Bus Bar Switching Schemes
Bus Bar Switching Schemes
https://50hz-academia.com 1
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Introduction
https://50hz-academia.com 2
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Concept of Power System
https://50hz-academia.com 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
What is Sub Station ?
DISTRIBUTION BOARD
https://50hz-academia.com 5
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
TR. LINE TR. LINE
General Arrangement
(INCOMER / OUTGOING) (INCOMER)
LIGHTNING ARRESTOR
CAP. VOLTAGE TRANSFORMER POWER
TRANSFORMER
WAVE TRAP
SUB
CURRENT TRANSFORMER STATION
EARTH SWITCH
ISOLATOR POTENTIAL
TRANSFORMER
CIRCUIT BREAKER
BUS
BAR ISOLATOR
https://50hz-academia.com 6
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Single Bus Bar Scheme
Faulty
BUS BAR
Faulty
https://50hz-academia.com 7
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
SINGLE BUS BAR (UPTO 33kV SS)
Advantages
Lowest cost
Small land area required
Easily expandable
Simple in concept and operation
Disadvantages
Lowest reliability
Failure of a circuit breaker causes loss of the feeder
Bus fault causes loss of the entire substation
https://50hz-academia.com 8
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Improvement
Main Disadvantage ?
Loss of the entire Sub Station in case of Bus fault.
Requirement ?
Avoid loss of entire bus i.e., entire Sub Station in Bus
fault.
How to Achieve ?
By Sectionalizing the Single Bus Bar.
Arrangement ?
Sectionalisation of Single Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 9
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Sectionalization of Single Bus Bar Scheme
Faulty
Faulty
SECTIONALIZING CB
https://50hz-academia.com 10
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
SECTIONALIZATION BUS BAR (33kV & 66kV SS)
Advantages
Flexible operation
Higher reliability than single bus scheme
Isolation of bus sections for maintenance
Loss of only part of the substation for a bus fault
Disadvantages
Loss of circuit for breaker failure
A sectionalized bus arrangement has a higher cost
than a single bus scheme as additional circuit breaker
and isolators are required for sectionalizing
https://50hz-academia.com 11
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Improvement
Main Disadvantage ?
Circuit Breaker failures are more than Bus fault. Thus,
we loose important feeder in case of Circuit Breaker
outage.
Requirement ?
Avoid loss of important circuit in case of Circuit
Breaker outage.
How to Achieve ?
By by-passing the faulty circuit breaker.
Arrangement ?
Main and Transfer Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 12
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Main and Transfer Bus Bar Scheme
TRANSFER BUS
COUPLER (TBC)
Faulty
MAIN BUS I
Faulty
TRANSFER BUS
https://50hz-academia.com 13
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
MAIN & TRANSFER BUS BAR (132kV SS)
Advantages
Circuit breaker outage / maintenance does not disrupt
the service of feeder / circuit
Reasonable in cost
Fairly small land area
Easily expandable
Disadvantages
Bus Fault causes disruption of service of entire sub
station
An additional circuit breaker is required for bus tie
https://50hz-academia.com 14
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Improvement
Main Disadvantage ?
Bus fault in a sub station having more nos. of circuits
causes greater interruption of power. In Main and
Transfer Bus Bar arrangement bus fault results loss of
entire sub station i.e., all circuits.
Requirement ?
Avoid loss of too many circuits in case of bus fault.
How to Achieve ?
By providing another Main Bus for connection of
circuits.
Arrangement ?
Double Main Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 15
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Double Main
Single Bus
Bus Bar Scheme
Scheme Mode
Faulty
MAIN BUS I
MAIN BUS II
Faulty https://50hz-academia.com 16
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
DOUBLE MAIN BUS BAR (220kV SS)
Advantages
Bus Bar outage / maintenance does not disrupt the
service of any feeder / circuit
Reasonable in cost
Fairly small land area
Easily expandable
Disadvantages
Circuit Breaker outage causes disruption of service of
that feeder
https://50hz-academia.com 17
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Main Disadvantage ? Improvement
Double Main Bus arrangement is an alternative to
Main & Transfer Bus scheme. In both cases, the
investment is same. The only difference is that in
Double Main Bus the outage of Bus Bar and in Main &
Transfer Bus the outage of Breaker is prioritized.
Interruption of Power during Isolator operation.
Requirement ?
Both Bus fault and Circuit Breaker outage are to be
taken care off.
How to Achieve ?
By using one of the Main Buses as “Main Cum Transfer
Bus”.
Arrangement ?
Double Main Cum Transfer Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 18
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Main
Double and
Main Transfer
Cum Single BusBus
Transfer Scheme Mode
Bar Scheme
SUB STATION POWER STATION LOAD CENTRE
BUS I CUM
TRANSFER
Faulty
Faulty
BC
BUS II
https://50hz-academia.com 19
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
DOUBLE MAIN CUM TRANSFER BUS BAR (220kV SS)
Advantages
Bus Bar outage / maintenance does not disrupt the
service of any feeder / circuit
Circuit Breaker outage does not cause disruption of
service of that feeder
Reasonable in cost
Fairly small land area
Easily expandable
Disadvantages
Additional Isolator in each circuit increases the cost
https://50hz-academia.com 20
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Improvement
Main Disadvantage ?
Double Main Cum Transfer Bus Bar arrangement
outage of Circuit Breaker and Bus together causes loss
of faulty Circuit Breaker feeder.
Interruption of Power.
Requirement ? during Isolator Operation
Avoid loss of feeder in case of simultaneous outage of
Circuit Breaker and a Main Bus.
How to Achieve ?
By providing separate transfer Bus along with Double
Main Buses.
Arrangement ?
Double Main and Transfer Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 21
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Double Main
Mainand Transfer
and
Single BusBus
Transfer Bar Scheme
Scheme
Scheme Mode
Mode
INTERRUPTION
BUS I
BUS II
Faulty
Faulty TBC
https://50hz-academia.com 22
TRANSFER BUS Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
DOUBLE MAIN AND TRANSFER BUS BAR (220kV SS)
Advantages
Bus Bar outage / maintenance does not disrupt the
service of any feeder / circuit
Circuit Breaker outage does not cause disruption of
service of that feeder
Maintenance of Bus and CB does not interrupt supply
Disadvantages
Additional Isolator and Circuit Breaker required for
transfer Bus tie.
https://50hz-academia.com 23
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Improvement
Main Disadvantage ?
Interruption of Power during Isolator operation.
Interruption of Power is likely to cause major
disturbance if the feeders are important and heavily
loaded.
Requirement ?
Avoid interruption of important and heavily loaded
feeders during bus fault or outage of Circuit Breaker.
How to Achieve ?
By connection of circuits for double feed through
Circuit Breakers and avoid Isolator switching.
Arrangement ?
One and a Half Breaker Bus Bar Arrangement.
https://50hz-academia.com 24
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
One and a Half Breaker Bus Bar Scheme
POWER STATION
BUS I BUS II
LOAD CENTRE
Faulty https://50hz-academia.com 28
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Advantage & Disadvantage
DOUBLE BREAKER BUS BAR (Mega Generating Units)
Advantages
Flexible operation
Very high reliability
Isolation of either main bus for maintenance without
disrupting service
Isolation of any circuit breaker for maintenance
without disrupting service
Double feed to each circuit
No interruption of service to any circuits from bus
fault
Loss of only one circuit for breaker failure
All switching with circuit breakers
Disadvantages
This configuration carries a high cost
Two circuit breakers are required for each circuit.
https://50hz-academia.com 29
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
PHOTOGRAPHS
https://50hz-academia.com 30
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
BUS
BAR
https://50hz-academia.com 31
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
https://50hz-academia.com 32
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
https://50hz-academia.com 33
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
CAPACITOR VOLTAGE
LIGHTNING ARRESTER TRANSFORMER
https://50hz-academia.com 34
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
https://50hz-academia.com 35
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
TRANSFORMER
https://50hz-academia.com 36
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
REACTOR
https://50hz-academia.com 37
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
Photographs
SUB STATION
https://50hz-academia.com 38
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
LAYOUT & SECTION
https://50hz-academia.com 39
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 1
A B
CL-LA CL-TFR.
CL-CVT
CL-WT CL-LA
CL-CT
CL-ISO
CL-CB
CL-ISO
A B
https://50hz-academia.com
40
SLIDE : 1 of 3
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 1
Earth Wire
Gantry
SECTION - AA
https://50hz-academia.com 41
SLIDE : 2 of 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 1
SECTION - BB
https://50hz-academia.com 42
SLIDE : 3 of 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
A B
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 2
CL-LA CL-TFR.
CL-CVT
CL-WT CL-LA
CL-CT
CL-ISO
CL-CB
CL-ISO
CL-ISO
https://50hz-academia.com 43
A SLIDE : 1 of 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
B
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 2
Earth Wire
Gantry
SECTION - AA
https://50hz-academia.com 44
SLIDE : 2 of 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
DRAWING – EXAMPLE : 2
Earth Wire
Gantry
SECTION - BB
https://50hz-academia.com 45
SLIDE : 3 of 3
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
https://50hz-academia.com 46
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
QUESTION
https://50hz-academia.com 47
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
QUESTION
What are the limitations of Main & Transfer Bus Bar
Scheme ?
How does Double Main Bus Scheme differ from Main &
Transfer Bus Arrangement ?
What is the difference between Double Main Bus and
Double Main Cum Transfer Bus Arrangement ?
What is the Bus Bar Arrangement for Sub Station having
voltage class 400kV & above ?
What is the advantages of One and a half Breaker Bus
Bar Scheme ?
What is the advantage & Disadvantage of Two Breaker
Bus Bar Scheme and where the same is used ?
https://50hz-academia.com 48
Project experienced Based Advanced Power System & Electrical Industry Relevant Courses
QUESTION