 )
c2 f 2 3
(0)
X ( 0 ) J 0
1 1.1
C ( 0 ) And
2.1
X (1) X ( 0) X ( 0)
0.3 1.3
And the process continues till the error is within certain limits.
14:25
28
Newton - Raphson Method for power system
• As previously derived:
n
Pi | Vi | | Yip || V p | cos ( i p ip ) (1)
p 1
n
Qi | Vi | | Yip || V p | sin ( i p ip ) (2)
p 1
We have two equations for each load bus and one equation for each
voltage controlled bus.
14:25
• Expanding the previous equations using Taylor’s series and neglecting all
higher order terms results in the following:
P ( k ) P2
(k )
P2
(k )
P2
(k )
2 ... .. ... ..
2 n
V
2
V
n
P2 .
(k ) . . .
2 ( k )
. . .
.
. .
(k )
. P ( k ) Pn
(k )
Pn
(k )
.
( k ) n ... .. ... .. Pn
Pn 2 V V ( k )
n 2 n n
(3)
.
Q ( k ) (k )
V
(k ) (k ) (k ) ( )
Q2
k
Q2 Q2
... .. Q2 2
2
.
2 ... .. V V .
n 2 n
. . . . . .
Q ( k ) (k )
n . . . . Vn
(k ) (k )
Qn
(k )
(k )
P J1 J 2
Or in short
14:25 Q J
J 4 V
3
29
Newton - Raphson Method for power system
• The terms Pi and Qi are the difference between the scheduled and
calculated values. Therefore: (k )
Pi Pi Pi
sch (k ) (4)
(k ) (k )
Qi Qi Qi
sch
(5)
Note:
For voltage controlled buses, the voltage magnitudes are known. Therefore,
if m buses of the system are voltage controlled, m equations involving Q
and V and the corresponding columns of the Jacobian matrix are
eliminated.
14:25
1. For load buses, voltage magnitudes and angles are set. For voltage
regulated buses, only the voltage angles are set.
2. For load buses, P and Q and for voltage controlled P are calculated
from the equations 4 and 5.
3. The elements of the Jacobian matrix are calculated.
4. The linear equations are solved by optimally ordered triangular
factorization and Gaussian elimination.
5. The new voltage magnitudes and phases are computed using equations 6
and 7.
6. The process is continued until:
(k )
Pi
(k )
Qi
14:25
30
Example 5:
The line impedances are as indicated in per unit on 100MVA base. Using Newton
Raphson method find the power flow solution of the system.
1 2
400
0.02 j 0.04 pu MW
G
0.01 j 0.03 pu 0.0125 j 0.025 pu
250
V1 1.050 o pu MVAR
3 | V3 | 1.04
200
MW G
14:25
The expressions for the real and reactive power are as follows:
3
P2 | V2 | | Y2 p | | V p | cos ( 2 p 2 p )
p 1
2
P2 V2 V1 Y21 cos( 2 1 21 ) V2 Y22 cos( 22 ) V2 V3 Y23 cos( 2 3 23 )
3
P3 V3 | Y3 p | | V p | cos ( 3 p 3 p )
p 1
2
P3 V3 V1 Y31 cos( 3 1 31 ) V3 V2 Y32 cos( 3 2 32 ) V3 Y31 cos( 33 )
3
Q2 | V2 | | Y2 p | | V p | sin ( 2 p 2 p )
p 1
2
Q2 V2 V1 Y21 sin( 2 1 21 ) V2 Y22 sin( 22 ) V2 V3 Y21 sin( 2 3 23 )
2
Q2 V2 V1 Y21 sin( 2 1 21 ) V2 Y22 sin( 22 ) V2 V3 Y21 sin( 2 3 23 )
14:25
31
P2 P2 P2
2 3 V2
P P3 P3
The Jacobian Matrix J 3
2 3 V2
Q Q2 Q2
2
2 3 V2
P2
V2 V1 Y21 sin( 21 2 1 ) V2 V3 Y23 sin( 23 2 3 )
2
P2
V2 V3 Y23 sin( 23 2 3 )
3
P2
V1 Y21 cos( 21 2 1 ) 2 V2 Y22 cos( 22 ) V3 Y23 cos( 23 2 3 )
V2
Classification of buses: 1 2
400
0.02 j 0.04 pu MW
3
Bus 2: Load Bus (PQ bus) | V3 | 1.04
200
MW G
14:25
P3 ,sch 2.0 pu
32
Using N-R method, select the initial values for the unknowns as:
2o 0o 3o 0 o
( 0) (0)
P2 P2 P2 4.0 (1.14) 2.86
sch
(0) (0)
P3 P2 P3 2.0 (0.5616) 1.4384
sch
( 0) (0)
Q2 Q2 Q2 2.5 (2.28) 0.220
sch
14:25
24.86 2
( 0)
2.86 54.28 33.28
1.4384 33.28
16.64 3
( 0)
66.04
0.22 27.14 16.64 49.72 V ( 0)
2
(0) (1)
V2 0.026548 V2 1 (0.026548) 0.97345
14:25
This is the end of the fist iteration, the process will be repeated for the second iteration and so on.
33
Example 6:
For the two bus power system shown below, use the Newton-Raphson power
flow to determine the voltage magnitude and angle at bus two. Assume
that bus one is the slack and SBase = 100 MVA.
Line Z = 0.1j
0 MW 200 MW
0 MVR 100 MVR
14:25
Example 6-solution:
P2 | V2 | 10 | sin ( 2 ) 0
2
Q2 | V2 | | Y2 p | | V p | sin ( 2 p 2 p )
p 1
34
Example 6-solution:
P2 P2
V2
The Jacobian Matrix
J
2
Q2 Q2
2 V2
1
0 10 0 2 0.2
X (1)
1 0 10 1 0.9
This is the end of the fist iteration, the process will be repeated for the second iteration and so on.
14:25
14:25
35
14:25
14:25
36
14:25
14:25
37
14:25
14:25
38
THE DECOUPLED POWER-FLOW METHOD
Approximate Version of Newton Raphson Procedure
Based on
Change in the voltage angle at a bus primarily
affects the flow of real power P in the
transmission lines and leaves the flow of reactive
power Q relatively un changed.
Change in the voltage magnitude V at a bus
primarily affects the flow of reactive power Q in
the transmission lines and leaves the flow of real
14:25
power P relatively un changed.
14:25
39